文献速递妇科

宫颈癌生存结局预测:Cox模型与深度学习模型的比较

Survival outcome prediction in cervical cancer: Cox models vs deep-learning model.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2018-12-21

该回顾性先导研究纳入2000-2014年连续新诊断的I-IV期宫颈癌患者768例,评估40项特征,比较深度学习神经网络模型与Cox比例风险回归模型等5种生存分析模型对无进展生存和总生存的预测性能,采用平均绝对误差和一致性指数评价,结果显示深度学习模型预测性能优于Cox模型。

要点

  • 深度学习模型预测无进展生存的平均绝对误差为29.3,Cox模型为316.2。
  • 深度学习模型预测总生存的平均绝对误差为30.7,Cox模型为43.6。
  • 纳入特征增多时深度学习模型一致性指数提高:20项特征0.695、36项特征0.787、40项特征0.795。

核心结论

  • 本研究提示深度学习神经网络模型可能是有用的宫颈癌生存预测分析工具,因其性能优于Cox比例风险回归模型。
  • 这种新分析方法可能为临床医生提供有意义的生存信息,并可能整合到治疗决策和规划中。
  • 需要进一步验证研究来支持这项先导研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性先导研究,纳入2000-2014年连续新诊断的I-IV期宫颈癌病例。
  • 共评估40项特征,包括患者人口学、生命体征、实验室检查结果、肿瘤特征和治疗类型,并分为3个特征集。
  • 将深度学习神经网络模型与Cox比例风险回归模型及另外3种生存分析模型进行比较,评估无进展生存和总生存,采用平均绝对误差和一致性指数评价性能。
  • 共纳入768例女性进行分析。

主要发现

  • 中位年龄49岁,大多数为西班牙裔(71.7%),大多数肿瘤为鳞状细胞癌(75.3%)和I期(48.7%)。
  • 中位随访时间40.2个月,随访期间复发和进展事件241例,死亡170例。
  • 深度学习模型预测无进展生存的平均绝对误差为29.3,Cox比例风险回归模型为316.2。
  • 深度学习模型预测总生存的平均绝对误差为30.7,Cox比例风险回归模型为43.6。
  • 深度学习模型一致性指数随特征数增加而提高:无进展生存20项特征0.695、36项特征0.787、40项特征0.795;无进展生存有10项特征仅在深度学习模型中显著,总生存有3项特征仅在深度学习模型中显著;无进展生存无特征仅在Cox模型中显著,总生存有3项特征仅在Cox模型中显著。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为深度学习神经网络模型可能是有用的宫颈癌生存预测分析工具。
  • 作者认为这种新分析方法可能为临床医生提供有意义的生存信息,并可能整合到治疗决策和规划中。
  • 作者指出需要进一步验证研究来支持这项先导研究。

局限性

  • 原文指出需要进一步验证研究来支持这项先导研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Historically, the Cox proportional hazard regression model has been the mainstay for survival analyses in oncologic research. The Cox proportional hazard regression model generally is used based on an assumption of linear association. However, it is likely that, in reality, there are many clinicopathologic features that exhibit a nonlinear association in biomedicine. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the deep-learning neural network model and the Cox proportional hazard regression model in the prediction of survival in women with cervical cancer. STUDY DESIGN: This was a retrospective pilot study of consecutive cases of newly diagnosed stage I-IV cervical cancer from 2000-2014. A total of 40 features that included patient demographics, vital signs, laboratory test results, tumor characteristics, and treatment types were assessed for analysis and grouped into 3 feature sets. The deep-learning neural network model was compared with the Cox proportional hazard regression model and 3 other survival analysis models for progression-free survival and overall survival. Mean absolute error and concordance index were used to assess the performance of these 5 models. RESULTS: There were 768 women included in the analysis. The median age was 49 years, and the majority were Hispanic (71.7%). The majority of tumors were squamous (75.3%) and stage I (48.7%). The median follow-up time was 40.2 months; there were 241 events for recurrence and progression and 170 deaths during the follow-up period. The deep-learning model showed promising results in the prediction of progression-free survival when compared with the Cox proportional hazard regression model (mean absolute error, 29.3 vs 316.2). The deep-learning model also outperformed all the other models, including the Cox proportional hazard regression model, for overall survival (mean absolute error, Cox proportional hazard regression vs deep-learning, 43.6 vs 30.7). The performance of the deep-learning model further improved when more features were included (concordance index for progression-free survival: 0.695 for 20 features, 0.787 for 36 features, and 0.795 for 40 features). There were 10 features for progression-free survival and 3 features for overall survival that demonstrated significance only in the deep-learning model, but not in the Cox proportional hazard regression model. There were no features for progression-free survival and 3 features for overall survival that demonstrated significance only in the Cox proportional hazard regression model, but not in the deep-learning model. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that the deep-learning neural network model may be a useful analytic tool for survival prediction in women with cervical cancer because it exhibited superior performance compared with the Cox proportional hazard regression model. This novel analytic approach may provide clinicians with meaningful survival information that potentially could be integrated into treatment decision-making and planning. Further validation studies are necessary to support this pilot study.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Matsuo K, Purushotham S, Jiang B, et al. Survival outcome prediction in cervical cancer: Cox models vs deep-learning model. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 30582927. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2018.12.030

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。