不同少数族裔或宗教背景女性希望获得更多不孕症教育及更具文化敏感性的生育照护
该研究通过一日绘画工作坊收集九名居住于威尔士的少数族裔或宗教背景不孕女性的视觉与文本数据,采用主题分析法提炼出41个主题并归为8个高阶主题。女性认为其社区持有强烈 pronatalist 态度并污名化不孕,表达了对自身及社区更多不孕教育和更具社会文化与人际敏感性的生育照护的需求。
要点
- 少数族裔或宗教背景女性感知社区强烈 pronatalist 态度并污名化不孕。
- 女性希望获得更多面向自身及社区的不孕症教育。
- 女性希望生育照护更具文化能力与人际敏感性。
核心结论
- 少数族裔或宗教背景女性认为其社区持有强烈 pronatalist 态度并污名化不孕,表达了对更多不孕教育及更具社会文化与人际敏感性的生育照护的需求。
研究设计与样本
- 研究基于一日绘画工作坊,收集参与者创作的视觉作品及工作坊中所有对话与讨论的文本数据,以了解其对不孕及生育照护需求的看法与经历。
- 参与者为九名居住于英国威尔士的成年女性,具有少数族裔或宗教背景,正在经历或曾经历不孕。
- 工作坊包括五项活动:小组与大组讨论不孕相关绘画、基于幻灯片的绘画基础讲座、想法与感受、自由绘画环节及小组分享。
- 工作坊录音逐字转录,文本数据采用主题分析;由两位作者独立编码后与研究团队及参与者共同呈现和讨论结果以控制偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 共识别41个主题并归为8个不同的高阶主题。
- 主题描述了女性经历的不孕情感、关系与社会负担,她们认为这源于社区强烈的 pronatalist 态度和对不孕的污名化。
- 主题还捕捉了女性的适应性应对策略以及对 pronatalist 意识形态的批判态度。
- 主题亦反映女性对其生育健康照护的总体积极评价,以及获得更多不孕教育(面向自身及社区)和更具文化能力与人际敏感性照护的愿望。
局限性
- 参与者为通过与当地慈善机构合作招募的小样本非随机样本,可能意味着所有参与者均良好融入其社区。
- 分析侧重于捕捉参与者经历的共性,有时可能导致多样化经历的同质化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: What are the views, experiences and healthcare needs of infertile women from a minority ethnic or religious background living in Wales? SUMMARY ANSWER: Women from ethnic and religious minority backgrounds consider that their communities have highly pronatalistic attitudes and stigmatize infertility, and express the need for more infertility education (for themselves and their communities), as well as more socio-culturally and interpersonally sensitive fertility care. WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN: Some people from minority ethnic or religious groups perceive pressure to conceive from their communities, experience social costs when they are unable to have children and stressful interactions with the fertility healthcare system while attempting to conceive. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This study was based on a one-day drawing workshop to collect visual (artwork produced by participants) and textual (all conversations and discussions during the workshop) data about the participants' views and experiences of infertility and their fertility care needs. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Participants were nine adult women with a minority ethnic or religious status living in Wales, UK, who were experiencing or had experienced infertility in the past. The workshop comprised five activities: (i) small and large group discussion of infertility-related drawings, (ii) lide-based lecture consisting of an introduction to the basics of drawing objects and people and (iii) thoughts and feelings, (iv) free drawing session and (v) group sharing. Audio recordings of the workshop were transcribed verbatim. Textual data was analysed with thematic analysis. Risk for bias was addressed via individual coding by two authors followed by joint presentation and discussion of results with the research team and participants. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Forty-one themes were identified and grouped into eight distinct higher order themes. These themes described the emotional, relational and social burden of infertility experienced by women, which they perceived to result from their communities' highly pronatalistic attitudes and stigmatization of infertility. Themes also captured women's adaptive coping strategies and critical attitude towards pronatalist ideologies. Lastly, themes captured their overall positive evaluation of their fertility health care, their desire for more infertility education (for themselves and their communities) and for culturally competent and interpersonally sensitive care. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Our participants were a small, non-random sample recruited in collaboration with a local charity, which may mean that all participants were well integrated in their communities. Analysis focused on capturing commonalities in participants' experiences and this may sometimes result in homogenising diverse experiences. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: More education about the infertility experiences of minority ethnic and religious groups at the community and healthcare delivery level may translate into lessened negative attitudes towards infertility and more culturally competent care, which can be beneficial for women. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This research was funded by Welsh Crucible. The authors have no conflict of interests to declare.
引用
- Gameiro S, El Refaie E, de Guevara BB, et al. Women from diverse minority ethnic or religious backgrounds desire more infertility education and more culturally and personally sensitive fertility care. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31411328. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez156
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。