产前与产后神经管缺陷修复术后运动功能的纵向评估
本研究为单中心回顾性队列研究,纳入2011年11月至2018年12月间127例开放性神经管缺陷(ONTD)患者,其中产前修复93例(51例胎儿镜、42例开放子宫切开),产后修复34例。产后修复组在出生时和12月龄时运动功能均差于产前修复组,产前修复组运动功能从转诊至12月龄保持稳定。作者认为产前超声运动功能评估有助于咨询和手术病例选择。
要点
- 产后修复组出生时和12月龄运动功能均差于产前修复组(P<0.01)。
- 产前修复组运动功能从转诊至12月龄保持稳定(P=0.26)。
- 产后修复组完整运动功能比例从转诊时79%降至出生时24%(P<0.01)。
核心结论
- 产后修复的ONTD婴儿在出生时和12月龄时运动功能均差于产前修复者,也差于其中孕期水平。
- 产前超声运动功能评估是识别出生后临床运动功能良好婴儿的合适工具。
- 胎儿运动功能评估信息对患者咨询和手术病例选择有重要作用。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性队列研究,纳入2011年11月至2018年12月间127例开放性神经管缺陷(ONTD)患者。
- 产前修复组93例(胎儿镜51例、开放子宫切开42例),产后修复组34例。
- 病变解剖水平定义为初始磁共振成像评估的上位骨性脊柱缺陷水平。
- 产前下肢运动功能由超声按Carreras等方法根据神经病变的体节水平评估;出生时和12月龄时由详细神经学检查评估。
- 统计学比较采用配对t检验,运动功能以神经水平中位数(范围)表示。
主要发现
- 转诊时产前修复组与产后修复组解剖病变水平相似(L3(T9-S1)vs L3(T7-S1);P=0.52),运动功能相似(S1(L1-S1)vs S1(L1-S1);P=0.52)。
- 转诊时产前修复组与产后修复组完整运动功能比例相似(81% vs 79%;P=0.88),运动功能较解剖水平预期好两级及以上比例相似(62% vs 74%;P=0.24)。
- 出生时产后修复组运动功能差于产前修复组(S1(L1-S1)vs L4(L1-S1);P<0.01),12月龄时亦差(S1(L1-S1)vs L4(L1-S1);P<0.01)。
- 产前修复组运动功能从转诊至12月龄保持稳定(P=0.26);完整运动功能比例在转诊时81%(75/93)、6周随访74%(64/87)、末次产前扫描74%(42/57)、出生时68%(63/93)、12月龄67%(39/58)。
- 产后修复组完整运动功能比例在转诊时79%(27/34)与6周随访80%(12/15)相似(P=0.92),但在末次产前评估25%(2/8)、出生时24%(8/34)、12月龄28%(7/25)均较低(P<0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为产前超声运动功能评估是识别出生后临床运动功能良好婴儿的合适工具。
- 作者认为胎儿运动功能评估信息对患者咨询和手术病例选择有重要作用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the evolution of motor function from mid-gestation to 12 months of age between prenatally and postnatally repaired cases of open neural tube defect (ONTD). METHODS: This was a retrospective cohort study of all fetuses that underwent prenatal (fetoscopic or open hysterotomy) or postnatal ONTD repair at a single institution between November 2011 and December 2018. The anatomical level of the lesion was defined as the upper bony spinal defect at initial magnetic resonance imaging assessment. Prenatal motor function of the lower extremities was evaluated by ultrasound according to the metameric level of the neurological lesion, based on the methodology of Carreras et al. Fetal motor function was assessed at referral, at 6 weeks after surgery in prenatally repaired cases or 6 weeks after referral in postnatally repaired cases (6-week follow-up) and at the last scan before delivery. In addition, motor function was assessed by a detailed neurological examination at birth and 12 months of age. First sacral (S1) neurological level of the lesion was considered as intact motor function. For statistical comparisons, we attributed numerical scores to each neurological level and motor function was expressed as median (range) neurological level. Motor function (as numerical score) and the proportion of cases with intact motor function and with motor function two or more levels better than expected based on the anatomical level of the lesion were compared between the prenatal- and postnatal-repair groups. Fetal motor function was compared to the anatomical level of the lesion at referral and a better motor function was defined when it was two or more levels better than the anatomical level of the lesion. To assess the evolution of motor function, we compared motor function at referral with that at each follow-up assessment using paired t-tests. RESULTS: We included 127 patients with ONTD, of whom 93 underwent prenatal (51 fetoscopic and 42 open hysterotomy) and 34 postnatal repair. At the time of referral, cases in the prenatal- and postnatal-repair groups presented with a similar anatomical level of lesion (L3 (T9-S1) vs L3 (T7-S1); P = 0.52), similar motor function (S1 (L1-S1) vs S1 (L1-S1); P = 0.52) and a similar proportion of cases with intact motor function (81% vs 79%; P = 0.88) and with motor function two or more levels better than expected based on the anatomical level of the lesion (62% vs 74%; P = 0.24). When compared with prenatally repaired cases, postnatally repaired cases showed worse motor function at birth (S1 (L1-S1) vs L4 (L1-S1); P < 0.01) and at 12 months of age (S1 (L1-S1) vs L4 (L1-S1); P < 0.01). In the prenatal-repair group, motor function remained stable from the time of referral to 12 months of age (P = 0.26). Furthermore, the proportion of patients with intact motor function at referral (81% (75/93)) was similar to that at the 6-week follow-up (74% (64/87)), at the last scan before birth (74% (42/57)), at birth (68% (63/93)) and at 12 months of age (67% (39/58)) in the prenatal-repair group. In the postnatal-repair group, worse motor function, starting from the third trimester to 12 months of age, was observed. The proportion of patients with intact motor function at referral (79% (27/34)) was similar to that at 6-week follow-up (80% (12/15); P = 0.92), but was lower at the last assessment before birth (25% (2/8); P < 0.01), at birth (24% (8/34); P < 0.01) and at 12 months of age (28% (7/25); P < 0.01). Similar findings were noted when assessing the evolution of the proportion of cases with motor function two or more levels better than expected based on the anatomical level of the lesion in each group. CONCLUSIONS: Infants with ONTD that underwent postnatal repair had worse motor function at birth and at 12 months of age than at mid-gestation and when compared with infants that underwent prenatal ONTD repair. Prenatal motor function assessment by ultrasound is an adequate tool to identify those infants who should have a good clinical motor function after delivery. Information obtained by fetal motor function assessment can have an important role for patient counseling and case selection for surgery. © 2020 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Corroenne R, Yepez M, Pyarali M, et al. Longitudinal evaluation of motor function in patients who underwent prenatal or postnatal neural tube defect repair. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 32730648. doi:10.1002/uog.22165
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。