利用视频分析评估荷兰产后出血护理对指南质量指标的依从性
荷兰16家医院前瞻性多中心观察性研究,分析398名产后出血高危妇女病历,其中293名辅以前瞻性视频记录,评估对产后出血预防、处理和组织指南质量指标的依从性。结果显示整体依从性不足,尤其出血>1,000 mL时(69例)措施缺失或延迟至>2,000 mL(21例);近41%(119/293)分娩未行主动管理,近80%(89/112)在出血>500 mL时未监测或监测过晚生命体征;视频显示实际护理在病历中普遍被低估报告。医院产后出血护理组织良好,15家有本地方案,12家组织团队培训。高危患者识别和医院类型(大学与非大学)与更好依从性最相关。
要点
- 出血>1,000 mL时(69例)措施依从性差,常延迟至>2,000 mL(21例)才行动。
- 近41%(119/293)分娩未行主动管理,近80%(89/112)出血>500 mL时未监测或过晚监测生命体征。
- 视频记录显示实际护理在病历中普遍被低估报告。
核心结论
- 本研究显示对指南质量指标依从性低,提示荷兰护理质量存在问题;视频观察提供了额外有价值信息以明确改进层面;已制定定制的实施策略以改善产后出血护理质量。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性观察性多中心研究,纳入荷兰16家医院398名产后出血高危妇女,分析病历数据,其中293名辅以前瞻性视频记录数据。
主要发现
- 出血>1,000 mL时(69例)措施未执行或仅延迟至出血已增至>2,000 mL(21例)时才执行。
- 近41%(119/293)分娩未行主动管理,近80%(89/112)在出血>500 mL时未监测生命体征或相对于出血监测过晚。
- 视频记录显示实际给予的护理在病历中普遍被严重低估报告。
- 医院产后出血护理组织良好:15家有本地产后出血方案,12家组织团队培训。
- 高危患者识别和医院类型(大学与非大学医院)与更好依从性最相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 预防和管理指标按出血量分类:<500 mL、>500 mL、>1,000 mL、>2,000 mL。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess adherence to the national postpartum hemorrhage guideline and Managing Obstetric Emergencies and Trauma course instructions and its determinants in the Netherlands. METHODS: A prospective observational multicenter study in 16 Dutch hospitals analyzing data from medical records of 398 women at high risk for postpartum hemorrhage, of which 293 were supplemented with data from prospective video recordings. Adherence to guideline-based quality indicators for prevention, management, and organization of postpartum hemorrhage care was measured. Indicators for prevention and management of postpartum hemorrhage were categorized according to the amount of blood loss (less than 500, greater than 500, greater than 1,000, and greater than 2,000 mL). RESULTS: Overall, a lack of adherence was observed, particularly for the actions to be undertaken with blood loss greater than 1,000 mL (69 patients). Actions were not or only taken in a later stage when the blood loss had already increased to greater than 2,000 mL (21 patients). In almost 41% (n=119/293) of the deliveries, no active management was performed, and in almost 80% (n=89/112), vital signs were not monitored (blood loss greater than 500 mL) or monitored too late with respect to blood loss. The video recordings showed that in general the actual care given was considerably underreported in medical records. Postpartum hemorrhage care in the hospitals was well organized. Fifteen hospitals had a local postpartum hemorrhage protocol, and in 12 hospitals, team trainings were organized. Regarding the determinants, high-risk patient identification and type of hospital (university vs nonuniversity hospital) were mostly associated with better adherence. CONCLUSION: This study showed low adherence to the guideline-based quality indicators, indicating a problem with Dutch quality care. The unique video observations provided additional, valuable information at which level improvement can be made. A tailor-made implementation strategy to improve quality of postpartum hemorrhage care has been developed. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT00928863.
引用
- Woiski M, de Visser S, van Vugt H, et al. Evaluating Adherence to Guideline-Based Quality Indicators for Postpartum Hemorrhage Care in the Netherlands Using Video Analysis. Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 30095761. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000002781
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。