基于超声的子宫内膜异位症分期系统的多中心国际时间与外部验证研究
本研究为多中心、国际、回顾性诊断准确性研究,纳入2016年1月至2018年4月疑似盆腔子宫内膜异位症的317例女性,评估基于超声的子宫内膜异位症分期系统(UBESS)预测腹腔镜手术复杂程度(RCOG 1-3级)的效能。结果显示UBESS在当前形式下除非存在肠深部子宫内膜异位症和/或直肠子宫陷凹封闭,否则不可推广,主要局限在于错误分类了无肠子宫内膜异位症但需输尿管松解术的女性。
要点
- UBESS在时间验证 site 预测RCOG 1级的准确率80.0%,外部 site 90.3%。
- 排除需输尿管松解术但无肠内异症的患者后,UBESS III预测RCOG 3级的敏感性从85.7%升至96.7%(时间 site)。
- UBESS当前形式不可推广,除非存在肠深部内异症和/或直肠子宫陷凹封闭。
核心结论
- UBESS在当前形式下不可推广,除非存在肠深部子宫内膜异位症和/或直肠子宫陷凹封闭。
- 主要局限是错误分类了无肠子宫内膜异位症但需输尿管松解术的女性。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、国际、回顾性诊断准确性研究,2016年1月至2018年4月开展。
- 共纳入317例疑似盆腔子宫内膜异位症并接受腹腔镜的连续女性,293/317(92.4%)有完整经阴道超声和腹腔镜手术结局。
- 4个中心参与:1个用于时间验证,3个用于外部验证。
主要发现
- 时间 site:UBESS I预测RCOG 1级的准确率80.0%、敏感性73.8%、特异性94.9%、阳性预测值97.2%、阴性预测值60.2%、阳性似然比14.5%、阴性似然比0.3%。
- 时间 site:UBESS II预测RCOG 2级的准确率81.0%、敏感性70.6%、特异性82.0%、阳性预测值26.7%、阴性预测值96.8%、阳性似然比3.9%、阴性似然比0.3%。
- 时间 site:UBESS III预测RCOG 3级的准确率91.0%、敏感性85.7%、特异性92.4%、阳性预测值75.0%、阴性预测值96.1%、阳性似然比11.3%、阴性似然比0.2%。
- 外部 site:UBESS I预测RCOG 1级的准确率90.3%、敏感性92.0%、特异性88.4%、阳性预测值90.2%、阴性预测值90.5%、阳性似然比7.9%、阴性似然比0.1%。
- 外部 site:UBESS II预测RCOG 2级的准确率89.2%、敏感性100.0%、特异性88.5%、阳性预测值37.5%、阴性预测值100.0%、阳性似然比8.7%、阴性似然比0.0%。
关键数值与推荐
- UBESS I、II、III分别与RCOG腹腔镜复杂程度1、2、3级对应。
- RCOG分级1至3级用于分类腹腔镜手术复杂程度。
临床怎么用
- UBESS可用于预测子宫内膜异位症腹腔镜手术复杂程度,但需注意其在不伴肠内异症的输尿管松解术患者中准确性有限。
- 在存在肠深部子宫内膜异位症和/或直肠子宫陷凹封闭时,UBESS可能更具适用性。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- UBESS当前形式不可推广,除非存在肠深部内异症和/或直肠子宫陷凹封闭。
- 主要局限为错误分类无肠内异症但需输尿管松解术的女性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to validate temporally and externally the ultrasound-based endometriosis staging system (UBESS) to predict the level of complexity of laparoscopic surgery for endometriosis. DESIGN: A multicenter, international, retrospective, diagnostic accuracy study was carried out between January 2016 and April 2018 on women with suspected pelvic endometriosis. SETTING: Four different centers with advanced ultrasound and laparoscopic services were recruited (1 for temporal validation and 3 for external validation). PATIENTS: Women with pelvic pain and suspected endometriosis. INTERVENTIONS: All women underwent a systematic transvaginal ultrasound and were staged according to the UBESS system, followed by classification of laparoscopic level of complexity according to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) levels 1 to 3. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: UBESS I, II, and III were then correlated with RCOG levels 1, 2, and 3, respectively. A comparison between temporal and external sites (skipping "A") and between each site was performed in terms of the diagnostic accuracy of UBESS to predict RCOG laparoscopic skill level. A total of 317 consecutive women who underwent laparoscopy with suspected endometriosis were included. Complete transvaginal ultrasound and laparoscopic surgical outcomes were available for 293/317 (92.4%). At the temporal site, the accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, positive likelihood ratio, and negative likelihood ratio of UBESS I to predict RCOG level 1 were 80.0%,73.8%, 94.9%, 97.2%, 60.2%, 14.5%, and 0.3%, respectively; of UBESS II to predict RCOG level 2 were 81.0%, 70.6%, 82.0%, 26.7%, 96.8%, 3.9%, and 0.3%, respectively; of UBESS III to predict RCOG level 3 were 91.0%, 85.7%, 92.4%, 75.0%, 96.1%, 11.3%, and 0.2%, respectively. At the external sites, the results of UBESS I to predict RCOG level 1 were 90.3%, 92.0%, 88.4%, 90.2%, 90.5%, 7.9%, and 0.1% respectively; UBESS II to predict RCOG level 2 were 89.2%, 100.0%, 88.5%, 37.5%, 100.0%, 8.7%, and 0.0%, respectively; and UBESS III to predict RCOG level 3 were 86.0%, 67.6%, 98.2%, 96.2%, 82.1%, 37.8%, and 0.3%, respectively. When patients requiring ureterolysis (i.e., RCOG level 3) in the absence of bowel endometriosis were excluded (n = 54), the sensitivity of UBESS III to correctly classify RCOG level 3 increased from 85.7% to 96.7% at the temporal site (n = 42) and from 67.6% to 96.0% at the external sites (n = 12) (p <.005). CONCLUSION: The results from this external validation study suggest that UBESS in its current form is not generalizable unless there is either or both bowel deep endometriosis and cul-de-sac obliteration present. The major limitation appears to be the misclassification of women who require surgical ureterolysis in the absence of bowel endometriosis.
引用
- Espada M, Leonardi M, Aas-Eng K, et al. A Multicenter International Temporal and External Validation Study of the Ultrasound-based Endometriosis Staging System. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 32289555. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2020.04.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。