性别选择与非侵入性产前检测:当前实践、证据与伦理问题综述
非侵入性产前检测(NIPT)能非常准确且很早期确定胎儿性别,令人担忧其便利性、时机和准确性会促进性别选择性终止妊娠。本文综述当前实践、NIPT与性别选择性终止妊娠关联的证据及相关伦理问题,指出超声技术普及已直接影响性别选择性终止妊娠率,而NIPT影响的数据很少且证据多为轶事性,需进一步研究量化。
要点
- NIPT可非常准确且很早期确定胎儿性别,引发对性别选择性终止妊娠的担忧。
- 超声是目前父母确定胎儿性别的主要方法,其普及直接影响性别选择性终止妊娠率。
- NIPT对性别选择实践影响的数据很少,证据多为轶事性,需进一步研究量化。
核心结论
- NIPT确定胎儿性别的便利性、时机和准确性可能促进性别选择性终止妊娠,但NIPT在性别选择性终止妊娠中作用的证据仍多为轶事性,需进一步研究评估和量化由NIPT性别确定导致的终止妊娠。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,回顾当前实践、NIPT与性别选择性终止妊娠关联的证据及相关伦理问题。
主要发现
- 性别选择性终止妊娠通常由男孩偏好驱动,在印度和中国等国已产生严重人口后果。
- 目前超声是父母确定胎儿性别的主要方法,超声技术的普及已直接影响性别选择性终止妊娠率。
- NIPT目前更昂贵,但其应用增加可能产生类似影响。
- 由于NIPT是产前筛查中相对较新的发展,关于NIPT对性别选择实践影响的数据很少。
- NIPT在性别选择性终止妊娠中起作用的证据仍多为轶事性。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 由于NIPT是产前筛查中相对较新的发展,关于NIPT对性别选择实践影响的数据很少。
- NIPT在性别选择性终止妊娠中起作用的证据仍多为轶事性。
- 需进一步研究评估和量化由NIPT性别确定导致的终止妊娠。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) can determine the sex of the fetus very accurately and very early in gestation. There are concerns that the ease, timing, and accuracy of NIPT sex determination will facilitate sex-selective termination of pregnancy (TOP). Here, we review current practices, the evidence for a link between NIPT and sex-selective TOP, and associated ethical issues. Sex-selective TOP, usually motivated by son preference, has had serious demographic consequences in countries such as India and China. Currently, ultrasound is the primary method by which parents determine the sex of the fetus. The diffusion of ultrasound technology has had a direct impact on the rates of sex-selective TOP. Although NIPT is currently more costly, it is feasible that increased uptake of this technology could have a similar effect. Partly because NIPT is a relatively recent development in prenatal screening, there is little data on the impact of NIPT on sex selection practices. Evidence that NIPT is playing a role in sex-selective TOP remains largely anecdotal. Further research is required to assess and quantify TOP resulting from NIPT sex determination. The use of these technologies for sex selection raises a number of ethical issues, in addition to practical demographic consequences.
引用
- Bowman-Smart H, Savulescu J, Gyngell C, et al. Sex selection and non-invasive prenatal testing: A review of current practices, evidence, and ethical issues. Prenat Diagn. 2019. PMID: 31499588. doi:10.1002/pd.5555
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。