剖宫产产后疼痛评估与管理中的种族和民族不平等现象
该回顾性队列研究纳入2014年7月1日至2016年6月30日单中心剖宫产活产产妇共1987例,其中1701例符合标准。黑人(28%)和西班牙裔(22%)产妇严重疼痛(≥7/10)比例高于白人(20%)和亚裔(15%)。产后0-24小时非西班牙裔白人产妇记录的疼痛评估次数(调整均值10.2)多于黑人、亚裔和西班牙裔产妇(调整均值8.4-9.5,P<.05);黑人、亚裔、西班牙裔及其他族裔产妇在0-24小时接受的麻醉药品(羟考酮片等效剂量调整均值5.1-7.5,P<.001-.05)也少于非西班牙裔白人产妇。结论认为产后疼痛体验、评估和治疗存在种族和民族不平等。
要点
- 黑人(28%)和西班牙裔(22%)产妇严重疼痛比例高于白人(20%)和亚裔(15%)。
- 产后0-24小时非西班牙裔白人疼痛评估次数(调整均值10.2)多于黑人、亚裔和西班牙裔(8.4-9.5,P<.05)。
- 黑人、亚裔、西班牙裔及其他族裔产后0-24小时接受麻醉药品少于非西班牙裔白人(调整均值5.1-7.5羟考酮片等效剂量,P<.001-.05)。
核心结论
- 研究识别出产后疼痛体验、评估和治疗存在种族和民族不平等。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2014年7月1日至2016年6月30日单中心剖宫产活产产妇,共1987例,1701例符合纳入标准。
- 疼痛评分和用药按产后0-24小时和25-48小时分组,模型调整倾向评分(含母亲年龄、体重指数、孕龄、初产、初次与重复剖宫产、古典式子宫切开、新生儿重症监护病房入住)。
主要发现
- 共记录30984次疼痛评分。
- 严重疼痛(≥7/10)在黑人(28%)和西班牙裔(22%)产妇中比白人(20%)和亚裔(15%)更常见。
- 产后0-24小时非西班牙裔白人疼痛评估次数(调整均值10.2)多于黑人、亚裔和西班牙裔(调整均值8.4-9.5;P<.05)。
- 产后25-48小时结果类似,非西班牙裔白人调整均值8.3。
- 黑人、亚裔、西班牙裔及其他族裔在产后0-24小时和25-28小时接受麻醉药品少于非西班牙裔白人(调整均值5.1-7.5羟考酮片等效剂量;P<.001-.05)。
局限性
- 研究无法评估患者对疼痛表达的信念、对止痛药物的偏好以及医护人员的信念和潜在偏见的作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate whether the frequency of pain assessment and treatment differed by patient race and ethnicity for women after cesarean birth. METHODS: We performed a retrospective cohort study of all women who underwent cesarean birth resulting in a liveborn neonate at a single institution between July 1, 2014, and June 30, 2016. Pain scores documented and medications administered after delivery were grouped into 0-24 and 25-48 hours postpartum time periods. Number of pain scores recorded, whether any pain score was 7 of 10 or greater, and analgesic medication administered were calculated. Models were adjusted for propensity scores incorporating maternal age, body mass index, gestational age, nulliparity, primary compared with repeat cesarean delivery, classical hysterotomy, and admission to the neonatal intensive care unit. RESULTS: A total of 1,987 women were identified, and 1,701 met inclusion criteria. There were 30,984 pain scores documented. Severe pain (7/10 or greater) was more common among black (28%) and Hispanic (22%) women than among women who identified as white (20%) or Asian (15%). In the first 24 hours after cesarean birth, non-Hispanic white women had more documented pain assessments (adjusted mean 10.2) than, black, Asian, and Hispanic women (adjusted mean 8.4-9.5; P<.05). Results at 25-48 hours were similar, compared with non-Hispanic white women (adjusted mean 8.3). Black, Asian, and Hispanic women and women who were identified as other all received less narcotic medication at 0-24 hours postpartum (adjusted mean 5.1-7.5 oxycodone tablet equivalents; P<.001-.05), as well as at 25-28 hours postpartum. CONCLUSION: Racial and ethnic inequities in the experience, assessment and treatment of postpartum pain were identified. A limitation of our study is that we were unable to assess the role of patient beliefs about expression of pain, patient preferences with regards to pain medication, and beliefs and potential biases among health care providers.
引用
- Johnson JD, Asiodu IV, McKenzie CP, et al. Racial and Ethnic Inequities in Postpartum Pain Evaluation and Management. Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31764724. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000003505
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。