子宫内膜异位症生育指数的可重复性:一项前瞻性评估者间与评估者内一致性研究
在单队列前瞻性观察研究中,对接受腹腔镜切除任何rASRM分期子宫内膜异位症的女性,由三名评估者进行EFI评分,评估者间临床一致率为1.000(95%CI 0.956-1.000;P=0.0149),数值一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000),rASRM评分的可重复性在所有比较中均明显低于EFI。结论认为EFI可由不同评估者可靠重复,支持其作为术后生育咨询与管理的日常临床工具。
要点
- 两名专家间EFI临床一致率为1.000(95%CI 0.956-1.000;P=0.0149),数值一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000)。
- 初级评估者与专家间临床一致率为0.963(95%CI 0.897-0.992),数值一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000)。
- 评估者内临床一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000),数值一致率为1.000(95%CI 0.956-1.000)。
核心结论
- EFI可由不同评估者可靠重复,进一步支持其作为子宫内膜异位症女性术后生育咨询与管理的日常临床主要工具。
研究设计与样本
- 单队列前瞻性观察研究,在大学医院开展。
- 研究对象为接受腹腔镜切除任何rASRM分期子宫内膜异位症的女性,所需样本量为71。
- 术前与术中资料被收集至编码研究档案,由三名评估者(专家-1、专家-2、初级评估者)整体进行EFI评分。
- 一致性定义:临床一致为评分处于同一范围(0-4、5-6、7-10),数值一致为EFI评分差值≤1分。
主要发现
- 两名专家间临床一致率为1.000(95%CI 0.956-1.000;P=0.0149),数值一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000)。
- 初级评估者与专家间临床一致率为0.963(95%CI 0.897-0.992),数值一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000)。
- 评估者内临床一致率为0.988(95%CI 0.934-1.000),数值一致率为1.000(95%CI 0.956-1.000)。
- 不一致的原因包括对最低功能评分的不同评分以及rASRM评分的分歧。
- 在所有比较中,rASRM评分的可重复性均明显低于EFI。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为EFI可在日常临床实践中可靠重复,支持其作为子宫内膜异位症女性术后生育咨询与管理的主要临床工具。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the reproducibility of the Endometriosis Fertility Index (EFI). DESIGN: Single-cohort prospective observational study. SETTING: University hospital. POPULATION: Women undergoing laparoscopic resection of any rASRM-stage endometriosis. METHODS: Details of pre- and peroperative findings were collected into a coded research file. EFI scoring was performed en-bloc by three different raters (expert-1 [C.T.], expert-2 [C.M.], junior [C.B.]). Required sample size: 71. Definitions used for agreement: clinical (scores within same range: 0-4, 5-6, 7-10) and numerical (difference ≤1 EFI point). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcome: rate of clinical agreement between two experts. SECONDARY OUTCOMES: expert numerical agreement, clinical and numerical agreement between expert-1 and junior, and within expert-1 (intra-observer), agreement of rASRM score and -stage. RESULTS: A near 'inter-expert' clinical agreement rate (1.000, 95% CI 0.956-1.000; P = 0.0149) was observed. The numerical agreement between two experts was also high (0.988, 95% CI 0.934-1.000); similarly, high agreement rates were observed for both 'junior-expert' comparisons (clinical 0 .963, 95% CI 0.897-0.992; numerical 0.988, 95% CI 0.934-1.000) and 'intra-expert' comparisons (clinical 0.988, 95% CI 0.934-1.000; numerical 1.000, 95% CI 0.956-1.000). Reasons for disagreements were different scoring of the least-function score and disagreements in rASRM scores. The reproducibility of the rASRM score was clearly inferior to that of the EFI for all comparisons. CONCLUSION: The EFI can be reproduced reliably by different raters, further supporting its use in daily clinical practice as the principal clinical tool for postoperative fertility counselling/management of women with endometriosis. TWEETABLE ABSTRACT: A study confirming the high reproducibility of the EFI substantiates its use in daily clinical practice.
引用
- Tomassetti C, Bafort C, Meuleman C, et al. Reproducibility of the Endometriosis Fertility Index: a prospective inter-/intra-rater agreement study. BJOG. 2019. PMID: 31319445. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.15880
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。