剖宫产后阴道分娩预测模型准确吗?
本研究在单一三级转诊队列中比较Grobman 2007、Grobman 2009和Metz 2013三个剖宫产后阴道分娩成功预测模型的准确性。共纳入404例,实际成功率为75%(305/404)。三模型一致性指数分别为0.717、0.703和0.727,校准分析显示Grobman 2007与Metz模型在预测概率>60%时最准确,<60%时低估实际成功率。
要点
- 404例中剖宫产后阴道分娩成功率为75%(305/404),三模型一致性指数在0.703至0.727之间。
- Grobman 2007与Metz模型在预测概率>60%时最准确,<60%时低估实际成功率。
- Grobman 2007与Metz模型在阈值概率60-90%间净获益最大,低于该范围时与全部推荐剖宫产后阴道分娩策略相比无净获益。
核心结论
- 在同一人群中比较3个常用剖宫产后阴道分娩预测模型时,各模型性能存在差异,可能影响机构对模型的选择。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为在学术健康系统内开展的队列分析,回顾2013年5月至2016年3月间剖宫产后试产失败及剖宫产后阴道分娩成功的所有病例。
- 纳入有1次剖宫产史、本次试产为足月(≥37周)、头位、单胎妊娠的妇女,排除产前宫内胎儿死亡或胎儿畸形者。
- 共404例符合纳入标准,以Grobman 2007、Grobman 2009和Metz 2013三个模型计算剖宫产后阴道分娩成功概率并与实际结局比较。
- 模型性能采用一致性指数、Brier评分和校准图评价,并以决策曲线分析确定最佳模型具有临床价值的阈值概率范围。
主要发现
- 观察到的剖宫产后阴道分娩成功率为75%(305/404)。
- Grobman 2007、Grobman 2009和Metz 2013模型的一致性指数分别为0.717(95%CI 0.659-0.778)、0.703(95%CI 0.647-0.758)和0.727(95%CI 0.669-0.779)。
- 三个模型的Brier评分分别为0.172、0.205和0.179。
- 校准分析显示Grobman 2007与Metz模型在预测概率>60%时最准确,对不希望剖宫产后阴道分娩但预测成功率60-90%的妇女咨询有益。
- 模型在预测成功率<60%时低估实际概率;Grobman 2007与Metz模型在阈值概率60-90%间净获益最大,在较低预测成功概率下与全部推荐剖宫产后阴道分娩策略相比无净获益。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,在机构层面常规应用预测模型前,建议先在机构目标人群中检验模型性能,以了解模型对目标人群的总体准确性及校准情况。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The use of trial of labor after cesarean delivery calculators in the prediction of successful vaginal birth after cesarean delivery gives physicians an evidence-based tool to assist with patient counseling and risk stratification. Before deployment of prediction models for routine care at an institutional level, it is recommended to test their performance initially in the institution's target population. This allows the institution to understand not only the overall accuracy of the model for the intended population but also to comprehend where the accuracy of the model is most limited when predicting across the range of predictions (calibration). OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare 3 models that predict successful vaginal birth after cesarean delivery with the use of a single tertiary referral cohort before continuous model deployment in the electronic medical record. STUDY DESIGN: All cesarean births for failed trial of labor after cesarean delivery and successful vaginal birth after cesarean delivery at an academic health system between May 2013 and March 2016 were reviewed. Women with a history of 1 previous cesarean birth who underwent a trial of labor with a term (≥37 weeks gestation), cephalic, and singleton gestation were included. Women with antepartum intrauterine fetal death or fetal anomalies were excluded. The probability of successful vaginal birth after cesarean delivery was calculated with the use of 3 prediction models: Grobman 2007, Grobman 2009, and Metz 2013 and compared with actual vaginal birth after cesarean delivery success. Each model's performance was measured with the use of concordance indices, Brier scores, and calibration plots. Decision curve analysis identified the range of threshold probabilities for which the best prediction model would be of clinical value. RESULTS: Four hundred four women met the eligibility criteria. The observed rate of successful vaginal birth after cesarean delivery was 75% (305/404). Concordance indices were 0.717 (95% confidence interval, 0.659-0.778), 0.703 (95% confidence interval, 0.647-0.758), and 0.727 (95% confidence interval, 0.669-0.779), respectively. Brier scores were 0.172, 0.205, and 0.179, respectively. Calibration demonstrated that Grobman 2007 and Metz vaginal birth after cesarean delivery models were most accurate when predicted probabilities were >60% and were beneficial for counseling women who did not desire to have vaginal birth after cesarean delivery but had a predicted success rates of 60-90%. The models underpredicted actual probabilities when predicting success at <60%. The Grobman 2007 and Metz vaginal birth after cesarean delivery models provided greatest net benefit between threshold probabilities of 60-90% but did not provide a net benefit with lower predicted probabilities of success compared with a strategy of recommending vaginal birth after cesarean delivery for all women . CONCLUSION: When 3 commonly used vaginal birth after cesarean delivery prediction models are compared in the same population, there are differences in performance that may affect an institution's choice of which model to use.
引用
- Harris BS, Heine RP, Park J, et al. Are prediction models for vaginal birth after cesarean accurate? Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 30716285. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2019.01.232
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。