文献速递产科

住院医师在主治产科医师监督下与主治产科医师本人管理的手术阴道分娩结局:一项前瞻性横断面研究

Outcomes of operative vaginal delivery managed by residents under supervision and attending obstetricians: a prospective cross-sectional study.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2019-02-23

该研究为一项5年前瞻性研究的二次分析,纳入2192例在三级大学医院尝试手术阴道分娩的单胎足月头位活产孕妇,比较住院医师在主治医师监督下与主治医师本人管理的手术阴道分娩的严重母儿病率。结果显示,住院医师管理组严重新生儿病率在未匹配分析中显著更低,但倾向性评分匹配后母儿病率均无显著差异;作者认为住院医师在监督下进行手术阴道分娩培训不增加母儿病率。

要点

  • 住院医师管理组严重母体病率为7.8%(115/1475),主治医师组为9.9%(48/484)。
  • 住院医师管理组严重新生儿病率为8.3%(123/1475),主治医师组为15.1%(73/484)。
  • 倾向性评分匹配后,住院医师管理与严重母体病率(aOR 0.74,95%CI 0.39-1.38)及新生儿病率(aOR 0.51,95%CI 0.25-1.04)均无显著关联。

核心结论

  • 住院医师在主治产科医师监督下管理尝试性手术阴道分娩,与主治医师本人管理相比,似乎与母体或新生儿病率均无关联。
  • 作者认为这些令人安心的结果支持继续在主治产科医师监督下开展住院医师手术阴道分娩培训项目。

研究设计与样本

  • 一项为期5年的前瞻性研究的二次分析,采用横断面分析,纳入2192例在三级大学医院尝试手术阴道分娩的单胎足月头位活产孕妇。
  • 按操作者经验分为两组:主治产科医师(经验≥5年)和产科住院医师(经验<5年,在主治医师监督下)。
  • 采用多变量逻辑回归和倾向性评分方法比较两组结局。

主要发现

  • 主治医师管理组中,孕前高体重指数、高剂量缩宫素、手法旋转、持续性枕后位或横位、手术室分娩、中骨盆分娩、产钳和铲钳的使用显著更频繁;住院医师管理组中,第二产程用力阶段超过30分钟显著更频繁。
  • 严重母体病率:住院医师组7.8%(115/1475) vs 主治医师组9.9%(48/484)。
  • 严重新生儿病率:住院医师组8.3%(123/1475) vs 主治医师组15.1%(73/484)。
  • 在单变量、多变量和敏感性分析中,住院医师管理的手术阴道分娩与严重新生儿病率显著负相关,但与母体病率无显著关联。
  • 倾向性评分匹配后,住院医师管理与严重母体病率无显著关联(调整比值比0.74;95%置信区间0.39-1.38),与新生儿病率也不再关联(调整比值比0.51;95%置信区间0.25-1.04)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 严重母体病率定义为:三度或四度会阴裂伤、会阴血肿、宫颈裂伤、剖宫产子宫切口延长、产后出血>1500 mL、手术止血操作、子宫动脉栓塞、输血、感染、血栓栓塞事件、入住重症监护室或孕产妇死亡。
  • 严重新生儿病率定义为:5分钟Apgar评分<7、脐动脉pH<7.00、需要复苏或插管、新生儿创伤、大于2级的脑室内出血、入住新生儿重症监护室超过24小时、惊厥、败血症或新生儿死亡。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,在主治产科医师监督下由住院医师管理尝试性手术阴道分娩,与主治医师本人管理相比,似乎不增加母体或新生儿病率。
  • 作者认为这些结果支持继续在主治产科医师监督下开展住院医师手术阴道分娩培训项目。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: To assess both severe maternal and neonatal mortality and morbidity after attempted operative vaginal deliveries by residents under supervision and by attending obstetricians. STUDY DESIGN: Secondary analysis of a 5-year prospective study with cross-sectional analysis including 2192 women with live singleton term fetuses in vertex presentation who underwent an attempted operative vaginal delivery in a tertiary care university hospital. Obstetricians who attempted or performed an operative vaginal delivery were classified into 2 groups according to their level of experience: attending obstetricians (who had 5 years or more of experience) and obstetric residents (who had less than 5 years of experience) under the supervision of an attending obstetrician. We used multivariate logistic regression and propensity score methods to compare outcomes associated with attending obstetricians and obstetric residents. Severe maternal morbidity was defined as third- or fourth-degree perineal laceration, perineal hematoma, cervical laceration, extended uterine incision for cesareans, postpartum hemorrhage >1500 mL, surgical hemostatic procedures, uterine artery embolization, blood transfusion, infection, thromboembolic events, admission to the intensive care unit, or maternal death; severe neonatal morbidity was defined as a 5-minute Apgar score <7, umbilical artery pH <7.00, need for resuscitation or intubation, neonatal trauma, intraventricular hemorrhage greater than grade 2, neonatal intensive care unit admission for more than 24 hours, convulsions, sepsis, or neonatal death. RESULTS: High prepregnancy body mass index, high dose of oxytocin, manual rotation, persistent occiput posterior or transverse positions, operating room delivery, midpelvic delivery, forceps, and spatulas were significantly more frequent in deliveries managed by attending obstetricians than residents whereas a second-stage pushing phase longer than 30 minutes was significantly more frequent in deliveries managed by residents. The rate of severe maternal morbidity was 7.8% (115/1475) for residents vs 9.9% (48/484) for attending obstetricians; for severe neonatal morbidity, the rates were 8.3% (123/1475) vs 15.1% (73/484), respectively. In the univariate, multivariable, and sensitivity analyses, attempted operative vaginal delivery managed by a resident was significantly and inversely associated with severe neonatal but not maternal morbidity. After propensity score matching, delivery managed by a resident was not significantly associated with severe maternal morbidity (adjusted odds ratio, 0.74; 95% confidence interval, 0.39-1.38) and was no longer associated with neonatal morbidity (adjusted odds ratio, 0.51; 95% confidence interval, 0.25-1.04). CONCLUSION: Management of attempted operative vaginal deliveries by residents under the supervision of attending obstetricians, compared with by the attending obstetricians themselves, does not appear to be associated with either maternal or neonatal morbidity. These reassuring results support the continued use of residency programs for training in operative vaginal deliveries under the supervision of attending obstetricians.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sentilhes L, Madar H, Ducarme G, et al. Outcomes of operative vaginal delivery managed by residents under supervision and attending obstetricians: a prospective cross-sectional study. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 30807764. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2019.02.044

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。