36家辅助生殖实验室使用同一质控应用监测环境条件和仪器参数的比较
研究比较了12个国家36家辅助生殖实验室使用同一云端质控应用监测仪器参数的做法。培养箱参数占比最高(35%),表面加温仪占15%;培养箱O2读数多在4.5%–5.5%,CO2多在5.5%–6.5%;实验室海拔与CO2设定相关性差;内置传感器与第三方传感器读数差异较大。质控勤勉评分与仪器数量或实验室规模无关,较高评分与有政府法规和强制审计系统的国家相关。
要点
- 培养箱参数占所有监测参数的35%,表面加温仪占15%。
- 培养箱O2读数多在4.5%–5.5%,CO2多在5.5%–6.5%。
- 质控勤勉评分与仪器数量或实验室规模无关,较高评分与有政府法规和强制审计系统的国家相关。
核心结论
- 各实验室在仪器监测实践上存在重大差异,培养箱监测是最大领域,但多数实验室也勤勉监测许多其他敏感仪器,需要国际标准化和指南。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入36家订阅同一质量保证应用的去标识化体外受精(IVF)实验室,数据按仪器类型归入10个领域评估。
主要发现
- 培养箱领域占参数比例最大(35%),其次为表面加温仪(15%)。
- 多数培养箱O2读数监测在4.5%–5.5%之间,CO2在5.5%–6.5%之间。
- 实验室海拔与CO2设定相关性差。
- 培养箱内置传感器显示和测得的气体与温度值与第三方传感器相比差异相当大。
- 质控勤勉评分或平均数据点与仪器数量或实验室规模无关,较高评分与有政府法规和强制审计系统的国家相关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: Assisted reproduction laboratories record instrument performance periodically. No standardized guidelines have been produced for this activity despite mandatory auditing systems in several countries. This study of 36 laboratories in 12 different countries was conducted to assess differences and similarities between quality assurance programmes using an adaptable cloud-based quality-control app for instrument monitoring. DESIGN: A total of 36 deidentified IVF laboratories that subscribed to the same quality-assurance application were studied. Data were evaluated based on instrument types allocated to 10 domains: incubators, gas tanks, warming surfaces, refrigerators and freezers, cryo-storage, environment, water purification, peripheral equipment, checklists and miscellaneous. RESULTS: The incubator domain constituted the greatest proportion of parameters (35%), followed by surface warming instruments at 15%. Most incubator O2 readings were monitored between 4.5 and 5.5%, and between 5.5 and 6.5% for CO2. The altitude of the laboratory was poorly correlated with the CO2 setting. Incubator display and measured values of gases and temperature by built-in sensors vary considerably compared with third-party sensors. A quality-control diligence score or mean average data points was calculated for each laboratory. This score is independent of number of instruments or laboratory size. Higher scores were associated with laboratories in countries with government regulations and mandatory auditing systems. CONCLUSIONS: Major differences exist in instrument monitoring practices among laboratories. Although incubator monitoring is the largest domain, many other sensitive instruments are diligently monitored by most laboratories. International standardization and guidelines are needed.
引用
- Palmer GA, Kratka C, Szvetecz S, et al. Comparison of 36 assisted reproduction laboratories monitoring environmental conditions and instrument parameters using the same quality-control application. Reprod Biomed Online. 2019. PMID: 31126717. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2019.03.204
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。