文献速递产科

既往剖宫产者试产利用率和成功率的医院间差异

Hospital variation in utilization and success of trial of labor after a prior cesarean.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2018-09-29

该研究利用2010—2012年加利福尼亚州母婴出院记录和出生证明数据,纳入249家医院的146,185名足月单胎、有1次剖宫产史且无禁忌证的孕妇,分析剖宫产后试产利用率和成功率的医院间差异及相关机构特征与结局。结果显示试产利用率中位数35.2%,成功率中位数40.5%,两者呈倒U形关系;高利用率高成功率医院的新生儿严重并发症风险有升有降,住院时间更短。

要点

  • 试产利用率中位数35.2%(第10—90百分位10.2—67.1%),成功率中位数40.5%(8.5—81.1%)。
  • 高利用率高成功率医院子宫破裂风险升高(调整RR 2.74,P<.001)。
  • 教学状态、系统归属、较大分娩量等与试产利用率和成功率正相关。

核心结论

  • 剖宫产后试产的利用率和成功率在各医院间差异很大。
  • 促进阴道分娩的策略应根据医院需求和特征量身定制。

研究设计与样本

  • 利用2010—2012年加利福尼亚州关联的母婴出院记录和出生证明数据。
  • 纳入249家医院的146,185名足月单胎、有1次剖宫产史且无先天畸形或明确试产禁忌证的孕妇。
  • 对每家医院估算风险标准化后的试产利用率和成功率。

主要发现

  • 总样本中12.5%的妇女经阴道分娩。
  • 风险标准化试产利用率中位数35.2%(第10—90百分位10.2—67.1%),成功率中位数40.5%(第10—90百分位8.5—81.1%)。
  • 风险标准化利用率和成功率呈倒U形关系,试产利用过低或过高均与较低成功率相关。
  • 与其它分娩相比,在利用率及成功率高于中位数的医院分娩者子宫破裂风险更高(调整RR 2.74,P<.001),严重新生儿呼吸并发症风险更高(调整RR 1.46,P<.001),严重新生儿神经系统并发症/创伤风险更高(调整RR 2.48,P<.001)。
  • 与其它分娩相比,在利用率及成功率高于中位数的医院分娩者严重新生儿感染风险更低(调整RR 0.80,P=.003),总体严重意外新生儿并发症风险更低(调整RR 0.86,P<.001),产妇和新生儿住院时间更短(调整均数比分别为0.948和0.924,P均<.001)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 教学状态、系统归属、较大分娩量、较高新生儿救治能力、麻醉可及性、较高助产士接生比例和较低医疗补助或未保险患者比例与试产利用率和成功率均正相关。
  • 农村地点和较高当地医疗事故保险费与试产利用率负相关,营利性所有权与较低成功率相关。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为促进阴道分娩的策略应针对医院需求和特征制定,例如在利用率低的医院增加试产可及性,在利用率高的医院更具选择性,并对低能力医院提供针对性支持。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Trial of labor after cesarean delivery is an effective and safe option for women without contraindications. OBJECTIVES: The objective of the study was to examine hospital variation in utilization and success of trial of labor after cesarean delivery and identify associated institutional characteristics and patient outcomes. STUDY DESIGN: Using linked maternal and newborn hospital discharge records and birth certificate data in 2010-2012 from the state of California, we identified 146,185 term singleton mothers with 1 prior cesarean delivery and no congenital anomalies or clear contraindications for trial of labor at 249 hospitals. Risk-standardized utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery were estimated for each hospital after accounting for differences in patient case mix. Risk for severe maternal and newborn morbidities, as well as maternal and newborn length of stay, were compared between hospitals with high utilization and high success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery and other hospitals. Bivariate analysis was also conducted to examine the association of various institutional characteristics with hospitals' utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery. RESULTS: In the overall sample, 12.5% of women delivered vaginally. After adjusting for patient clinical risk factors, utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery varied considerably across hospitals, with a median of 35.2% (10th to 90th percentile range: 10.2-67.1%) and 40.5% (10th to 90th percentile range: 8.5-81.1%), respectively. Risk-standardized utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery demonstrated an inverted U-shaped relationship such that low or excessively high use of trial of labor after cesarean delivery was associated with lower success rate. Compared with other births, those delivered at hospitals with above-the-median utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery had a higher risk for uterine rupture (adjusted risk ratio, 2.74, P < .001), severe newborn respiratory complications (adjusted risk ratio, 1.46, P < .001), and severe newborn neurological complications/trauma (adjusted risk ratio, 2.48, P < .001), but they had a lower risk for severe newborn infection (adjusted risk ratio, 0.80, P = .003) and overall severe unexpected newborn complications (adjusted risk ratio, 0.86, P < .001) as well as shorter length of stays (adjusted mean ratio, 0.948 for mothers and 0.924 for newborns, P < .001 for both). Teaching status, system affiliation, larger volume, higher neonatal care capacity, anesthesia availability, higher proportion of midwife-attended births, and lower proportion of Medicaid or uninsured patients were positively associated with both utilization and success of trial of labor after cesarean delivery. However, rural location and higher local malpractice insurance premium were negatively associated with the utilization of trial of labor after cesarean delivery, whereas for-profit ownership was associated with lower success rate. CONCLUSION: Utilization and success rates of trial of labor after cesarean delivery varied considerably across hospitals. Strategies to promote vaginal birth should be tailored to hospital needs and characteristics (eg, increase availability of trial of labor after cesarean delivery at hospitals with low utilization rates while being more selective at hospitals with high utilization rates, and targeted support for lower capacity hospitals).

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Xu X, Lee HC, Lin H, et al. Hospital variation in utilization and success of trial of labor after a prior cesarean. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 30278176. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2018.09.034

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。