不明原因不孕症夫妇的体外受精治疗:谁应接受治疗?
本研究比较了英国接受体外受精(IVF)的不明原因不孕症夫妇(n=40 921)与荷兰前瞻性全国队列(n=4875)及苏格兰阿伯丁回顾性区域队列(n=975)中期待管理夫妇的结局。调整后IVF组1年持续妊娠的受孕机会为47.9%(95%CI:45.0-50.9),期待管理组为26.1%(95%CI:24.2-28.0),绝对差为21.8%(95%CI:18.3-25.3),支持IVF。IVF对40岁以下女性有效,但34岁以上女性IVF受孕机会急剧下降;40岁以上女性IVF效果较差,与期待管理相比绝对差为10%或更低。
要点
- 调整后IVF组1年受孕机会47.9% vs 期待管理组26.1%,绝对差21.8%支持IVF。
- IVF对40岁以下女性有效,但34岁以上女性IVF受孕机会急剧下降。
- 40岁以上女性IVF效果较差,与期待管理相比绝对差为10%或更低。
核心结论
- 对于女性年龄40岁以下的不明原因不孕症夫妇,IVF与比期待管理更高的受孕机会相关。
- IVF的效果受女性年龄、不孕持续时间和既往妊娠影响。
- 无论女性年龄如何,对于继发性不孕持续时间短(1年)且自然受孕机会为30%或以上的夫妇,IVF效果也较差。
研究设计与样本
- 比较英国注册数据中接受IVF的不明原因不孕症夫妇(n=40 921)与期待管理夫妇的结局。
- 期待管理夫妇包括荷兰前瞻性全国队列(n=4875)和苏格兰阿伯丁回顾性区域队列(n=975)。
- 排除尝试受孕不足1年、无排卵、单侧或双侧输卵管阻塞、轻度或重度子宫内膜异位症或男性不育(根据世界卫生组织标准精液质量受损)的夫妇。
- 基于夫妇特征进行匹配以控制混杂,拟合Cox比例风险模型包括患者特征、IVF治疗及其交互作用,估计个体化1年受孕机会。
- 终点为导致持续妊娠的受孕,定义为胎儿达到至少12周孕龄。
主要发现
- 调整后1年受孕机会在IVF后为47.9%(95%CI:45.0-50.9),期待管理后为26.1%(95%CI:24.2-28.0)。
- 平均调整后1年受孕机会的绝对差为21.8%(95%CI:18.3-25.3),支持IVF。
- IVF对40岁以下女性有效,但34岁以上女性IVF 1年受孕机会急剧下降。
- 40岁以上女性中,IVF效果较差,与期待管理相比机会绝对差为10%或更低。
- 无论女性年龄如何,对于继发性不孕持续时间短(1年)且自然受孕机会为30%或以上的夫妇,IVF效果也较差。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,IVF应基于对特定夫妇与继续期待管理相比的获益判断进行选择性使用。
- 作者认为,结果可用于临床医生咨询不明原因不孕症夫妇,告知其期望并促进循证共同决策。
局限性
- 1年受孕机会基于三个采样机制不同的队列。
- 尽管调整了三个最重要的预后患者特征(女性年龄、不孕持续时间和原发性或继发性不孕),估计值可能无法免于残余混杂。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Which couples with unexplained subfertility can expect increased chances of ongoing pregnancy with IVF compared to expectant management? SUMMARY ANSWER: For couples in which the woman is under 40 years of age, IVF is associated with higher chances of conception than expectant management. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: The clinical indications for IVF have expanded over time from bilateral tubal blockage to include unexplained subfertility in which there is no identifiable barrier to conception. Yet, there is little evidence from randomized controlled trials that IVF is effective in these couples. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: We compared outcomes in British couples with unexplained subfertility undergoing IVF (n = 40 921) from registry data to couples with the same type of subfertility on expectant management. Those couples on expectant management (defined as no intervention aside from the advice to have intercourse) comprised a prospective nation-wide Dutch cohort (n = 4875) and a retrospective regional cohort from Aberdeen, Scotland (n = 975). We excluded couples who had tried for <1 year to conceive and also those with anovulation, uni- or bilateral tubal occlusion, mild or severe endometriosis or male subfertility i.e. impaired semen quality according to World Health Organization criteria. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: We matched couples who received IVF and couples on expectant management based on their characteristics to control for confounding. We fitted a Cox proportional hazards model including patient characteristics, IVF treatment and their interactions to estimate the individualized chance of conception over 1 year-either following IVF or expectant management for all combinations of patient characteristics. The endpoint was conception leading to ongoing pregnancy, defined as a foetus reaching a gestational age of at least 12 weeks. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The adjusted 1-year chance of conception was 47.9% (95% CI: 45.0-50.9) after IVF and 26.1% (95% CI: 24.2-28.0) after expectant management. The absolute difference in the average adjusted 1-year chances of conception was 21.8% (95%CI: 18.3-25.3) in favour of IVF. The effectiveness of IVF was influenced by female age, duration of subfertility and previous pregnancy. IVF was effective in women under 40 years, but the 1-year chance of an IVF conception declined sharply in women over 34 years. In contrast, in woman over 40 years of age, IVF was less effective, with an absolute difference in chance compared to expectant management of 10% or lower. Regardless of female age, IVF was also less effective in couples with a short period of secondary subfertility (1 year) who had chances of natural conception of 30% or above. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The 1-year chances of conception were based on three cohorts with different sampling mechanisms. Despite adjustment for the three most important prognostic patient characteristics, namely female age, duration of subfertility and primary or secondary subfertility, our estimates might not be free from residual confounding. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: IVF should be used selectively based on judgements on gain compared to continuing expectant management for a given couple. Our results can be used by clinicians to counsel couples with unexplained subfertility, to inform their expectations and facilitate evidence-based, shared decision making. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This work was supported by Tenovus Scotland [grant G17.04]. Travel for RvE was supported by the Amsterdam Reproduction & Development Research Group [grant V.000296]. SB reports acting as editor-in-chief of HROpen. Other authors have no conflicts.
引用
- van Eekelen R, van Geloven N, van Wely M, et al. IVF for unexplained subfertility; whom should we treat? Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 31194864. doi:10.1093/humrep/dez072
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。