宫腔止血囊联合腹主动脉临时阻断术用于胎盘植入性疾病产妇的随机对照试验
在南京鼓楼医院开展的开放随机对照试验中,胎盘植入性疾病产妇在胎儿娩出后止血困难时随机接受宫腔止血囊或纱条填塞联合腹主动脉临时阻断,止血囊组止血成功率100%(81/81)显著高于纱条组88%(70/80,P=0.001),纱条组产后出血≥1000 ml比例及母体不良事件更高。
要点
- 止血囊组止血成功率100%(81/81),显著高于纱条组88%(70/80,P=0.001)。
- 纱条组产后出血≥1000 ml者占69%(55/80),多于止血囊组47%(38/81,P=0.006)。
- 纱条组产后贫血、产褥病率和术后疼痛评分均高于止血囊组。
核心结论
- 在胎盘植入性疾病剖宫产术中,止血囊和纱条宫腔填塞都能有效用于胎盘娩出后的止血,但宫腔止血囊比纱条止血效果更好、并发症少。
- 取出宫腔纱条时,要做好防治大出血的准备。
研究设计与样本
- 开放标签随机对照试验,在南京鼓楼医院开展,2015年8月至2018年1月招募疑为胎盘植入性疾病计划保留子宫的孕妇。
- 胎儿娩出后腹主动脉球囊临时阻断及必要时压迫缝合仍不能止血时,按1∶1随机分为止血囊组(n=81)和纱条组(n=80)。
- 主要结局为避免二线手术的止血成功率,次要结局包括剖宫产术围术期出血量和出血率、输血、子宫切除、术后疼痛、ICU入住、住院时间、再入院和放射介入相关并发症。
主要发现
- 止血囊组止血成功率100%(81/81),显著高于纱条组88%(70/80,P=0.001)。
- 宫腔填塞前中位出血量止血囊组820 ml(620~1230 ml) vs 纱条组850 ml(605~1442 ml),子宫下段局部压迫缝合术比例两组均为96%(78/81和77/80),差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 填塞后出血量纱条组显著高于止血囊组(P<0.01);产后出血≥1000 ml者纱条组69%(55/80)明显多于止血囊组47%(38/81,P=0.006)。
- 纱条组产后贫血、产褥病率和术后疼痛评分均高于止血囊组(P<0.05);动脉阻断时长、放射剂量、动脉临时阻断相关并发症发生率两组差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 宫腔止血囊上囊中位注水量180 ml(100~240 ml),下囊70 ml(50~100 ml),无止血囊相关严重并发症发生。
关键数值与推荐
- 止血囊组止血成功率100%(81/81) vs 纱条组88%(70/80),P=0.001。
- 产后出血≥1000 ml比例止血囊组47%(38/81) vs 纱条组69%(55/80),P=0.006。
- 宫腔止血囊上囊中位注水量180 ml(100~240 ml),下囊70 ml(50~100 ml)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为在胎盘植入性疾病剖宫产术中,止血囊和纱条宫腔填塞均可有效用于胎盘娩出后止血,但宫腔止血囊止血效果更好、并发症少。
- 作者指出取出宫腔纱条时需做好防治大出血的准备。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To access the effectiveness and safety of the intrauterine balloon tamponade verse gauze packing combined with temporary abdominal aortic balloon occlusion in the management of placenta accreta spectrum (PAS). Methods: This was an open-label, randomized controlled trial conducted in Nanjing Drum Tower Hospital. The patients suspected with PAS for uterine preservation surgery under the multidisciplinary team care were recruited between Aug 2015 and Jan 2018. When bleeding could not be achieved after fetus delivered, and a temporary abdominal aortic balloon occlusion and the compression sutures as needed, the women were randomly allocated 1∶1 into balloon tamponade (n=81) or gauze packing (n=80) group. The primary outcome was successful bleeding arrests by avoiding second line surgeries. The secondary outcomes included the volume of blood loss during and after cesarean section, the rate of PPH, incidence and amount of blood transfusion, hysterectomy, postpartum pain, ICU admission, need for re-laparotomy, and the length of hospital stay, readmission, and interventional radiology complications. Results: All the women [100% (81/81)] in the balloon group were obtained hemostasis without further intervention, significantly higher than 88% (70/80) in the gauze group (P=0.001). Before uterine tamponade, blood loss were 820 ml (620-1 230) ml and 850 ml (605-1 442) ml, while placenta bed were sutured in 96%(78/81, 77/80) respectively (P>0.05).The proportion of blood loss≥1 000 ml was higher in the gauze group than that in the balloon group (P=0.006). Maternal adverse events involving total blood loss, puerperal morbidity and postpartum pain occurred more frequently in the gauze group (P<0.05). The following outcome showed no statistically significant difference between the two groups: the vascular occlusion time, the dose of radiation, and interventional radiology complication (P>0.05). The median volume infused into the lower and upper balloons is 70 ml (50-100 ml) and 180 ml (100-240 ml). Conclusions: Incrauterine balloon tamponade is as effective as gauze packing in hemostasis following the placenta delivery in PAS. Compared with gauze packing, the uterine balloon tamponade is more effective. 目的: 评价宫腔止血囊联合腹主动脉临时阻断术用于胎盘植入性疾病(PAS)剖宫产术中止血的有效性和安全性。 方法: 收集2015年8月至2018年1月在南京大学医学院附属鼓楼医院收治的疑为PAS计划保留子宫的孕妇。胎儿娩出后以腹主动脉球囊临时阻断以及必要时胎盘附着部位压迫缝合术等处理仍不能止血时,根据随机表按1∶1将孕妇分为止血囊组(n=81)和纱条组(n=80),进行开放的随机对照研究。比较两组产妇的主要结局指标止血成功率,次要结局指标剖宫产术围术期的出血量和出血率,以及输血、子宫切除、术后疼痛、ICU入住、住院时间、再入院和放射介入相关并发症。 结果: 止血囊组的止血成功率为100%(81/81),显著高于纱条组的88%(70/80;P=0.001)。宫腔填塞之前,止血囊组、纱条组产妇的中位出血量分别为820 ml (620~1 230 ml)和850 ml(605~1 442 ml),进行子宫下段局部压迫缝合术的比例均为96%(78/81和77/80),两组分别比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。但填塞后出血量纱条组显著高于止血囊组(P<0.01);纱条组产后出血≥1 000 ml者占69%(55/80),也明显多于止血囊组的47%(38/81;P=0.006)。纱条组其他结局指标,包括产后贫血,产褥病率和术后疼痛评分均高于止血囊组。止血囊组和纱条组的动脉阻断时长、放射剂量、动脉临时阻断相关并发症发生率两组分别比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。宫腔止血囊上囊中位数注水量为180 ml(100~240 ml),下囊为70 ml(50~100 ml),无止血囊相关严重并发症发生。 结论: 在PAS剖宫产术中,止血囊和纱条宫腔填塞都能有效用于胎盘娩出后的止血,但宫腔止血囊比纱条止血效果更好,并发症少。取出宫腔纱条时,要做好防治大出血的准备。.
引用
- Dai YM, Wei J, Wang ZQ, et al. [Intrauterine balloon tamponade combined with temporary abdominal aortic balloon occlusion in the management of women with placenta accreta spectrum:a randomized controlled trial]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2020. PMID: 32842248. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20200225-00135
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。