远程监测增强的减少就诊产前保健模式的随机比较
在美国中西部一家门诊产科三级学术中心开展单中心随机对照试验,将300名孕龄<13周的孕妇随机分为OB Nest组与常规保健组各150例。OB Nest组接受8次现场预约、6次虚拟访视及家庭胎心多普勒和血压计监测,常规组接受12次预约产检。OB Nest组患者满意度更高(93.9% vs 78.9%,P<.01),孕14周和36周妊娠相关压力更低,两组照护质量感知、美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)推荐服务依从性及母婴临床结局相似。
要点
- OB Nest组患者满意度93.9%高于常规组78.9%(P<.01)。
- OB Nest组孕14周和36周妊娠相关压力低于常规组。
- 两组ACOG推荐产前服务依从性及母婴临床结局相似。
核心结论
- OB Nest是一种创新、可接受且有效的减少就诊频率的产前保健模式。
- 与常规产前保健相比,OB Nest提高患者满意度并降低产前压力,同时减少临床医生预约次数并维持保健标准。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心随机对照试验,从美国中西部一家门诊产科三级学术中心招募18-36岁孕妇。
- 300名孕龄<13周的孕妇采用最小化算法随机分为OB Nest组或常规保健组,每组150例。
- OB Nest组接受8次现场预约、6次与指定护士的电话或在线虚拟访视,并辅以家庭胎心多普勒和血压计监测设备及在线孕妇社区。
- 常规保健组接受12次预先安排的产科医生门诊预约。
主要发现
- OB Nest组在100分制改良Littlefield和Adams满意度量表上满意度为93.9%,常规组为78.9%(P<.01)。
- OB Nest组孕14周妊娠相关压力评分为0.32,常规组为0.41(P<.01)。
- OB Nest组孕36周妊娠相关压力评分为0.34,常规组为0.40(P<.03)。
- 两组照护质量感知无统计学差异。
- 两组ACOG推荐产前服务依从性相似,母婴临床结局相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 满意度采用100分制改良Littlefield和Adams满意度量表测量。
- 妊娠相关压力采用0-2分PreNatal Maternal Stress量表测量,分数越高表示压力水平越高。
- 依从性依据ACOG推荐的常规产前及辅助服务进行评估。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为OB Nest是一种创新、可接受且有效的减少就诊频率的产前保健模式,是迈向循证驱动产前保健的一步,可提高患者满意度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Standard prenatal care, consisting of 12-14 visits per pregnancy, is expensive and resource intensive, with limited evidence supporting the structure, rhythm, or components of care. Some studies suggest a reduced-frequency prenatal care model is as safe as the standard model of care for low-risk pregnant women, but evidence is limited. We developed and evaluated an innovative, technology-enhanced, reduced prenatal visit model (OB Nest). OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the acceptability and effectiveness of OB Nest, a reduced-frequency prenatal care model enhanced with remote home monitoring devices and nursing support. STUDY DESIGN: A single-center randomized controlled trial, composed of pregnant women, aged 18-36 years, recruited from an outpatient obstetric tertiary academic center in the Midwest United States. OB Nest care consisted of 8 onsite appointments with an obstetric provider; 6 virtual visits consisting of phone or online communication with an assigned nurse, supplemented with fetal Doppler and sphygmomanometer home monitoring devices; and access to an online community of pregnant women. Usual care consisted of 12 prescheduled prenatal clinic appointments with obstetric providers. Acceptability of OB Nest was measured by validated surveys of patient satisfaction with care at 36 weeks; perception of stress at 14, 24, and 36 weeks; and perceived quality of care at 36 weeks of gestation. Effectiveness was analyzed by comparing adherence to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommended routine prenatal and ancillary services, maternal and fetal safety outcomes, and healthcare utilization. RESULTS: Three hundred pregnant women at <13 weeks of gestation were recruited and randomized to OB Nest or usual care (150 in each arm) using a minimization algorithm. Demographic characteristics were similar between groups. Compared to usual care, patients in OB Nest had higher satisfaction on a 100-point validated modified Littlefield and Adams Satisfaction scale (OB Nest = 93.9% vs usual care = 78.9%, P < .01). Pregnancy-related stress, measured, on a 0-2 point PreNatal Maternal Stress validated scale, with higher scores indicating higher levels of stress, was lower among OB Nest participants at 14 weeks (OB Nest = 0.32 vs usual care = 0.41, P < .01) and at 36 weeks of gestation (OB Nest = 0.34 vs usual care = 0.40, P < .03). There was no statistical difference in perceived quality of care. Adherence to the provision of American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists prenatal services was similar in both arms. Maternal and fetal clinical outcomes were similar between groups. Total reported nursing time was higher in OB Nest (OB Nest = 171.2 minutes vs usual care = 108.2 minutes, 95% confidence interval, 48.7-77.4). CONCLUSION: OB Nest is an innovative, acceptable, and effective reduced-frequency prenatal care model. Compared to routine prenatal care, OB Nest resulted in higher patient satisfaction and lower prenatal stress, while reducing the number of appointments with clinicians and maintaining care standards for pregnant women. This program is a step toward evidence-driven prenatal care that improves patient satisfaction.
引用
- Butler Tobah YS, LeBlanc A, Branda ME, et al. Randomized comparison of a reduced-visit prenatal care model enhanced with remote monitoring. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31228414. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2019.06.034
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。