生殖医学中的随访:伦理探讨
该研究通过文献研究和比利时布鲁塞尔及荷兰马斯特里赫特学术医疗中心的经验,分析辅助生殖技术(ART)后出生儿童随访研究的伦理问题。主要伦理问题包括不可避免的负担与风险的比例性以及尊重自主性原则,尤其涉及无行为能力儿童时应确保负担和风险不超过最小限度。
要点
- 欧洲人类生殖与胚胎学会建议将ART后代的随访(理想为长期)作为引入新ART的组成部分。
- 随访面临资金等实际障碍,以及确保家庭参与和获得知情同意的挑战。
- 对无行为能力儿童,研究负担和风险不应超过最小限度且无合理预期受益。
核心结论
- 从伦理角度看,最相关的问题包括ART后家庭不可避免的负担和风险的比例性以及尊重自主性原则。
- 比例性要求对无行为能力儿童最为关键,若无合理预期受益,其研究负担和风险不应超过最小限度。
- 在尊重自主性下,当寻求符合比例性条件的随访研究自愿同意时,专业人员可鼓励ART家庭参与。
研究设计与样本
- 文献研究结合比利时布鲁塞尔和荷兰马斯特里赫特学术医疗中心的相关经验,以识别和分析最相关的伦理问题。
主要发现
- 根据欧洲人类生殖与胚胎学会建议,医学辅助生殖(MAR) conceived儿童的随访(理想为长期)应成为引入新ART的组成部分。
- 随着潜在风险的新ART出现,这些建议需更认真对待。
- 随访的挑战包括资金等实际障碍,以及确保MAR家庭积极参与并从年幼儿童父母开始,理想情况下包括同意的青少年和成人在其大部分生活中参与,甚至可能涉及下一代。
关键数值与推荐
- ESHRE建议:MAR conceived儿童的随访(理想为长期)应作为引入新ART的组成部分。
- 比例性要求:对无行为能力儿童,若无合理预期受益,研究负担和风险不应超过最小限度。
临床怎么用
- 在引入新ART时,应将长期随访作为组成部分认真考虑。
- 设计随访研究时需评估负担和风险的比例性,尤其对无行为能力儿童。
- 在符合比例性条件时,可鼓励ART家庭自愿参与随访研究。
局限性
- 基于文献研究和两个学术医疗中心的经验,可能不全面代表所有中心。
- 未报告具体样本量、数值或统计结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What ethical implications, issues and concerns play a role in conducting follow-up studies of children born after assisted reproductive technologies (ART)? DESIGN: Literature study and relevant experiences of academic medical centres in Brussels, Belgium, and Maastricht, the Netherlands were used to identify and analyse the most pertinent ethical implications, issues and concerns. RESULTS: According to recommendations from the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology, follow-up (ideally long term) of children conceived through medically assisted reproduction (MAR) should be an integral part of introducing new ART. With potentially risky new ART on the horizon, these recommendations need to be taken more seriously. Apart from practical barriers, such as funding, challenges for follow-up include securing active involvement of families of children conceived through MAR, starting with parents of young children, and ideally involving consenting adolescents and adults during a large part of their lives, possibly even into the next generation. CONCLUSIONS: From an ethical viewpoint, the most pertinent issues include the proportionality of the inevitable burdens and risks for families of children conceived through MAR, and the implications of the principle of respect for autonomy. The proportionality requirement is most critical when it concerns incompetent children, who should not be included in research with more than minimal burdens and risks if there is no reasonable expectation of benefit for themselves. With respect for autonomy, we argue that, when seeking voluntary consent for participating in follow-up studies that meet the condition of proportionality, professionals may encourage members of families of children conceived through MAR to partake in follow-up research.
引用
- Jans V, Dondorp W, Bonduelle M, et al. Follow-up in the field of reproductive medicine: an ethical exploration. Reprod Biomed Online. 2020. PMID: 32967810. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2020.08.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。