妇产科住院医师与项目主任对住院医师手术准备度的信心调查
本研究基于2019年妇产科住院教育委员会调查,评估美国妇产科住院医师自评手术信心与项目主任对其毕业住院医师独立手术能力的评价。住院医师应答率99.3%,项目主任应答率83%。结果显示双方对剖宫产、产钳/胎吸、腹式子宫切除及宫腔镜手术的信心无显著差异,但毕业住院医师对阴式和腹腔镜子宫切除的信心低于项目主任的评价。
要点
- 毕业住院医师与项目主任对剖宫产、阴道助产、腹式子宫切除及宫腔镜手术的信心无显著差异。
- 90%毕业住院医师自信能独立完成急诊腹式子宫切除,86%自信能完成腹腔镜子宫切除,69%自信能完成阴式子宫切除。
- 97%项目主任认为住院医师毕业时能完成腹腔镜子宫切除,93%毕业住院医师自评能完成。
核心结论
- 毕业妇产科住院医师及其项目主任对毕业时完成多数核心手术的能力有信心。
- 到第二年时,超过90%的住院医师及其项目主任对完成剖宫产和宫腔镜手术的能力有信心。
- 69%和86%的毕业住院医师分别对完成阴式和腹腔镜子宫切除感到自如。
研究设计与样本
- 2019年妇产科住院教育委员会调查评估住院医师自评信心和感知的独立完成常见手术的准备度。
- 同期调查妇产科住院项目主任对其毕业住院医师独立完成相同手术的准备度评价。
- 住院医师应答率为99.3%(5,473/5,514名考生尝试完成调查),项目主任应答率为83%(241/292份调查返回)。
主要发现
- 毕业住院医师与项目主任对剖宫产手术信心的评估无显著差异:99.6%(95%CI 98.9-99.9)vs 100%(95%CI 98.2-100.0)。
- 毕业住院医师与项目主任对阴道助产手术信心的评估无显著差异:96.5%(95%CI 95.2-97.4)vs 98.6%(95%CI 95.9-99.7)。
- 毕业住院医师与项目主任对腹式子宫切除手术信心的评估无显著差异:95.1%(95%CI 93.6-96.2)vs 96.7%(95%CI 93.3-98.7)。
- 毕业住院医师与项目主任对宫腔镜手术信心的评估无显著差异:99.5%(95%CI 98.9-99.9)vs 100%(95%CI 98.2-100.0)。
- 90%、86%和69%的毕业住院医师分别认为在紧急情况下能独立完成腹式子宫切除、腹腔镜子宫切除和阴式子宫切除。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess self-reported readiness of U.S. obstetrics and gynecology residents to perform surgical procedures compared with the perceptions of their program directors. METHODS: The 2019 Council on Resident Education in Obstetrics and Gynecology Survey assessed resident self-confidence and perceived readiness to independently perform common surgical procedures. Concurrently, obstetrics and gynecology residency program directors were surveyed about the readiness of their graduating residents to independently perform the same procedures. RESULTS: The overall response rate was 99.3% for residents (5,473/5,514 examinees attempted to complete the survey) and 83% for program directors (241/292 returned surveys). There were no significant differences in graduating residents and program directors' assessments of graduating residents' surgical confidence in performing cesarean delivery (99.6% [95% CI 98.9-99.9] vs 100% [95% CI 98.2-100.0]), vacuum delivery (96.5% [95% CI 95.2-97.4] vs 98.6% [95% CI 95.9-99.7]), abdominal hysterectomy (95.1% [95% CI 93.6-96.2] vs 96.7% [95% CI 93.3-98.7]) or operative hysteroscopy (99.5% [95% CI 98.9-99.9] vs 100% [95% CI 98.2-100.0]). Ninety percent, 86%, and 69% of graduating residents felt that they could independently perform an abdominal hysterectomy, laparoscopic hysterectomy, and vaginal hysterectomy, respectively, in the event of an emergency. Ninety-seven percent (95% CI 93.3-98.7) of program directors reported their residents could perform a laparoscopic hysterectomy by graduation, as did 93% of graduating resident respondents (95% CI 90.8-94.0). Ninety percent (95% CI 85.3-93.8) of program directors felt their residents could perform vaginal hysterectomies by graduation, compared with 79% (95% CI 76.9-81.8) of fourth-year residents. CONCLUSION: Graduating obstetrics and gynecology residents and their program directors are confident in their abilities to perform the majority of core surgical procedures by graduation. By the second year, more than 90% of residents and their program directors were confident in their ability to perform cesarean deliveries and operative hysteroscopy. Sixty-nine percent and 86% of graduating residents felt comfortable performing vaginal and laparoscopic hysterectomies, respectively.
引用
- Banks E, Gressel GM, George K, et al. Resident and Program Director Confidence in Resident Surgical Preparedness in Obstetrics and Gynecologic Training Programs. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32649501. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000003990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。