校正失访后的IVF成功率:逆概率加权的应用
该队列研究纳入1995年1月1日至2014年12月31日在本机构接受首个新鲜胚胎移植IVF周期的女性,共20015名女性、47079个IVF周期、10031例活产,最多纳入6个周期。研究比较标准Kaplan-Meier(乐观法)、假定失访者未获活产的保守Kaplan-Meier法与逆概率加权(IPW)三种方法估计活产累积发生率,结果显示IPW可提供更准确的IVF治疗成功估计,供咨询与决策使用。
要点
- 活产累积发生率:乐观法72.1%(95%CI 71.0-73.1%),保守法50.1%(49.4-50.8%),IPW法66.8%(65.5-68.1%)。
- 年龄<38岁女性中IPW估计略高于乐观法,41-42岁女性中IPW估计略低于乐观法。
- 保守估计在所有年龄组中均为最低。
核心结论
- IPW可为IVF治疗成功的咨询与决策提供更准确的估计。
- IPW可用于多种场景,以处理因失访差异或治疗退出导致的选择偏倚。
研究设计与样本
- 数据来自本机构1995年1月1日至2014年12月31日接受首个新鲜胚胎移植IVF周期的女性队列研究。
- 纳入所有自体周期(新鲜与冷冻),最多共6个周期。
- 共识别20015名女性、47079个IVF周期,研究期间有10031例活产。
- 采用三种方法计算活产累积发生率:标准Kaplan-Meier乐观法(失访时删失)、保守Kaplan-Meier法(假定失访者未获活产)及纳入Kaplan-Meier框架的IPW法。
主要发现
- 活产累积发生率为乐观法72.1%(95%CI 71.0-73.1%)、保守法50.1%(95%CI 49.4-50.8%)、IPW法66.8%(95%CI 65.5-68.1%)。
- 年龄<38岁女性中,IPW计算的活产累积发生率略高于乐观法。
- 41-42岁女性中,IPW活产累积发生率略低于乐观法。
- 其他年龄组中IPW与乐观法相近;保守估计在所有年龄组中最低。
关键数值与推荐
- IPW通过上调与退出治疗女性相似的仍在观察者的数据权重,减少失访所致潜在选择偏倚。
- IPW权重所用协变量包括:周期开始时的年龄、孕次和年份;原发不孕诊断;操作类型(新鲜或冷冻胚胎移植);获成熟卵母细胞数;移植胚胎数;周期取消;该周期妊娠丢失;保险状态。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为IPW可为IVF治疗成功的咨询与决策提供更准确的估计。
- 作者认为IPW可用于多种场景,以处理因失访差异或治疗退出导致的选择偏倚。
局限性
- 仅使用提供者在IVF周期中记录的临床数据生成IPW权重。
- 无法确定治疗退出的确切原因(如停止IVF治疗、转至其他机构或自然妊娠)。
- IPW模型基于权重分母计算的c统计量为中等预测能力;由于协变量数据范围有限,可能仍存在残余选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Does inverse probability weighting (IPW) provide a more valid estimate of the cumulative incidence of live birth after multiple cycles of IVF? SUMMARY ANSWER: IPW can provide a more accurate estimate of treatment success for counseling and decision-making regarding IVF. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Different approaches have been used to define and calculate IVF success; however, many of these approaches have limitations and potentially violate statistical assumptions. IPW can address potential selection bias that arises when people do not continue IVF treatment after a failed cycle. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: Data were derived from a cohort study of women undergoing their first fresh embryo transfer IVF cycle at our institution between 1 January 1995 and 31 December 2014. All autologous cycles (fresh and frozen) were included, up to six total cycles. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: We identified 20 015 women who underwent 47 079 IVF cycles and had 10 031 live births during the study period. The cumulative incidence of live birth was calculated using three approaches. First, we used a standard Kaplan-Meier approach, 'the optimistic approach', censoring women when they dropped out of treatment. Second, we used a 'conservative' Kaplan-Meier approach that assumed women who dropped out of treatment did not achieve a live birth. Finally, we used IPW to calculate the probability of remaining in treatment, while accounting for differences in treatment drop out. IPW up-weights the data of those remaining under observation who resembled the women who dropped out of treatment, thereby decreasing the potential selection bias resulting from loss to follow-up. The IPW was incorporated into a Kaplan-Meier approach. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The cumulative incidence of live birth was 72.1% (95% CI: 71.0-73.1%) for the optimistic approach, 50.1% (49.4-50.8%) for the conservative approach and 66.8% (65.5-68.1%) for the IPW approach. Among women < 38 years of age, the cumulative incidence of live birth calculated by the IPW was slightly higher than that calculated by the optimistic approach. For women 41-42 years of age, the IPW cumulative incidence of live birth was slightly lower. The IPW was similar to the optimistic approach for the other age groups. The conservative estimate was lowest for all age groups. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Only clinical data recorded by the providers during an IVF cycle were used to generate weights for IPW. Covariates included: age, gravidity and year at the start of the cycle; primary infertility diagnosis; procedure type (i.e. whether a fresh or frozen embryo was transferred); number of mature oocytes retrieved; number of embryos transferred; cycle cancellation; pregnancy loss in the cycle; and insurance status. We were unable to determine exact reasons for treatment drop out (e.g. cessation of IVF treatment, transfer to another institution or spontaneous pregnancy). Our IPW model was moderately predictive based on the c-statistic from the calculation of the denominator of the weight; however, residual selection bias may remain due to the limited range of covariate data. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: IPW can be used in a variety of settings to address selection bias introduced by differential loss to follow up or treatment drop out. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): AMM was supported by National Institutes of Health (NIH) T32 HD052458-Boston University Reproductive, Perinatal and Pediatric Epidemiology Training Program. The authors report no conflicts of interest. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.
引用
- Modest AM, Wise LA, Fox MP, et al. IVF success corrected for drop-out: use of inverse probability weighting. Hum Reprod. 2018. PMID: 30325421. doi:10.1093/humrep/dey309
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。