妇科急诊质量与安全测量框架提案
本研究在法国和比利时的妇科急诊科开展混合方法多中心研究,先用改良德尔菲法确定8种潜在危及生命的妇科急症和17条近失误标准,再通过前瞻性病例队列研究评估其发生率。3825名急性盆腔痛女性中130名(3%)存在潜在危及生命的状况,最常见为异位妊娠伴严重出血(54例,42%)。这些患者的诊断错误率更高,近失误标准也更常见,提示该框架可用于急诊质量改进。
要点
- 改良德尔菲法确定了8种潜在危及生命的妇科急症和17条近失误标准。
- 急性盆腔痛女性中潜在危及生命急症的发生率为3%(130/3825)。
- 潜在危及生命急症患者的诊断错误率和近失误发生率显著更高。
核心结论
- 潜在危及生命的妇科急症是高危情况,可作为改善急诊质量与安全的框架。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法多中心研究,在法国和比利时的妇科急诊科开展。
- 2014年采用改良德尔菲法确定潜在危及生命的状况和近失误标准。
- 2015年春季前瞻性病例队列研究评估潜在危及生命急症和近失误的发生率。
- 研究对象为因急性盆腔痛就诊的育龄女性,病例组来自21个参与中心,对照组包括非潜在危及生命急症住院女性和10%随机门诊女性样本。
主要发现
- 德尔菲法确定了8种妇科急症和17条近失误标准。
- 3825名急性盆腔痛女性中,130名(3%)存在潜在危及生命的状况。
- 最常见诊断为异位妊娠伴严重出血(54例,42%)、复杂性盆腔炎性疾病(30例,23%)、附件扭转(20例,15%)、出血性流产(15例,12%)和严重阑尾炎(6例,5%)。
- 潜在危及生命急症女性的诊断错误率高于住院对照组(OR 1.7,95% CI 1.1-2.7)和门诊对照组(OR 14.7,95% CI 8.1-26.8)。
- 潜在危及生命状况女性中26例符合近失误标准,而非潜在危及生命状况女性中仅6例符合(OR 25.6,95% CI 10.9-70.7)。
关键数值与推荐
- 潜在危及生命的妇科急症包括异位妊娠伴严重出血、复杂性盆腔炎性疾病、附件扭转、出血性流产和严重阑尾炎等8种。
- 近失误标准共17条。
- 潜在危及生命急症的发生率为3%(130/3825)。
临床怎么用
- 该框架可用于急诊科审计妇科急诊的质量与安全。
- 识别潜在危及生命的妇科急症和近失误标准有助于改进急诊诊疗流程。
局限性
- 研究仅在法国和比利时的妇科急诊科进行,外推性可能受限。
- 德尔菲法确定的组合和标准可能需要进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To define and assess the prevalence of potentially life-threatening gynecologic emergencies among women presenting for acute pelvic pain for the purpose of developing measures to audit quality of care in emergency departments. METHODS: We conducted a mixed-methods multicenter study at gynecologic emergency departments in France and Belgium. A modified Delphi procedure was first conducted in 2014 among health care professionals to define relevant combinations of potentially life-threatening conditions and near misses in the field of gynecologic emergency care. A prospective case-cohort study in the spring of 2015 then assessed the prevalence of these potentially life-threatening emergencies and near misses among women of reproductive age presenting for acute pelvic pain. Women in the case group were identified at 21 participating centers. The control group consisted of a sample of women hospitalized for acute pelvic pain not caused by a potentially life-threatening condition and a 10% random sample of outpatients. RESULTS: Eight gynecologic emergencies and 17 criteria for near misses were identified using the Delphi procedure. Among the 3,825 women who presented for acute pelvic pain, 130 (3%) were considered to have a potentially life-threatening condition. The most common diagnoses were ectopic pregnancies with severe bleeding (n=54; 42%), complex pelvic inflammatory disease (n=30; 23%), adnexal torsion (n=20; 15%), hemorrhagic miscarriage (n=15; 12%), and severe appendicitis (n=6; 5%). The control group comprised 225 hospitalized women and 381 outpatients. Diagnostic errors occurred more frequently among women with potentially life-threatening emergencies than among either hospitalized (odds ratio [OR] 1.7, 95% CI 1.1-2.7) or outpatient (OR 14.7, 95% CI 8.1-26.8) women in the control group. Of the women with potentially life-threatening conditions, 26 met near-miss criteria compared with six with not potentially life-threatening conditions (OR 25.6, 95% CI 10.9-70.7). CONCLUSIONS: Potentially life-threatening gynecologic emergencies are high-risk conditions that may serve as a useful framework to improve quality and safety in emergency care.
引用
- Fauconnier A, Provot J, Le Creff I, et al. A Framework Proposal for Quality and Safety Measurement in Gynecologic Emergency Care. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 33030878. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000004132
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。