比较预测子宫内膜癌淋巴播散的风险分层标准
回顾性分析2004年1月1日至2013年9月30日手术的1103例子宫内膜样子宫内膜癌患者,比较Milwaukee模型与Mayo标准预测淋巴播散。Milwaukee模型高危率最低但假阴性率13.6%不可接受;传统Mayo标准假阴性率0%但高危率69.5%;将肿瘤直径阈值改为≤3cm可减少13.5%的淋巴结清扫但假阴性率3.7%仍不可接受。
要点
- Milwaukee模型高危率38.1%,假阴性率13.6%(95%CI 7.0-23.0)。
- 传统Mayo标准(肿瘤直径2cm)高危率69.5%,假阴性率0%(95%CI 0-4.5)。
- Mayo标准肿瘤直径改为≤3cm可减少13.5%淋巴结清扫,但假阴性率3.7%不可接受。
核心结论
- Milwaukee模型淋巴播散高危率最低但假阴性率不可接受。
- 将Mayo标准肿瘤直径阈值从≤2cm改为≤3cm可减少约13.5%的淋巴结清扫,但伴随的假阴性率仍不可接受。
- 传统Mayo标准用于低危子宫内膜癌在判定可省略淋巴结清扫方面仍最敏感。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2004年1月1日至2013年9月30日手术的1103例I-III期子宫内膜样子宫内膜癌患者。
- 用两种独立风险模型将患者分为低危与高危,计算各模型假阳性率和假阴性率。
主要发现
- 1103例中81例(7.3%)发生淋巴播散(72例淋巴结阳性,9例淋巴结复发),90.2%为I期。
- Milwaukee模型高危率38.1%,假阴性率13.6%(95%CI 7.0-23.0)。
- 传统Mayo标准(肿瘤直径2cm)高危率69.5%,假阴性率0%(95%CI 0-4.5)。
- Mayo标准肿瘤直径改为≤3cm后高危率56.8%(对比69.5%),假阳性率53.6%(对比67.1%),假阴性率3.7%(95%CI 0.8-10.4)。
关键数值与推荐
- 淋巴播散定义为手术时淋巴结阳性、或淋巴结清扫阴性后2年内淋巴结复发、或未行淋巴结清扫时的淋巴结复发。
- Milwaukee模型假阴性率13.6%(95%CI 7.0-23.0)。
- 传统Mayo标准假阴性率0%(95%CI 0-4.5)。
- 改良Mayo标准(肿瘤直径≤3cm)假阴性率3.7%(95%CI 0.8-10.4)。
临床怎么用
- 传统Mayo标准用于低危子宫内膜癌在判定可省略淋巴结清扫方面仍最敏感。
- 作者认为将Mayo标准肿瘤直径阈值从≤2cm改为≤3cm虽可减少约13.5%的淋巴结清扫,但假阴性率不可接受。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare two published risk stratification models (Milwaukee Model vs. Mayo Criteria) to predict lymphatic dissemination (LD) in endometrioid endometrial cancer (EC). METHODS: Patients with stage I-III EC undergoing surgery from 1/1/2004-9/30/2013 were retrospectively reviewed and classified as low-risk vs at-risk for LD using two independent risk models. LD was defined as positive nodes at surgery or lymph node recurrence within 2 years of surgery after negative lymph node dissection (LND) or when LND was not performed. False positive (FP) and false negative (FN) rates for each risk model were calculated. RESULTS: Among 1103 patients, 81 (7.3%) had LD (72 positive LN and 9 LN recurrences), and most (90.2%) had stage I EC. The Milwaukee Model yielded a low at-risk rate for LD (38.1%) but a high FN rate (13.6%, 95% CI 7.0-23.0). The traditional Mayo Criteria using a cut-off of 2 cm for tumor diameter (TD) had a higher at-risk rate for LD (69.5%) but a FN rate of 0% (95% CI, 0-4.5). Modifying the Mayo Criteria using a TD cutoff of ≤3 cm identified fewer women at-risk (56.8% vs. 69.5%) and had a lower FP rate (53.6% vs. 67.1%), but had a higher FN rate (3.7%, 95% CI, 0.8-10.4). CONCLUSIONS: The Milwaukee Model had the lowest at-risk rate of LD but an unacceptable FN rate. Modifying the Mayo Criteria by increasing the TD cutoff from the traditional ≤2 cm to ≤3 cm would spare an estimated 13.5% of patients LND, but the accompanying FN rate is unacceptably high. The traditional Mayo Criteria for low-risk EC remains the most sensitive in determining which patients LND can be omitted.
引用
- Kilts TP, Glaser GE, Langstraat CL, et al. Comparing risk stratification criteria for predicting lymphatic dissemination in endometrial cancer. Gynecol Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31409487. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2019.08.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。