文献速递妇科

治疗卵巢癌医院的年最小手术量标准的潜在后果

Potential Consequences of Minimum-Volume Standards for Hospitals Treating Women With Ovarian Cancer.
PubMed 文献 · Obstet Gynecol · 2019-01-01

该研究利用美国国家癌症数据库2005至2015年数据,分析1321家医院共136196例卵巢癌患者,发现医院年手术量增加与60天、1年、2年和5年死亡率降低相关。若实施年最小手术量标准(如上年至少1例或3例),将分别导致13.6%或34.5%的医院被限制收治,其中包括许多结局优于预期的中心。

要点

  • 医院年手术量增加与60天、1年、2年和5年死亡率降低相关(P值分别为.004、<.001、<.001、.008)。
  • 若以上年至少1例为最小手术量标准,2015年将排除144家(13.6%)医院,这些医院治疗了2.6%的患者。
  • 上年手术量为1例的医院中,49.2%的2年死亡率观察/预期比值≥1(表现差于预期),50.8%的比值<1(表现优于预期)。

核心结论

  • 实施医院最小手术量标准可能限制大量医院的诊疗,包括许多结局优于预期的中心。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于美国国家癌症数据库的回顾性队列研究,纳入2005至2015年治疗的136196例卵巢癌患者,来自1321家医院。
  • 采用多变量模型估计60天、1年、2年和5年死亡率的观察/预期比值,并模拟实施最小手术量标准的影响。

主要发现

  • 医院年手术量增加与60天死亡率(P=.004)、1年死亡率(P<.001)、2年死亡率(P<.001)和5年死亡率(P=.008)降低相关。
  • 2015年,以上年至少1例为最小手术量标准将排除144家(13.6%)医院,这些医院治疗了2.6%的患者;以上年至少3例为标准将排除364家(34.5%)医院,治疗了7.7%的患者。
  • 上年手术量为1例的医院,平均观察/预期比值:60天死亡率1.14,1年死亡率1.06,2年死亡率1.12,5年死亡率1.08。
  • 上年手术量为1例的医院中,49.2%的2年死亡率观察/预期比值≥1(差于预期),50.8%的比值<1(优于预期)。
  • 上年手术量≤2例的医院,平均观察/预期比值:60天死亡率1.11,1年死亡率1.09,2年死亡率1.08,5年死亡率1.07。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To assess the potential effects of implementing minimum hospital volume standards for ovarian cancer on survival and access to care. METHODS: We used the National Cancer Database to identify hospitals treating women with ovarian cancer from 2005 to 2015. We estimated the number of patients treated by each hospital during the prior year. Multivariable models were used to estimate the ratio of observed/expected 60-day, and 1-, 2- and 5-year mortalities. The mean predicted observed/expected ratio of hospitals was plotted based on prior year volume. The number of hospitals that would be restricted if minimum-volume standards were implemented was modeled. RESULTS: A total of 136,196 patients treated at 1,321 hospitals were identified. Increasing hospital volume was associated with decreased 60-day (P=.004), 1-year (P<.001), 2-year (P<.001) and 5-year (P=.008) mortality. In 2015, using a minimum-volume cutpoint of one case in the prior year would eliminate 144 (13.6%) hospitals (treated 2.6% of all patients); a cutpoint of three would eliminate 364 (34.5%) hospitals (treated 7.7% of the patients). The mean observed/expected ratios for hospitals with a prior year volume of 1 was 1.14 for 60-day mortality, 1.06 for 1-year mortality, 1.12 for 2-year mortality, and 1.08 for 5-year mortality. Among hospitals with a prior year volume of one, 49.2% had an observed/expected ratio for 2-year mortality of at least 1 (indicating worse than expected performance), and 50.8% had an observed/expected ratio of less than 1 (indicating better than expected performance). The mean observed/expected ratios for hospitals with a prior year volume of two or less were 1.11 for 60-day mortality, 1.09 for 1-year mortality, 1.08 for 2-year mortality, and 1.07 for 5-year mortality. Implementing a minimum-volume standard of one case in the prior year would result in one fewer death for every 198 patients at 60 days, for every 613 patients at 1 year, and for every 62 patients at 5 years. CONCLUSION: Implementation of minimum hospital volume standards could restrict care at a significant number of hospitals, including many centers with better-than-predicted outcomes.

来源:Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wright JD, Huang Y, Melamed A, et al. Potential Consequences of Minimum-Volume Standards for Hospitals Treating Women With Ovarian Cancer. Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 31135724. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000003288

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。