低风险医院分娩中助产与产科医疗的比较
该回顾性队列研究纳入2014年1月1日至2018年12月31日期间11家医院低风险单胎分娩23,100例(助产3,816例,产科19,284例),比较助产与产科医生的分娩干预、分娩方式及母婴结局,发现助产患者干预率更低、剖宫产及阴道助产风险更低,但经产妇肩难产风险更高。
要点
- 与产科医生相比,助产患者的干预率显著更低。
- 初产妇剖宫产风险约降低30%(aRR 0.68;95th% CI 0.57-0.82),经产妇约降低40%(aRR 0.57;95th% CI 0.36-0.89)。
- 经产妇接受助产护理时肩难产更常见(aRR 1.42;95th% CI 1.04-1.92)。
核心结论
- 在低风险妊娠中,助产护理与分娩干预减少、剖宫产及阴道助产减少相关,并且在经产妇中肩难产风险增加。
- 作者认为,将助产护理更大程度地整合到美国孕产服务中,可能减少低风险妊娠的分娩干预,甚至可能减少剖宫产。
- 需要更大规模的研究来评估不常见但重要的母婴结局。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2014年1月1日至2018年12月31日期间11家医院的37 0/7-42 6/7周妊娠单胎分娩。
- 研究队列共23,100例分娩,其中助产3,816例,产科19,284例。
- 排除标准包括:从家庭分娩中心产时转运、产前死胎、既往剖宫产、由助产士或产科医生以外的执业者提供照护、产程开始前剖宫产、孕前母体疾病以及妊娠并发症或危险因素。
- 采用改良泊松回归模型,调整个体混杂因素后评估风险比,并按产次分层分析医疗提供者类型与围产期结局。
主要发现
- 与产科医生相比,助产患者的干预率显著更低。
- 初产妇中,助产患者的剖宫产风险约降低30%(aRR 0.68;95th% CI 0.57-0.82)。
- 经产妇中,助产患者的剖宫产风险约降低40%(aRR 0.57;95th% CI 0.36-0.89)。
- 阴道助产在初产妇中更少见(aRR 0.73;95th% CI 0.57-0.93),在经产妇中也更少见(aRR 0.30;95th% CI 0.14-0.63)。
- 经产妇接受助产护理时肩难产更常见(aRR 1.42;95th% CI 1.04-1.92)。
关键数值与推荐
- 初产妇剖宫产:aRR 0.68(95th% CI 0.57-0.82),助产较产科降低。
- 经产妇剖宫产:aRR 0.57(95th% CI 0.36-0.89),助产较产科降低。
- 初产妇阴道助产:aRR 0.73(95th% CI 0.57-0.93),助产较产科降低。
- 经产妇阴道助产:aRR 0.30(95th% CI 0.14-0.63),助产较产科降低。
- 经产妇肩难产:aRR 1.42(95th% CI 1.04-1.92),助产较产科升高。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,将助产护理更大程度地整合到美国孕产服务中,可能减少低风险妊娠的分娩干预,甚至可能减少剖宫产。
- 作者指出,需要更大规模的研究来评估不常见但重要的母婴结局。
局限性
- 需要更大规模的研究来评估不常见但重要的母婴结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare midwife and obstetrician labor practices and birth outcomes in women with low-risk pregnancies delivered in the hospital. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cohort study of singleton births of 37 0/7-42 6/7 weeks of gestation at 11 hospitals between January 1, 2014, and December 31, 2018. Exclusions included intrapartum transfer from home-birth center, antepartum stillbirth, previous cesarean delivery, practitioner other than midwife or obstetrician, prelabor cesarean, prepregnancy maternal disease, and pregnancy complications or risk factors. Interventions (induction, artificial rupture of membranes, epidural, oxytocin, and episiotomy), mode of delivery, maternal outcomes (third- or fourth-degree laceration, postpartum hemorrhage, blood transfusion, and severe maternal morbidity), and newborn outcomes (shoulder dystocia, 5-minute Apgar score less than 7, resuscitation at delivery, birth trauma, and neonatal intensive care unit admission) were examined by practitioner type. We used modified Poisson regression models adjusted for individual confounders to assess risk ratios, stratified by parity, for health care provider type and perinatal outcomes. RESULTS: The study cohort comprised 23,100 births (3,816 midwife and 19,284 obstetrician). Compared with obstetricians, midwifery patients had significantly lower intervention rates, an approximately 30% lower risk of cesarean delivery in nulliparous patients (adjusted relative risk [aRR] 0.68; 95th% CI 0.57-0.82), and an approximately 40% lower risk of cesarean in multiparous patients (aRR 0.57; 95th% CI 0.36-0.89). Operative vaginal birth was also less common in nulliparous patients (aRR 0.73; 95th% CI 0.57-0.93) and multiparous patients (aRR 0.30; 95th% CI 0.14-0.63). Shoulder dystocia was more common in multiparous patients receiving midwifery care (aRR 1.42; 95th% CI 1.04-1.92). CONCLUSIONS: In low-risk pregnancies, midwifery care in labor was associated with decreased intervention, decreased cesarean and operative vaginal births, and, in multiparous women, an increased risk for shoulder dystocia. Greater integration of midwifery care into maternity services in the United States may reduce intervention in labor and potentially even cesarean delivery, in low-risk pregnancies. Larger research studies are needed to evaluate uncommon but important maternal and newborn outcomes.
引用
- Souter V, Nethery E, Kopas ML, et al. Comparison of Midwifery and Obstetric Care in Low-Risk Hospital Births. Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31599830. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000003521
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。