迈向更务实、更明智的不孕症诊疗路径
该文指出不孕症诊疗中诊断与治疗可延续数年且诊断工具准确性不理想,导致「不明原因不孕」过度诊断与体外受精过度治疗,并可能影响治疗依从性。作者呼吁关注备孕时长、在无异常检查结果时延长备孕至2年以上再诊断不明原因不孕、处理肥胖与吸烟等不良生活习惯及提高依从性。
要点
- 不孕症诊断依赖备孕时长而非明确症状,诊断工具准确性不理想,易致过度诊断与过度治疗。
- 无异常检查结果时,无论年龄,备孕时长应延长至2年以上再诊断不明原因不孕。
- 即使干预性研究结论不确定,仍建议处理肥胖与吸烟问题,并关注性交频率与治疗依从性。
核心结论
- 作者呼吁对不孕症采取更明智、更务实的诊疗路径,更多关注备孕时长、不良生活习惯与治疗依从性这些被忽视但作者认为至关重要的方面。
研究设计与样本
- 原文为发表于《Human Reproduction》的观点性文章,未报告系统检索范围或样本量。
主要发现
- 不孕症诊疗中诊断与治疗可延续很长时间甚至数年,且诊断工具组合的准确性并非最优。
- 诊断的不确定性与对坚持治疗的需求给夫妇和医生带来压力,构成过度诊断「不明原因不孕」与过度治疗体外受精的有利条件,也可能影响治疗依从性。
- 多数不孕原因会降低但不会损害自然受孕。
- 在较年长女性中更早启动治疗并不明智,因为该人群生育力较低,备孕时长对获得可靠不孕诊断更为重要。
关键数值与推荐
- 无异常检查结果时,无论年龄,备孕时长应延长至2年以上再作出不明原因不孕的诊断。
- 即使干预性研究结论不确定,仍建议处理肥胖与吸烟问题。
- 关注性交频率可能对自然受孕有益。
- 在治疗开始时提供关于坚持治疗重要性的信息、促进共同决策以及处理患者、诊所和治疗方面的退出原因,均可改善总体获得亲职的机会。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应更多关注备孕时长,在无异常检查结果时延长备孕至2年以上再诊断不明原因不孕。
- 作者建议处理肥胖与吸烟问题,关注性交频率,并在治疗开始时提供坚持治疗重要性的信息、促进共同决策及处理退出原因。
- 作者建议在较年长女性中不应更早启动治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Infertility represents a very peculiar area of medicine. Contrary to other areas, where signs and symptoms lead to a diagnosis, which in turn leads to a specific treatment, in reproduction the lack of signs and symptoms for more than 12 months suggests the diagnosis of 'unexplained subfertility', and if this condition has lasted for some years, couples qualify for IVF. Diagnosis and treatments can extend over long periods of time (even years) and the accuracy of the diagnostic armamentarium is not optimal. Uncertainty about diagnosis and the need for significant perseverance is demanding on both couples and physicians, and actually constitute a very favourable situation for overdiagnosis ('unexplained subfertility') and overtreatment (IVF) on one hand, and, on the other, it may also affect compliance with treatments. To improve our capacity to properly handle this challenging situation, increased attention should be given to the duration of pregnancy seeking. Initiating treatments earlier in older women is unwise because this population has a lower fecundity and, therefore, duration of pregnancy seeking is even more important to achieve a reliable diagnosis of infertility. Moreover, if the infertility work-up is unremarkable, duration of pregnancy seeking should be extended up to more than 2 years prior to making a diagnosis of unexplained infertility regardless of age. An adequate period of pregnancy seeking is also required for couples who are diagnosed with conditions that can interfere with fertility to avoid overdiagnosis and overtreatment. Indeed, most causes of infertility will reduce but not impair natural conception. Within this sometimes long-term management, physicians should also pay attention to detrimental life habits in order to optimize the chances of both natural and assisted reproduction technology -mediated pregnancy. Even if interventional studies are not conclusive, it is advisable to address the problems of obesity and smoking. Focussing on frequency of sexual intercourse may be also beneficial for natural conception. Finally, there is the need for improving our capacity to handle compliance. Providing information on the importance of persevering at the start of treatment, promoting shared decision-making and tackling patient, clinic and treatment causes of drop-out can all improve the overall chances of parenthood. Thus, we plead for a wiser and more pragmatic approach to infertility, paying more attention to these neglected, but in our opinion essential, aspects of infertility care.
引用
- Towards a more pragmatic and wiser approach to infertility care. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31241741. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez101
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。