文献速递生殖医学产科

供精IUI对异性恋夫妇、单身女性和女同性恋同样有效,但自体IUI效果较差

Donor IUI is equally effective for heterosexual couples, single women and lesbians, but autologous IUI does worse.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2019-01-01

这项回顾性多中心队列研究分析了2013年至2016年西班牙13家私立生殖医学诊所的7228个IUI周期,比较了供精IUI在异性恋夫妇、单身女性和女同性恋群体中的临床结局,并以自体IUI异性恋夫妇为对照。结果显示,在≤37岁良好预后年龄段,供精IUI三组活产率相似(18.8%、16.5%、17.6%),均显著高于自体IUI组的11%;38岁及以上各组无显著差异,40岁后所有组活产率均低于7%。

要点

  • 供精IUI在异性恋夫妇、单身女性和女同性恋中活产率相似。
  • ≤37岁时供精IUI活产率显著高于自体IUI(11%)。
  • 40岁后所有组活产率均低于7%。

核心结论

  • 供精IUI的临床结局在不同人群群体中相似,且优于自体IUI。
  • 在≤37岁良好预后年龄段,供精IUI三组活产率相似但显著高于自体IUI组。
  • 38岁及以上各组无显著差异,40岁后所有组活产率均低于7%。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性多中心队列研究,纳入2013年1月至2016年12月西班牙13家私立诊所的7228个IUI周期(3807名患者)。
  • 供精IUI周期5318个:异性恋夫妇1167个、单身女性2839个、女同性恋1312个;自体IUI异性恋夫妇1910个作为对照。
  • 排除既往IUI尝试的患者,仅1.9%周期失访。

主要发现

  • 多因素分析显示人群群体、女性年龄和低卵巢储备诊断与活产率显著相关(P<0.001)。
  • ≤37岁时活产率:供精IUI异性恋夫妇18.8%、单身女性16.5%、女同性恋17.6%,自体IUI异性恋夫妇11%。
  • 38岁及以上各人群群体间无显著差异,40岁后所有组活产率均低于7%。

关键数值与推荐

  • ≤37岁时供精IUI异性恋夫妇活产率18.8%,单身女性16.5%,女同性恋17.6%,自体IUI异性恋夫妇11%(P<0.001)。
  • 40岁后所有组活产率均低于7%。

临床怎么用

  • 研究结果可用于向不同人群群体咨询ART策略。
  • 在≤37岁良好预后年龄段,供精IUI的生殖表现显著优于自体IUI。
  • 年龄对所有组影响相同,40岁后活产率均低于7%。

局限性

  • 吸烟习惯是唯一已知可能影响ART结局但无法控制的因素,因显著比例的临床档案中缺乏该信息。
  • 低卵巢储备诊断对IUI和供精IUI活产率的影响无法精确量化,因该诊断患者周期数较少(n=231,占总数的3.2%)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: Are there differences in the clinical outcomes of IUI among different populational groups (heterosexual couples, single women and lesbian couples)? SUMMARY ANSWER: The outcome of donor IUI (D-IUI) is similar in all populational groups and better than that seen with autologous insemination. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: A vast body of literature on clinical outcome is available for counselling heterosexual couples regarding decisions related to ART. The reproductive potential of single women, lesbian couples and heterosexual couples who need donor semen is assumed to be better, but there is a scarcity of data on their ART performance to actually confirm it. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: In this retrospective multicentric cohort study, a total of 7228 IUI treatment cycles performed in 3807 patients between January 2013 and December 2016 in 13 private clinics belonging to the same reproductive medicine group in Spain were included. Patients with previous IUI attempts were excluded from the study. Only 1.9% of cycles were lost to follow-up. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: A total of 5318 D-IUI cycles were performed in three different populational groups: heterosexual couples (D-HC, 1167 cycles), single women (SW, 2839 cycles) and lesbian couples (LC, 1312), while a total of 1910 autologous IUI cycles were performed in heterosexual couples (A-HC). This last one was considered the control group and was composed of cycles performed in couples with a male partner with sperm parameters equivalent to those requested from donors. In order to identify factors with an impact on clinical outcome, a multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed. Regarding live birth rate (LBR), mixed effect models were employed to control for the fact that different patients were submitted to different numbers of treatments. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Parameters that were significant to the primary outcome (LBR) according to the multivariate analysis were the populational group (D-HC, SW, LC and A-HC) to which the patient belonged, female age and a diagnosis of low ovarian reserve. At the age range of good prognosis (≤37 years), LBR was similar in all groups that underwent D-IUI (18.8% for D-HC, 16.5% for SW and 17.6% for LC) but was significantly lower in the autologous IUI (A-HC) group (11%). For all these significant findings, the strength of the association was confirmed by P values <0.001. From 38 years of age on, no significant differences were observed among the populational groups studied, and for all of them, LBR was below 7% from 40 years of age on. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: To the best of our knowledge, a smoking habit was the only known factor with a potential effect on ART outcome that could not be controlled for, due to the unavailability of this information in a significant percentage of the clinical files studied. Our study was not capable of precisely quantifying the impact of a diagnosis of low ovarian reserve on the LBR of both IUI and D-IUI, due to the number of cycles performed in patients with such diagnosis (n = 231, 3.2% of the total). WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: For the first time, a comparison among D-HC, SW, LC and A-HC was performed in a study with a robust sample size and controlling for potential sources of bias. There is now sound evidence that equivalent clinical outcome is seen in the three groups treated with donor semen (D-HC, SW and LC). Specifically, regarding the comparison between SW and LC, our findings rule out differences in LBR proposed by previous publications, with very similar clinical outcomes within the same age ranges. At age ranges of good prognosis (≤37 years), reproductive performance of D-IUI is significantly better than that seen in heterosexual couples undergoing autologous IUI, even when only cases of optimal sperm quality are considered in this last group. This finding is in agreement with the concept that, as a group, A-HC are more prone to have female factor infertility, even when their infertility assessment finds no contraindication to IUI. Age affects all these groups equally, with none of them reaching a 7% LBR after the age of 40 years. Our findings will be useful for the counselling of patients from the different populations studied here about ART strategies. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): None.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Soares SR, Cruz M, Vergara V, et al. Donor IUI is equally effective for heterosexual couples, single women and lesbians, but autologous IUI does worse. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31711203. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez179

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。