转诊至接受专科进修培训的微创妇科手术亚专科医生的障碍
本研究通过互联网问卷对美国及其领地和加拿大正在执业的一般妇产科医生进行调查,了解转诊至接受专科进修培训的微创妇科手术(MIGS)亚专科医生的模式和障碍。157名受访者中144名(91.7%)一般妇产科医生被纳入分析,86名(59.7%)考虑转诊至MIGS亚专科医生。不转诊的前三大原因包括住院医师培训充分、偏好连续性照护和偏好转诊至其他亚专科医生;转诊的前三大原因包括复杂病理、复杂内科和/或手术病史以及超出执业范围。
要点
- 59.7%(86/144)的一般妇产科医生考虑转诊至MIGS亚专科医生。
- 不转诊前三大原因:住院医师培训充分(58.3%)、偏好连续性照护(33.3%)、偏好转诊至其他亚专科医生(31.9%)。
- 自我报告为高手术量的医生更不可能转诊(p<.01),低手术量医生(p=.02)和知晓社区内有MIGS亚专科医生的医生(p<.01)更可能考虑转诊。
核心结论
- 大多数一般妇产科医生会考虑转诊至接受专科进修培训的MIGS亚专科医生。
- 报告住院医师培训充分、偏好连续性照护或偏好转诊至其他外科亚专科医生的医生更不可能转诊至MIGS亚专科医生。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为问卷调查,通过互联网进行调查。
- 调查地点为美国及其领地和加拿大,参与者为正在执业的一般妇产科医生。
- 157名受访者中144名(91.7%)一般妇产科医生被纳入,13名(8.3%)因亚专科进修培训被排除。
主要发现
- 86名受访者(59.7%)考虑转诊至接受专科进修培训的MIGS亚专科医生。
- 不转诊的前三大原因:住院医师培训充分(n=84,58.3%)、偏好连续性照护(n=48,33.3%)、偏好转诊至其他亚专科医生(n=46,31.9%)。
- 转诊至MIGS亚专科医生的前三大原因:复杂病理(n=92,63.9%)、复杂内科和/或手术病史(n=76,52.8%)、超出执业范围(n=53,36.8%)。
- 需要术中协助时,受访者咨询培训相当的一般妇产科同事(n=50,34.7%)、妇科肿瘤医生(n=48,33.3%)或非妇产科外科亚专科医生(n=33,22.9%)。
- 与转诊至MIGS亚专科医生决策无关的因素包括执业年限(p=.13)、住院医师培训外的额外培训经历(p=.45)和经腹子宫切除术数量(p=.69);自我报告为高手术量的医生更不可能转诊(p<.01),而自我报告为低手术量的医生(p=.02)和知晓社区内有MIGS亚专科医生的医生(p<.01)更可能考虑转诊;受访者最常使用腹腔镜途径行子宫切除术(n=79,54.9%),36.8%为自己或伴侣偏好腹腔镜途径,48.6%偏好阴道途径。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To determine patterns and barriers for referral to fellowship-trained minimally invasive gynecologic surgeons. DESIGN: Questionnaire. SETTING: United States and its territories and Canada. PARTICIPANTS: Actively practicing general obstetrician/gynecologists (OB/GYNs). INTERVENTIONS: Internet-based survey. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Of 157 respondents, 144 (91.7%) general OB/GYNs were included. Subspecialty fellowship training resulted in the exclusion of 13 (8.3%) respondents. A total of 86 respondents (59.7%) considered referral to fellowship-trained minimally invasive gynecologic surgery (MIGS) subspecialists. The top 3 cited reasons for nonreferral were adequate residency training (n = 84, 58.3%), preference for continuity of care (n = 48, 33.3%), and preference for referral to other subspecialists (n = 46, 31.9%). The top 3 cited reasons for referral to MIGS subspecialists were complex pathology (n = 92, 63.9%), complex medical and/or surgical history (n = 76, 52.8%), and out of scope of practice (n = 53, 36.8%). If providers required intraoperative assistance, respondents consulted an OB/GYN colleague with comparable training (n = 50, 34.7%), gynecologic oncologist (n = 48, 33.3%), or non-OB/GYN surgical subspecialist (n = 33, 22.9%). Factors that were not associated with the decision to refer to MIGS subspecialists included years in practice (p = .13), additional training experiences beyond residency (p = .45), and number of hysterectomies performed by laparotomy (p = .69). Self-reported high-volume surgeons (p <.01) were less likely to refer. In contrast, providers who self-reported as low-volume surgeons (p = .02) and were aware of MIGS subspecialists in the community (p <.01) were more likely to consider referral. Respondents reported using a laparoscopic approach to hysterectomy most frequently (n = 79, 54.9%). In contrast, 36.8% preferred the laparoscopic route for themselves or their partner, whereas 48.6% preferred the vaginal approach. CONCLUSION: Most of the general OB/GYNs would consider referral to fellowship-trained MIGS subspecialists. Providers who reported adequate residency training and those who preferred continuity of care or referral to other surgical subspecialists were less likely to refer to MIGS subspecialists.
引用
- Delara R, Misal M, Yi J, et al. Barriers to Referral to Fellowship-trained Minimally Invasive Gynecologic Surgery Subspecialists. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32805461. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2020.08.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。