剖宫产时输卵管切除术与输卵管阻断用于永久避孕:结局与医生态度
回顾性队列联合问卷调查,比较剖宫产时输卵管切除术与输卵管阻断的临床结局及医生态度。共363例,输卵管切除术116例(32%),输卵管阻断247例(68%)。输卵管切除术平均手术时间增加6.5分钟(p=.001),但术后症状性贫血和感染更少。医生对输卵管切除术无明显偏见,但该术式并非主流。
要点
- 剖宫产时输卵管切除术较输卵管阻断平均手术时间增加6.5分钟(p=.001)。
- 输卵管阻断组术后症状性贫血(5.7% vs 0.9%)和感染(6.9% vs 1.7%)多于输卵管切除术组。
- 医生认为输卵管切除术的获益(降低癌症风险)与风险相当或更大,但该术式未占主导。
核心结论
- 与输卵管结扎相比,剖宫产时输卵管切除术增加手术时间但不增加围手术期发病率。
- 医生似乎对输卵管切除术无偏见,并了解已发表的获益与风险,但该术式并非主要手术方式。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究联合问卷调查,地点为俄亥俄州辛辛那提一家私立医院。
- 研究对象为2016年1月至2017年12月期间在剖宫产时接受永久避孕的18岁及以上女性,共363例,其中输卵管切除术116例(32%),输卵管阻断247例(68%)。
- 通过现行操作术语代码识别研究对象,病历回顾采集人口学、手术细节和围手术期发病率指标。
- 对研究人群医生进行在线问卷调查,评估其对输卵管切除术的态度。
主要发现
- 尽管队列人口学相似,输卵管切除术较输卵管阻断平均手术时间增加6.5分钟(p=.001)。
- 输卵管阻断组术后症状性贫血发生率5.7%,输卵管切除术组0.9%;输卵管阻断组感染发生率6.9%,输卵管切除术组1.7%。
- logistic回归显示,主刀医生是预测输卵管切除术的最强因素(p<.001)。
- 30名医生中23名(77%)完成问卷,这些医生实施了80%的手术;医生性别、年龄、执业年限、独立执业与团体执业、医院雇佣与私人执业与其输卵管切除术数量或比例无差异。
- 降低癌症风险是医生认为最常见的输卵管切除术获益(23名中17名,74%);65%认为输卵管切除术带来额外风险,但70%认为获益等于或大于风险;完成问卷的23名医生中20名(87%)认为输卵管切除术不增加额外手术时间且成本中性。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: Compare clinical outcomes and physician attitudes toward tubal occlusion and salpingectomy during cesarean section. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study with survey. SETTING: Private hospital in Cincinnati, Ohio. PATIENTS: Women aged ≥18 years undergoing permanent contraception during cesarean delivery with and without salpingectomy from January 2016 to December 2017. INTERVENTIONS: Rate measurements of permanent contraception during cesarean section by salpingectomy versus tubal occlusion. Online survey assessment of study population physicians' attitudes toward salpingectomy. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Study subjects identified using Current Procedural Terminology codes. Subject demographics, operative details, and perioperative morbidity indicators were identified by chart review. A total of 363 subjects were included: 116 (32%) had salpingectomies, and 247 (68%) had tubal occlusions. Study variables were compared using Wilcoxon rank sum and Fisher exact tests. Despite similar cohort demographics, salpingectomy increased mean operative time by 6.5 minutes compared with tubal occlusion (p = .001). Compared with subjects who had a salpingectomy, those who had a tubal occlusion had more postoperative symptomatic anemia (5.7% vs 0.9%) and infection (6.9% vs 1.7%). The primary surgeon was identified by logistic regression as the factor most predictive of salpingectomy (p <.001). Of 30 physicians, 23 (77%) completed the survey, and these physicians performed 80% of procedures. Physicians did not differ by sex, age, years of practice, solo vs group practice, or hospital-employed vs private practice when compared with the number or rate of salpingectomies performed. Cancer risk reduction was the most common physician-identified salpingectomy benefit (17 of 23, 74%). A total of 65% believed that salpingectomy posed additional risks, but 70% believed the benefits were equal to or greater than the risks. Of the 23 (87%) who completed the survey, 20 believed that salpingectomy added no additional operative time and was cost-neutral. CONCLUSION: Relative to tubal ligation, salpingectomy during cesarean section increases operative time but not perioperative morbidity. Physicians do not seem biased against salpingectomy and express awareness of published benefits and risks, yet it is not the dominant surgical approach.
引用
- Levy D, Casey S, Zemtsov G, et al. Salpingectomy versus Tubal Occlusion for Permanent Contraception during Cesarean Delivery: Outcomes and Physician Attitudes. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32745622. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2020.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。