文献速递妇科

子宫内膜异位症相关盆腔痛手术治疗的随机对照试验问题识别

Identifying the Problems of Randomized Controlled Trials for the Surgical Management of Endometriosis-associated Pelvic Pain.
PubMed 文献 · J Minim Invasive Gynecol · 2019-11-08

该系统综述检索1996年至2019年10月的英文全文文献,最终纳入20项随机对照试验(RCT),评估手术治疗子宫内膜异位症相关盆腔痛的证据。RCT报告与不手术相比疼痛显著减轻(可达80%的女性),但高达三分之一的女性报告安慰剂反应;手术方式(腹腔镜、开腹或机器人辅助腹腔镜)间疼痛减轻无差异证据;骶前神经切除术价值有限;子宫骶神经消融/离断无价值。

要点

  • 与不手术相比,RCT报告疼痛显著减轻可达80%的女性,但高达三分之一报告安慰剂反应。
  • 腹腔镜、开腹或机器人辅助腹腔镜等手术方式间疼痛减轻无差异证据。
  • 子宫骶神经消融/离断对疼痛无价值,骶前神经切除术价值有限(如有)。

核心结论

  • 尽管手术RCT难以开展,但已有16项关于子宫内膜异位症相关疼痛的RCT。
  • 伦理考量、外科医生和参与者的均势以及随访时长是建立RCT的重要参数。
  • 当证据显示特定结果时(如子宫骶神经破坏不改善疼痛,或肠病碟形切除与节段切除相比未显著减少并发症),我们应愿意接受和采纳证据。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索Cochrane、MEDLINE、EMBASE和临床试验数据库,由2名作者独立筛选摘要,分歧由第三作者解决。
  • 纳入报告手术前后疼痛的随机研究,非随机试验的支持性数据用于讨论,对纳入研究进行Cochrane偏倚风险评估。
  • 检索1996年至2019年10月的英文全文文章,共594项潜在研究,最终20项研究符合纳入标准。

主要发现

  • RCT报告与不手术相比疼痛显著减轻可达80%的女性,但高达三分之一报告安慰剂反应。
  • 手术方式(腹腔镜、开腹或机器人辅助腹腔镜)间疼痛减轻无差异证据。
  • 有限证据表明切除优于消融手术,但疾病位置、深度和受影响疼痛症状的报告存在混杂因素。
  • 子宫骶神经消融和/或离断对疼痛无价值,骶前神经切除术价值有限(如有)。
  • 基于首个相关RCT,需重新考虑碟形切除并发症更少且优于节段切除的假说。

关键数值与推荐

  • 与不手术相比,RCT报告疼痛显著减轻可达80%的女性。
  • 高达三分之一的女性在RCT中报告安慰剂反应。
  • 子宫骶神经消融和/或离断对疼痛无价值,骶前神经切除术价值有限(如有)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,如果接受设计良好的RCT提供最佳质量证据,则应至少愿意接受长期持有的观点可能被新科学挑战和改变。
  • 作者建议,当证据显示特定结果时(如子宫骶神经破坏不改善疼痛,或肠病碟形切除与节段切除相比未显著减少并发症),应愿意接受和采纳证据。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To report on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that examine the surgical treatment of endometriosis-associated pelvic pain and to highlight their strengths and weaknesses. DATA SOURCES: We performed a systematic review of English-language, full-text articles addressing the surgical management of pain symptoms associated with endometriosis. The terms endometriosis, pain, surgery, laparoscopy, plasma, and laser were used for searches in Cochrane, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and clinical trial databases. Additional studies were identified from references in electronically located articles. METHODS OF STUDY SELECTION: A literature search was conducted by 2 authors, and abstracts were independently screened for inclusion, with the resolution of any discrepancy by a third author. Randomized studies that reported pain before and after surgery were eligible for inclusion. Supporting data from nonrandomized trials were used for discussion. The Cochrane risk-of-bias assessment was performed on included studies. TABULATION, INTEGRATION, AND RESULTS: Search results for available articles from 1996 to October 2019 revealed 594 potential studies, with 20 studies meeting the final inclusion criteria. Comparative studies of surgery vs no surgery for an effect on pain, surgical approach, the effect of different locations of disease on pain, nerve-dividing techniques for pain, and nerve-sparing effects for pain were studied. RCTs reported a substantial reduction in pain compared with no surgery in up to 80% of women; however, up to a third of women in these studies reported a placebo response. There was no evidence of a difference in pain reduction with the mode of surgery (laparoscopy, laparotomy, or robot-assisted laparoscopy). There is limited evidence stating that excision is superior to ablative surgery; however, there are confounders in the reporting of disease location and depth and the pain symptoms most affected. We need to reconsider the hypothesis that disc excision results in fewer complications and has superior outcomes to those of segmental resection in light of the first RCT on this subject. Nerve-dividing surgery for pain has been demonstrated to be of no value for uterosacral nerve ablation and/or division and of limited (if any) value for presacral neurectomy. CONCLUSION: Although surgical RCTs have always been difficult to undertake, there are 16 RCTs on endometriosis-associated pain. Ethical considerations, the equipoise of surgeons and participants, and follow-up duration are important parameters in establishing RCTs. In addition, we must be willing to accept and adopt the evidence when it does demonstrate a particular outcome, such as the fact that surgical uterosacral nerve disruption does not improve pain or that disc excision does not substantially reduce complications compared with segmental resection for bowel disease, as suggested by previous nonrandomized studies. If we accept that a well-conducted RCT provides best-quality evidence, then we should at least be open to the possibility that our long-held views may be challenged and changed with new science in our practice.

来源:J Minim Invasive Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Budden A, Ravendran K, Abbott JA, et al. Identifying the Problems of Randomized Controlled Trials for the Surgical Management of Endometriosis-associated Pelvic Pain. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31712161. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2019.11.002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。