文献速递生殖医学

评估子宫内膜搔刮的随机对照试验存在方法学问题

Randomised controlled trials evaluating endometrial scratching: assessment of methodological issues.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2019-01-01

该研究评估了25项IVF前和12项IUI/ intercourse前子宫内膜搔刮RCT的方法学问题。结果显示多数RCT存在注册不充分、统计错误或不可重现等问题,可能使结果产生偏倚。

要点

  • 25项IVF RCT中仅8项(32%)注册充分,10项(40%)有统计方法问题。
  • 12项IUI/ intercourse RCT中仅2项(17%)注册充分,5项(42%)有统计方法问题。
  • 上述方法学问题可能使子宫内膜搔刮RCT的结果产生偏倚。

核心结论

  • 多数评估子宫内膜搔刮的RCT存在方法学问题。
  • 这些方法学问题可能使试验结果产生偏倚。

研究设计与样本

  • 评估25项IVF前和12项IUI/ intercourse前子宫内膜搔刮RCT的方法学问题。
  • 评估标准包括试验注册充分性、统计问题、基线特征相似性/差异及杂项问题。

主要发现

  • 25项IVF RCT中仅8项(32%)注册充分,10项(40%)有统计方法问题。
  • 13项适用RCT中9项(69%)报告与重现的基线/中间分类变量单变量分析存在至少一处不一致。
  • 19项适用RCT中14项(74%)至少一个结局的统计结果不可重现。
  • 仅2项(8%)IVF RCT无上述任何问题。
  • 12项IUI/ intercourse RCT中仅2项(17%)注册充分,5项(42%)有统计方法问题,4项(57%,7项适用)报告与重现的单变量分析不一致,8项(80%,10项适用)至少一个结局不可重现,所有RCT均有至少一项上述问题。

关键数值与推荐

  • IVF RCT基线特征未显著违反随机化过程的零假设(P = 0.4395)。
  • IUI/ intercourse RCT基线特征与正确随机分配的零假设不一致(P = 1.659*10-7)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未提供临床实践建议。

局限性

  • 无法评估未以全文发表的RCT。
  • 无法分析个体参与者数据以调查统计不一致的可能原因。
  • 推断正确随机抽样可能性的方法依赖于独立基线特征、简单随机化和无发表偏倚等假设。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: Do randomised controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating endometrial scratching suffer from methodological issues including insufficient trial registration, statistical errors or irreproducibility, randomisation errors or miscellaneous issues? SUMMARY ANSWER: The majority of RCTs investigating endometrial scratching have methodological issues. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: A large number of small RCTs investigating the effectiveness of endometrial scratching prior to in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and intrauterine insemination (IUI)/intercourse have reported favourable findings. Subsequently, systematic reviews incorporating these RCTs yielded meta-analyses in favour of endometrial scratching. Endometrial scratching has been widely adopted by infertility specialists around the world. Recently, an international RCT including 1364 women reported no benefit from endometrial scratching before IVF. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: We evaluated several methodological issues of RCTs investigating the effectiveness of endometrial scratching prior to IVF and IUI/intercourse. We identified 25 RCTs for IVF and 12 RCTs for IUI/intercourse with full-text publication. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: We assessed the RCTs on the following criteria: adequacy of trial registration, statistical issues (description of statistical methods and reproducibility of univariable statistical analysis), excessive similarity or difference in baseline characteristics that is not compatible with chance (Monte Carlo simulations and Kolmogorov-Smirnov test) and miscellaneous methodological issues. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Of 25 RCTs evaluating endometrial scratching prior to IVF, only eight (32%) had adequate trial registration. In total, 10 (40%) RCTs had issues regarding statistical methods. Nine (69%, 13 applicable) RCTs had at least one inconsistency between reported and reproduced univariable statistical analysis for categorical baseline/intermediate characteristics. Statistical results of at least one outcome were not reproducible in 14 (74%, 19 applicable) RCTs. Only two (8%) RCTs had none of the above issues. Suggested by the simulations, these RCTs did not significantly violate the null hypothesis that the baseline characteristics were the results of a properly conducted randomisation process (P = 0.4395).Of 12 IUI/intercourse RCTs, only 2 (17%) had adequate trial registration. In total, five (42%) studies had issues of statistical methods. Inconsistency between reported and reproduced univariable analysis for baseline/intermediate categorical variable(s) was found in four (57%, 7 applicable) RCTs. Statistical analysis was not reproducible for at least one outcome in eight (80%, 10 applicable) studies. All RCTs had at least one of the above issues. These RCTs were inconsistent with the null hypothesis that their baseline characteristics were the results of proper randomised allocation (P = 1.659*10-7). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: We were unable to assess RCTs which were not published as full-text papers. We could not analyse individual participant data to investigate possible reasons for statistical inconsistencies. The method to infer the likelihood of proper random sampling rests on assumptions including independent baseline characteristics, simple randomisation and no publication bias. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The methodological issues common to RCTs evaluating endometrial scratching may have biased the results of the trials. Further development and validation of these novel methods may be helpful for the critical appraisal of RCTs. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No external funding was sought to support this work. B.W.M. is supported by a National Health Medical Research Council (NHMRC) Practitioner Fellowship (GNT1082548). B.W.M. reports consultancy for ObsEva, Merck and Guerbet. D.W. is supported by a grant from the Paracelsus Medical University Salzburg, Austria (PMU Research Fund-PMU FFF Number: L-18/02/006-WET) and by Drs Haackert Foundation, Germany. S.L. is an author of a trial included in this study, an author of an included systematic review and a Cochrane editor. All other authors have no conflicts of interest. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Li W, Suke S, Wertaschnigg D, et al. Randomised controlled trials evaluating endometrial scratching: assessment of methodological issues. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31825478. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez207

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。