胚胎捐赠的伦理:剩余胚胎捐赠与双配子捐赠的道德异同
随着辅助生殖技术中对捐赠胚胎的需求增加,本文探讨剩余胚胎捐赠与双配子捐赠的伦理可接受性。作者认为两种形式均不存在压倒性反对理由,但应满足咨询条件,且结论主要来自单配子捐赠家庭的实证研究,需对这两类家庭进一步研究。
要点
- 剩余胚胎捐赠与双配子捐赠均尊重患者生殖自主权,无压倒性伦理反对理由。
- 实证研究表明遗传联系并非亲子关爱关系的必要条件。
- 咨询应涵盖剩余胚胎去向、早期披露、信息交换与联系期待。
核心结论
- 作者认为剩余胚胎捐赠与双配子捐赠均不存在压倒性反对理由,患者与临床医生应讨论哪种辅助生殖技术形式适合其具体情况。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为伦理分析论文,探讨剩余胚胎捐赠与双配子捐赠的伦理可接受性,结论主要来自单配子捐赠家庭的实证研究结果。
主要发现
- 辅助生殖技术使用捐赠胚胎通过允许患者体验妊娠亲职而尊重其生殖自主权,也为体外受精患者提供除丢弃或捐给研究外的额外选择。
- 大量实证研究表明亲子遗传联系并非关爱关系的前提条件。
- 植入前胚胎的低道德地位不意味着诊所有道德义务优先使用现有剩余胚胎或通过双配子捐赠防止产生更多剩余胚胎。
- 没有理由认为知晓有遗传相关者生活在别处会对捐赠者受孕后代、捐赠者现有子女及其各自家庭的福祉产生不可接受的影响。
关键数值与推荐
- 对体外受精患者的咨询应涉及潜在剩余胚胎的去向讨论。
- 对捐赠者和接受者的咨询应讨论早期披露孩子受孕方式的重要性、孩子在无遗传联系家庭中成长的影响、以及对捐赠者与接受者家庭或遗传相关兄弟姐妹之间信息交换与联系的期待。
临床怎么用
- 患者和临床医生应讨论哪种辅助生殖技术形式适合其具体情况,以确保伦理上合理的捐赠胚胎辅助生殖技术。
局限性
- 结论主要来自单配子捐赠家庭的实证研究结果。
- 需对通过剩余胚胎捐赠或双配子捐赠创建的家庭进行更多实证研究以评估其福祉。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Over the years, the demand for ART with donated embryos has increased. Treatment can be performed using donated 'surplus embryos' from IVF treatment or with embryos intentionally created through so-called 'double gamete donation'. Embryo donation is particularly sensitive because treatment results in the absence of a genetic link between the parent(s) and the child, creating complex family structures, including full genetic siblings living in another family in the case of surplus embryo donation. In this paper, we explore the ethical acceptability of embryo donation in light of the similarities and differences between surplus embryo donation and double gamete donation. We will argue that no overriding objections to either form of embryo donation exist. First of all, ART with donated embryos respects patients' reproductive autonomy by allowing them to experience gestational parenthood. It also respects IVF patients' reproductive autonomy by providing an additional option to discarding or donating surplus embryos to research. Second, an extensive body of empirical research has shown that a genetic link between parent and child is not a condition for a loving caring relationship between parent(s) and child. Third, the low moral status of a pre-implantation embryo signifies no moral duty for clinics to first use available surplus embryos or to prevent the development of (more) surplus embryos through double gamete donation. Fourth, there is no reason to assume that knowledge of having (full or half) genetically related persons living elsewhere provides an unacceptable impact on the welfare of donor-conceived offspring, existing children of the donors, and their respective families. Thus, patients and clinicians should discuss which form of ART would be suitable in their specific situation. To guarantee ethically sound ART with donated embryos certain conditions have to be met. Counselling of IVF patients should involve a discussion on the destination of potential surplus embryos. When counselling donors and recipient(s) a discussion of the significance of early disclosure of the child's mode of conception, the implications of having children raised in families with whom they share no genetic ties, expectations around information-exchange and contact between donor and recipient families or genetically related siblings is warranted. Importantly, conclusions are mainly drawn from results of empirical studies on single gamete donation families. To evaluate the welfare of families created through surplus embryo donation or double gamete donation additional empirical research on these particular families is warranted.
引用
- Huele EH, Kool EM, Bos AME, et al. The ethics of embryo donation: what are the moral similarities and differences of surplus embryo donation and double gamete donation? Hum Reprod. 2020. PMID: 32772101. doi:10.1093/humrep/deaa166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。