边界形态囊胚冷冻决策观察者间一致性差且改良分级系统未改善
这项前瞻性研究纳入同一机构四家IVF诊所的18名胚胎学家,评估边界形态囊胚冷冻决策的观察者间一致性。顶级和非存活囊胚的冷冻决策一致性近乎完美(kappa 1.0),但边界囊胚一致性低(kappa 0.304);改用改良Gardner标准后平均冷冻率从52.7%升至64.8%(P<0.0001),一致性仍无改善(kappa 0.301)。
要点
- 顶级与非存活囊胚冷冻决策一致性近乎完美(kappa 1.0)
- 边界囊胚冷冻决策一致性低(kappa 0.304),改良分级后仍低(kappa 0.301)
- 改良分级后边界囊胚平均冷冻率从52.7%升至64.8%(P<0.0001)
核心结论
- 胚胎学家对边界形态囊胚冷冻决策的观察者间一致性低,改良Gardner分级系统未能改善该一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究纳入同一机构四家IVF诊所的18名胚胎学家,于2019年1月至7月进行。
- 使用三平面囊胚图像,分别在使用Gardner标准和改用改良Gardner标准(ICM和TE各四级)后评估冷冻决策。
- 囊胚按质量分为顶级(n=20)、边界(n=60)和非存活/退化(n=20),共评估1800次冷冻决策。
主要发现
- 顶级和非存活/退化囊胚的冷冻决策一致性近乎完美(kappa 1.0),且不受分级标准影响(顶级P=0.330;非存活/退化P=0.18)。
- 边界囊胚首次调查平均冷冻率为52.7%,观察者间一致性低(kappa 0.304)。
- 改用改良Gardner标准后,边界囊胚平均冷冻率升至64.8%(P<0.0001),但一致性无变化(kappa 0.301)。
关键数值与推荐
- 顶级囊胚冷冻决策kappa 1.0,非存活/退化囊胚kappa 1.0。
- 边界囊胚首次调查平均冷冻率52.7%,kappa 0.304。
- 改良分级后边界囊胚平均冷冻率64.8%(P<0.0001),kappa 0.301。
临床怎么用
- 边界形态囊胚冷冻决策存在显著观察者间差异,可能影响患者护理一致性和累积活产率。
- 改良分级系统未能改善边界囊胚冷冻决策一致性,提示需进一步研究或探索人工智能等新技术。
局限性
- 囊胚评估基于三平面延时图像而非实验室显微镜下评估。
- 不同诊所采用不同分级方案时,冷冻决策的观察者间一致性可能更低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: What is the inter-observer agreement among embryologists for decision to freeze blastocysts of borderline morphology and can it be improved with a modified grading system? SUMMARY ANSWER: The inter-observer agreement among embryologists deciding whether to freeze blastocysts of marginal morphology was low and was not improved by a modified grading system. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: While previous research on inter-observer variability on the decision of which embryo to transfer from a cohort of blastocysts is good, the impact of grading variability regarding decision to freeze borderline blastocysts has not been investigated. Agreement for inner cell mass (ICM) and trophectoderm (TE) grade is only fair, factors which contribute to the grade that influences decision to freeze. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This was a prospective study involving 18 embryologists working at four different IVF clinics within a single organisation between January 2019 and July 2019. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: All embryologists currently practicing blastocyst grading at a multi-site organisation were invited to participate. The survey was comprised of blastocyst images in three planes and asked (i) the likelihood of freezing and (ii) whether the blastocyst would be frozen based on visual assessment. Blastocysts varied by quality and were categorised as either top (n = 20), borderline (n = 60) or non-viable/degenerate quality (n = 20). A total of 1800 freeze decisions were assessed. To assess the impact of grading criteria on inter-observer agreement for decision to freeze, the survey was taken once when the embryologists used the Gardner criteria and again 6 months after transitioning to a modified Gardner criterion with four grades for ICM and TE. The fourth grade was introduced with the aim to promote higher levels of agreement for the clinical usability decision when the blastocyst was of marginal quality. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The inter-observer agreement for decision to freeze was near perfect (kappa 1.0) for top and non-viable/degenerate quality blastocysts, and this was not affected by the blastocysts grading criteria used (top quality; P = 0.330 and non-viable/degenerate quality; P = 0.18). In contrast, the cohort of borderline blastocysts received a mixed freeze rate (average 52.7%) during the first survey, indicative of blastocysts that showed uncertain viability and promoting significant disagreement for decision to freeze among the embryologists (kappa 0.304). After transitioning to a modified Gardner criteria with an additional grading tier, the average freeze rate increased (64.8%; P < 0.0001); however, the inter-observer agreement for decision to freeze was unchanged (kappa 0.301). Therefore, significant disagreement for decision to freeze among embryologists is an ongoing issue not resolved by the two grading criteria assessed here. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Blastocyst assessment was performed from time-lapse images in three planes, rather than with a microscope in the laboratory. The inter-observer agreement for decision to freeze may be lower for embryologists working in different clinics with different grading protocols. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The decision to freeze a blastocyst with borderline morphology is a common clinical issue that has the potential to arise for any patient during blastocyst culture. Disagreement for decision to freeze these blastocysts, and therefore clinical usability in frozen embryo transfer cycles, affects consistency in patient care due to a potential impact on cumulative live birth rates, as well as financial, emotional and time costs associated with the frozen embryo transfer cycles. We demonstrate significant disagreement for decision to freeze borderline blastocysts among embryologists using the same grading scheme within a large multisite organisation, a phenomenon which was not improved with a modified grading system. Decision-making around borderline embryos is an area requiring further research, especially as studies continue to demonstrate the reduced but modest live birth rates for low quality blastocysts (Grade C). These results provide support for emerging technology for embryo assessment, such as artificial intelligence. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): None declared. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: Not applicable.
引用
- Hammond ER, Foong AKM, Rosli N, et al. Should we freeze it? Agreement on fate of borderline blastocysts is poor and does not improve with a modified blastocyst grading system. Hum Reprod. 2020. PMID: 32358601. doi:10.1093/humrep/deaa060
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。