术后病房环境对盆腔重建手术患者疼痛与满意度的影响:一项随机试验
该随机对照试验纳入133例因症状性盆腔器官脱垂接受自体组织阴道穹窿悬吊术的患者,评估术后病房增加音乐与自然风景画是否改善疼痛与满意度。结果显示术后第1天疼痛评分无差异,但干预组在转诊意愿及术后2周对护理、医院和愈合环境的满意度更高。
要点
- 音乐与风景画未显著降低术后第1天疼痛评分。
- 干预组转诊家属至同一医院的意愿更高。
- 术后2周干预组对护理、医院及愈合环境满意度更高。
核心结论
- 音乐与风景画 imagery 未对术后疼痛评分产生实质性影响,但对术后体验有积极影响,且该效应在术后2周似乎扩大。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,经机构审查委员会批准,纳入18-85岁、英语、计划行自体组织阴道穹窿悬吊术的症状性盆腔器官脱垂患者,排除慢性疼痛或药物滥用史者;每组计划43例以检测视觉模拟量表疼痛评分10 mm差异;实际入组133例,主要结局数据可用92例(每组46例)。
主要发现
- 术后第1天中位视觉模拟量表疼痛评分干预组与对照组分别为28.8 mm(0, 86)和24.5 mm(0, 81),无差异(P=.57)。
- 总吗啡当量(P=.817)和护理疼痛评分(P=.774)两组相似。
- 干预组转诊家属至同一医院的意愿更高(98 mm(47, 100) vs 96 mm(65, 100),P=.037)。
- 术后2周干预组对护理满意度更高(98 mm(34, 100) vs 95 mm(42, 100),P=.032)。
- 术后2周干预组对医院满意度更高(98 mm(71, 100) vs 94 mm(6, 100),P=.004),对愈合环境感知更高(98 mm vs 92 mm(19, 100),P=.020)。
临床怎么用
- 在盆腔重建手术术后病房中增加音乐和自然风景画可能提升患者满意度及转诊意愿,且不增加额外风险。
局限性
- 主要结局数据仅92例可用,低于计划样本量;受试者以白人为主(94.6%),平均年龄63.8岁(标准差9.5),中位Charlson合并症评分为2(最小0,最大7),外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Improving the patient experience, controlling pain with nonopiate therapies, and preparing for value-based reimbursement are increasingly important foci for both physicians and hospitals. OBJECTIVE: We aimed to determine whether the addition of music and a natural landscape image to postoperative hospital rooms would result in improved pain and satisfaction scores among inpatients undergoing pelvic reconstructive surgery. STUDY DESIGN: This randomized controlled trial was approved by an Institutional Review Board. Eligible candidates were 18-85 years old, English speaking, and scheduled to undergo native tissue vaginal vault suspension for symptomatic pelvic organ prolapse. Patients with history of a chronic pain or substance abuse were excluded. Subjects were advised that the purpose of the study was to assess the effect of changes to the hospital environment on patient experience but were blinded to their group and intervention details. Changes included a landscape image mounted to the wall and access to a speaker with preprogrammed music selections. The intervention group was instructed to listen to their preferred music for a minimum of 2 30-minute sessions postoperatively. The control group had a standard hospital room, without music or landscape. All patient rooms were private. The primary outcome was the visual analog scale for pain in the morning of postoperative day 1. Secondary outcomes included narcotic use, likelihood to refer family to the same hospital facility, satisfaction with care and the hospital, and perception of a healing environment. A sample size of 43 subjects per arm was calculated to detect a difference of 10 mm in visual analog scale pain score. RESULTS: A total of 133 subjects were enrolled; primary outcome data were available for 92 (46 per arm). The mean age was 63.8 (standard deviation, 9.5) years, median Charlson comorbidity score was 2 (min, 0; max, 7), and 94.6% of subjects were white. On postoperative day 1, median visual analog scale pain scores were low (28.8 mm [0, 86]; 24.5 mm [0, 81]) and did not differ between intervention and control, respectively (P=.57). Total morphine equivalents (P=.817) and nursing pain scores (P=.774) were also similar. However, the intervention group displayed a higher likelihood to refer family members to the hospital (98 mm (47, 100); 96 mm (65, 100); P=.037). At postoperative 2 weeks, the intervention group indicated higher satisfaction with their care (98 mm, (34, 100); 95 mm (42, 100); P=.032), the hospital (98 mm (71, 100); 94 mm (6, 100); P=.004), and the healing environment provided during their stay (98 mm; 92 mm (19, 100); P=.020) than those in the standard hospital rooms. CONCLUSION: In this randomized trial, we found music and landscape imagery did not substantially affect postoperative pain scores; however, they had a positive effect on the postoperative experience. Furthermore, this effect appeared to broaden 2 weeks after surgery. Given the importance of value-based care, interventions such as these should be emphasized to enhance patient satisfaction, quality scores, and overall well-being.
引用
- Hill AM, Crisp CC, Shatkin-Margolis A, et al. The influence of postoperative environment on patient pain and satisfaction: a randomized trial. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32387326. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2020.05.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。