分析多周期体外受精数据的方法学探讨
本研究基于EARTH前瞻性队列中442名女性642个IVF周期,比较仅取首周期与纳入多周期的多种统计模型,发现混合效应模型和GEE均可处理多周期数据,其中CWGEE模型置信区间最窄,并建议IVF数据分析应报告风险而非比值。
要点
- 混合效应模型和GEE模型可纳入多周期数据,可能减少仅用首周期方法的偏倚。
- CWGEE模型置信区间最窄,计算简单且对协方差结构误设稳健。
- IVF数据分析中应估计风险而非比值。
核心结论
- CWGEE模型在多周期IVF数据分析中应被更广泛考虑,其置信区间通常最窄,可能提示估计最精确。
- 在IVF数据分析中应强调估计风险而非比值。
研究设计与样本
- 环境与生殖健康(EARTH)研究是一项在学术医疗中心开展的持续前瞻性队列研究,自2004年建立,随访因不孕接受治疗的夫妇。
- 纳入2004至2017年入组、年龄18-46岁、至少启动一个IVF周期的女性,周期启动定义为开始促排卵并计划进行IVF或ICSI周期。
- 分析纳入符合标准的442名女性共642个周期。
- 比较限制于首周期的对数二项模型和逻辑模型,以及纳入所有周期的混合效应模型、未加权GEE模型和CWGEE模型。
- 分析两种暴露:周期启动时的母亲年龄,以及母亲孕前尿中邻苯二甲酸二(2-乙基己基)酯(DEHP)代谢物浓度。
主要发现
- 总体而言,混合效应模型的置信区间最宽,CWGEE模型的置信区间最窄。
- 在评估尿DEHP代谢物总和(∑DEHP,91%女性有数据)的模型中,首周期模型与多周期模型的点估计存在意外差异。
- 所有模型中母亲年龄与活产均存在显著关联。
- 未观察到∑DEHP与活产之间的关联。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,CWGEE模型在多周期IVF数据分析中应被更广泛考虑。
- 作者强调,在IVF数据分析中应估计风险而非比值。
局限性
- 本分析限于一个示例数据集,其中任何暴露的真实效应均未知。
- 未来应在各种假设下的模拟数据集中进行分析,以进一步评估每种方法的适用性。
- 本研究的统计方法未处理随访中的差异性失访。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Which methodological approaches are most appropriate for analyzing IVF data with multiple cycles in the context of a binary outcome? SUMMARY ANSWER: Both mixed effect models and generalized estimating equation (GEE) modeling approaches can account for multiple IVF cycles and may reduce bias over first-cycle only approaches, but CIs were narrowest with cluster-weighted generalized estimating equation models (CWGEE). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: There is a lack of consensus among investigators regarding how to best incorporate data from multiple cycles and whether to present odds or risks in the analysis of IVF data. Failure to account for correlated outcomes within individuals and informative cluster size may lead to invalid CIs and biased estimates. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: The Environment and Reproductive Health (EARTH) Study is an ongoing prospective cohort study of subfertile couples conducted at an academic medical center. This cohort was established in 2004 and follows couples seeking treatment for infertility throughout the course of their treatment and pregnancy. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Women aged 18-46 years enrolled in the EARTH Study from 2004 to 2017 who initiated at least one IVF cycle were eligible. Cycle initiation was defined as beginning ovulation induction with the intent to progress through an IVF or ICSI cycle. This analysis included 442 women undergoing 642 cycles who met the study inclusion criteria. We compared the results and interpretations of log-binomial and logistic models restricting to the first cycle, as well as mixed effects models, unweighted GEE models, and CWGEE models including all cycles. This analysis was conducted for two distinct exposures: maternal age at cycle initiation, and maternal preconception urinary concentrations of di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) metabolites (previously reported to be associated with a decreased probability of live birth). MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: In general, the CIs were widest for mixed effects models and narrowest for CWGEE models. Further, in models evaluating the sum of urinary concentrations of DEHP metabolites (∑DEHP, available for 91% of women), the point estimates were surprisingly different between the first-cycle and multiple-cycle models. We observed significant associations between maternal age and live birth in all models. However, we observed no associations between ∑DEHP and live birth. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: This analysis was limited to an example dataset in which the true effect of any exposure is unknown. While this allows us to observe model performance in the context of real data, future analyses should be conducted within simulated datasets under various assumptions to further evaluate the appropriateness of each approach. In addition, we did not address differential loss to follow-up in our statistical approaches. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The use of CWGEE models should be more widely considered in the analysis of IVF data with multiple cycles per woman. The CWGEE approach is computationally simple, addresses non-ignorable (informative) cluster size, and is robust against mis-specification of the underlying covariance structure. Among the methods compared in this analysis, CWGEE models generally yielded the narrowest CIs, possibly indicating the most precise estimates. We also stress the importance of estimating risks rather than odds in the analysis of IVF data. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): The project was funded by Grants (R01ES022955, R01ES009718, and P30ES000002) from the National Institutes of Health. None of the authors has any conflicts of interest to declare.
引用
- Yland J, Messerlian C, Mínguez-Alarcón L, et al. Methodological approaches to analyzing IVF data with multiple cycles. Hum Reprod. 2019. PMID: 30576499. doi:10.1093/humrep/dey374
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。