文献速递妇科

当前实践中的微型腹腔镜全子宫切除术可行性与获益:单中心随机对照试验

Minilaparoscopic Total Hysterectomy in Current Practice Feasibility and Benefits: A Unicentric, Randomized Controlled Trial.
PubMed 文献 · J Minim Invasive Gynecol · 2019-06-04

单中心随机对照单盲平行非劣效试验,2015年4月2日至2018年6月1日纳入32例良性妇科疾病行子宫切除术患者,16例用3毫米器械(A组)、16例用5毫米器械(B组)。A组手术时间128分钟(范围122-150分钟)vs B组111分钟(范围92-143分钟),δ=17(90%CI -6至39),拒绝35分钟非劣效阈值。结论:微型腹腔镜全子宫切除术在手术时间和术者工作条件方面劣于标准腹腔镜,仅短期美容外观有利于3毫米入路。

要点

  • 3毫米组手术时间128分钟(范围122-150分钟)vs 5毫米组111分钟(范围92-143分钟),δ=17(90%CI -6至39),拒绝35分钟非劣效阈值。
  • 31%初始使用3毫米器械的子宫切除术转为传统器械完成。
  • 微型器械手术需要更多注意力(p=.02),术者报告更高挫败感(p=.009)和失败感(p=.006)。

核心结论

  • 微型腹腔镜全子宫切除术在手术时间和术者工作条件方面劣于标准腹腔镜,仅短期美容外观有利于3毫米入路。

研究设计与样本

  • 单中心、随机对照、单盲、平行、非劣效试验,比较两种手术技术。
  • 2015年4月2日至2018年6月1日在一家三级转诊中心纳入32例因良性妇科疾病行子宫切除术的患者,A组16例、B组16例。
  • A组使用3毫米器械行子宫切除术加双侧附件切除术或保留卵巢,B组使用传统5毫米器械。

主要发现

  • A组子宫切除术手术时间128分钟(范围122-150分钟)vs B组111分钟(范围92-143分钟),δ=17(90%CI -6至39),拒绝35分钟非劣效阈值。
  • 31%初始使用3毫米器械的子宫切除术转为传统器械完成。
  • 微型器械子宫切除术需要更多注意力(p=.02),术者报告更高挫败感(p=.009)和失败感(p=.006)。
  • 术后随访疤痕疼痛:3毫米组1例中度疼痛 vs 5毫米组4例中度疼痛(患者疤痕评估量表30-50毫米)。
  • 疤痕硬度:p=.021;3毫米组3例中度硬度 vs 5毫米组7例中度硬度(患者疤痕评估量表30-50毫米)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether mini-instrumentation may be used for hysterectomy (HT) by all surgeons (assistants and seniors) without increasing the operative time or altering surgeon working conditions. DESIGN: A unicenter, randomized controlled, single blind, parallel, noninferiority trial comparing 2 surgical techniques. SETTING: A tertiary referral center. PATIENTS: Thirty-two patients undergoing HT for a benign gynecologic disease were enrolled in this study in our center between April 2, 2015, and June 1, 2018. Sixteen patients were randomized in group A and 16 patients in group B. INTERVENTIONS: HT with bilateral annexectomy or ovarian conservation using 3-mm instruments (group A) or conventional 5-mm instruments (group B). MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Concerning the primary outcome, the operative time for the HT 3-mm group was 128 minutes (range, 122-150 minutes) versus 111 minutes (range, 92-143 minutes) for the HT 5-mm group (i.e., δ = 17 [90% confidence interval, -6 to 39]), with rejection of the noninferiority threshold at 35 minutes. Thirty-one percent of HTs initially performed using 3-mm instruments were completed with conventional instruments. HTs performed with mini-instruments required more concentration (p = .02) with surgeons reporting higher levels of frustration (p = .009) and sense of failure (p = .006). Patients tend to experience greater satisfaction regarding scars with a significant difference noted during the postoperative visit both for scar pain (1 vs 4 patients with moderate pain [30-50 mm on the Patient Scar Assessment Scale) in the HT 3-mm group and the HT 5-mm group, respectively) and scar firmness (p = .021; 3 vs 7 patients with moderate firmness [30-50 mm on the Patient Scar Assessment Scale] in the HT 3-mm group and the HT 5-mm group, respectively). CONCLUSION: Total minilaparoscopic HT appears inferior to standard laparoscopy in terms of operative time and surgeon working conditions; only the short-term cosmetic appearance was in favor of the 3-mm approach.

来源:J Minim Invasive Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Béguinot M, Botchorishvili R, Comptour A, et al. Minilaparoscopic Total Hysterectomy in Current Practice Feasibility and Benefits: A Unicentric, Randomized Controlled Trial. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31173939. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2019.05.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。