无创正常阴道分娩:有多少女性能够如愿以偿?
本文为一项围产期影像干预研究的回顾性二次分析,纳入660例无并发症单胎初产妇,产后经会阴超声评估盆底损伤。结果显示,仅33%–40%的初产妇达到无创正常阴道分娩标准,较年轻和分娩时孕周较早是预测因素。
要点
- 仅33%–40%的初产妇达到无创正常阴道分娩标准。
- 会阴部、肛提肌及肛门括约肌损伤在阴道分娩后常见且常被低估。
- 较年轻和分娩时孕周较早与无创正常阴道分娩相关。
核心结论
- 阴道分娩后显著盆底创伤的发生率远高于普遍认识,仅33%–40%的初产妇达到无创正常阴道分娩标准。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为回顾性二次分析,数据来自一项围产期影像干预研究,共纳入660例无并发症单胎妊娠初产妇。
- 504/660例(76%)女性返回接受产后随访,排除21例数据不完整或合并妊娠者,最终483例纳入分析。
- 产后评估包括访谈、阴道检查(盆腔器官脱垂定量)及四维经会阴超声,超声数据在不知临床资料的情况下分析。
主要发现
- 483例中,112例(23%)行剖宫产,103例(21%)行手术阴道分娩,17例(4%)发生三/四度裂伤,251例可视为正常阴道分娩。
- 模型1中,27例(6%)存在肛提肌撕脱,31例(6%)存在残余括约肌缺陷,193/483例(40%)符合无创正常阴道分娩标准。
- 模型2中,额外33例(7%)存在微创伤,仅160/483例(33%)符合无创正常阴道分娩标准。
- 多因素分析显示,较年轻和分娩时孕周较早两个模型均为高度显著预测因素,模型2中Valsalva动作时肛提肌裂孔面积增大亦显著(均P≤.035)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Trauma to the perineum, levator ani complex, and anal sphincter is common during vaginal childbirth, but often clinically underdiagnosed, and many women are unaware of the potential for long-term damage. OBJECTIVE: In this study we use transperineal ultrasound to identify how many women will achieve a normal vaginal delivery without substantial damage to the levator ani or anal sphincter muscles, and to create a model to predict patient characteristics associated with successful atraumatic normal vaginal delivery. STUDY DESIGN: This is a retrospective, secondary analysis of data sets gathered in the context of an interventional perinatal imaging study. A total of 660 primiparas, carrying an uncomplicated singleton pregnancy, underwent an antepartum and postpartum interview, vaginal exam (Pelvic Organ Prolapse Quantification), and 4-dimensional translabial ultrasound. Ultrasound data were analyzed for levator trauma and/or overdistention and residual sphincter defects. Postprocessing analysis of ultrasound volumes was performed blinded against clinical data and analyzed against obstetric data retrieved from the local maternity database. Levator avulsion was diagnosed if the muscle insertion at the inferior pubic ramus at the plane of minimal hiatal dimensions and within 5 mm above this plane on tomographic ultrasound imaging was abnormal, ie the muscle was disconnected from the inferior pubic ramus. Hiatal overdistensibility (microtrauma) was diagnosed if there was a peripartum increase in hiatal area on Valsalva by >20% with the resultant area ≥25 cm2. A sphincter defect was diagnosed if a gap of >30 degrees was seen in ≥4 of 6 tomographic ultrasound imaging slices bracketing the external anal sphincter. Two models were tested: a first model that defines severe pelvic floor trauma as either obstetric anal sphincter injury or levator avulsion, and a second, more conservative model, that also included microtrauma. RESULTS: A total of 504/660 women (76%) returned for postpartum follow-up as described previously. In all, 21 patients were excluded due to inadequate data or intercurrent pregnancy, leaving 483 women for analysis. Model 1 defined nontraumatic vaginal delivery as excluding operative delivery, obstetric anal sphincter injuries, and sonographic evidence of levator avulsion or residual sphincter defect. Model 2 also excluded microtrauma. Of 483 women, 112 (23%) had a cesarean delivery, 103 (21%) had an operative vaginal delivery, and 17 (4%) had a third-/fourth-degree tear, leaving 251 women who could be said to have had a normal vaginal delivery. On ultrasound, in model 1, 27 women (6%) had an avulsion and 31 (6%) had a residual defect, leaving 193/483 (40%) who met the criteria for atraumatic normal vaginal delivery. In model 2, an additional 33 women (7%) had microtrauma, leaving only 160/483 (33%) women who met the criteria for atraumatic normal vaginal delivery. On multivariate analysis, younger age and earlier gestation at time of delivery remained highly significant as predictors of atraumatic normal vaginal delivery in both models, with increased hiatal area on Valsalva also significant in model 2 (all P ≤ .035). CONCLUSION: The prevalence of significant pelvic floor trauma after vaginal child birth is much higher than generally assumed. Rates of obstetric anal sphincter injury are often underestimated and levator avulsion is not included as a consequence of vaginal birth in most obstetric text books. In this study less than half (33-40%) of primiparous women achieved an atraumatic normal vaginal delivery.
引用
- Caudwell-Hall J, Kamisan Atan I, Guzman Rojas R, et al. Atraumatic normal vaginal delivery: how many women get what they want? Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 30063899. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2018.07.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。