两种引导式自我管理干预对不孕女性心理困扰的效果:三臂随机对照试验
该三臂随机对照试验将234名首次接受IVF/ICSI的女性随机分为简短正念组、感恩日记组和对照组。简短正念组抑郁较对照组下降(MD=-1.69,[-3.01,-0.37],d=0.44)且睡眠质量改善(MD=-1.24,[-1.95,-0.39],d=0.43),感恩日记组所有结局变量均无显著效果。
要点
- 简短正念干预可降低抑郁并改善睡眠质量,感恩日记干预对所有结局变量无显著效果。
- 两组干预在焦虑、生育问题量表总分、正念、感恩评分或妊娠率上均无显著效果。
- 简短正念组抑郁和睡眠质量在T1至T2显著改善,T1至T3持续显著改善,T2至T3无改善。
核心结论
- 简短正念干预有益于降低抑郁和改善睡眠质量,感恩日记干预对所有结局变量无显著效果。
- 在资源匮乏地区实施引导式自我管理正念可使不孕患者更容易获得心理咨询服务。
- 感恩日记干预的效率和可行性需进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 三臂随机对照试验,2016年5月至2017年11月在一家公立医院生殖中心纳入234名接受IVF/ICSI的女性随机分为简短正念组(n=78)、感恩日记组(n=78)和对照组(n=78)。
- 纳入标准为首次IVF周期、至少初中教育、无亲生或收养子女。
- 简短正念组完成4次课程并每日听20分钟音频(含引导式正念呼吸和身体扫描);感恩日记组完成4次课程并每日写3篇感恩日记;对照组接受常规护理。
- 采用广义估计方程进行意向性治疗分析,主要结局为抑郁,次要结局为焦虑、睡眠质量、不孕相关压力、正念和感恩。
主要发现
- 与对照组相比,简短正念组抑郁下降(MD=-1.69,[-3.01,-0.37],d=0.44)且睡眠质量改善(MD=-1.24,[-1.95,-0.39],d=0.43)。
- 简短正念组在焦虑、生育问题量表总分、正念、感恩评分或妊娠率上无显著效果。
- 简短正念组抑郁和睡眠质量在T1至T2显著改善,T1至T3持续显著改善,T2至T3无改善。
- 感恩日记组对所有变量均无显著效果。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为简短正念干预有益于降低抑郁和改善睡眠质量。
- 作者认为实施引导式自我管理正念可使资源匮乏地区的不孕患者更容易获得心理咨询服务。
- 作者认为感恩日记干预的效率和可行性需进一步研究。
局限性
- 纳入标准可能引入偏倚,因部分低教育程度参与者被排除且仅纳入不孕女性。
- 感恩日记组依从率低。
- 本研究未纳入男性。
- 进一步研究应考虑纳入目标人群的配偶。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: What is the effect of two guided self-administered interventions on psychological distress in women undergoing IVF or ICSI? SUMMARY ANSWER: A brief mindfulness intervention significantly reduced depression and improved sleep quality, while the gratitude journal intervention showed no significant effect on any outcome variables. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Mindfulness and gratitude journal interventions have been found to be beneficial in reducing negative affect and improving well-being. However, there are very few mental health professionals who implement such interventions in low- and middle-income countries. Therefore, two guided self-administered interventions for women with infertility were designed to help them cope with their psychological distress. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: A three-armed, randomized controlled trial was designed to evaluate the mindfulness and gratitude journal interventions for women undergoing IVF/ICSI. Between May 2016 and November 2017, at the reproductive center in a public hospital, 234 women were randomly assigned to the brief mindfulness group (BMG, n = 78), gratitude journal group (GJG, n = 78) or control group (CG, n = 78). The inclusion criteria were being a woman undergoing her first cycle of IVF, having at least junior middle school education and having no biological or adopted children. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Female infertility patients (n = 346) were approached, and 112 did not meet the inclusion criteria. All three randomized groups completed questionnaires on the day of down-regulation (T1), the day before embryo(s) transfer (T2), and 3 days before the pregnancy test (T3). The BMG completed four sessions and listened to a 20-minute audio daily, including guided mindfulness breathing and body scan. The GJG completed four sessions and wrote three gratitude journals daily. The CG received routine care. A generalized estimating equation was used in an intention-to-treat analysis. The primary outcome was depression. Secondary outcomes were anxiety, sleep quality, infertility-related stress, mindfulness and gratitude. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Participants of the BMG showed decreased depression (mean difference (MD) = -1.69, [-3.01, -0.37], d = 0.44) and improved sleep quality (MD = -1.24, [-1.95, -0.39], d = 0.43) compared to the CG, but the effect was not significant for anxiety, Fertility Problem Inventory totals, mindfulness, gratitude scores or pregnancy rates. The BMG showed a significant reduction in depression and improvement in sleep quality between T1 and T2, a continuous significant reduction between T1 and T3 and no reduction between T2 and T3. There were no significant effects on any of the variables for the GJG. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The inclusion criteria may result in bias because some participants with low education were excluded and only women with infertility were included. A low compliance rate occurred in the gratitude journals group. Moreover, men were not included in this study. Further research should consider including spouses of the target population. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The brief mindfulness intervention was beneficial in decreasing depression and improving sleep quality. Implementation of guided self-administered mindfulness could make the psychological counseling service more accessible for patients with infertility in resource-poor settings. The efficiency and feasibility of the gratitude journal intervention needs to be investigated further. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This study was funded by the National Social Science Foundation (17BSH054). The authors have no conflicts of interest. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: ChiCTR-IOR-16008452. TRIAL REGISTRATION DATE: 9 May 2016. DATE OF FIRST PATIENT’S ENROLMENT: 15 May 2016.
引用
- Bai CF, Cui NX, Xu X, et al. Effectiveness of two guided self-administered interventions for psychological distress among women with infertility: a three-armed, randomized controlled trial. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31242506. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。