使用二维经阴道超声和三维容积对比成像对子宫内膜癌进行离线分期:方法间一致性、评分者间信度和诊断准确性
研究纳入58例活检确诊的子宫内膜癌患者,由15名超声专家独立离线评估2D-TVS视频和3D-VCI容积,比较诊断深肌层浸润和宫颈间质受累的一致性、信度与准确性。2D-TVS的评分者间信度和准确性均优于3D-VCI,且准确性评分者年评估病例数显著相关,作者建议将此类检查集中至高流量中心。
要点
- 2D-TVS与3D-VCI诊断深肌层浸润的一致性中位数为76%,宫颈间质受累为88%。
- 2D-TVS的评分者间信度优于3D-VCI:深肌层浸润Fleiss kappa 0.41 vs 0.31,宫颈间质受累0.55 vs 0.45。
- 诊断准确性评分者年评估病例数显著相关,作者建议将检查集中至高流量中心。
核心结论
- 离线评估子宫内膜癌深肌层浸润和宫颈间质受累时,3D-VCI的评分者间信度和准确性均低于2D-TVS视频评估。
- 由于准确性评分者年评估病例数相关,作者建议将这些检查集中至高流量中心。
研究设计与样本
- 15名超声专家对58例活检确诊的子宫内膜癌患者的离线去标识3D-VCI容积和2D-TVU视频片段进行独立评估,判断是否存在深(≥50%)肌层浸润和宫颈间质受累。
- 以子宫切除术后组织学诊断作为金标准,采用kappa统计量评价评分者间信度,采用Spearman秩相关系数(ρ)分析准确性评分者经验的相关性。
主要发现
- 2D-TVU与3D-VCI诊断肌层浸润的一致性中位数为76%(范围64-93%),诊断宫颈间质受累的一致性中位数为88%(范围79-97%)。
- 评分者间信度2D-TVU优于3D-VCI:肌层浸润Fleiss kappa 0.41 vs 0.31,宫颈间质受累Fleiss kappa 0.55 vs 0.45。
- 诊断深肌层浸润的中位准确性2D-TVU为76%(范围59-84%),3D-VCI为69%(范围52-83%);诊断宫颈间质受累的中位准确性分别为88%(范围81-93%)和86%(范围72-95%)。
- 准确性评分者年评估病例数显著相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议将子宫内膜癌的此类超声检查集中至高流量中心。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim is to estimate agreement between two-dimensional transvaginal ultrasound (2D-TVS) and three-dimensional volume contrast imaging (3D-VCI) in diagnosing deep myometrial invasion (MI) and cervical stromal involvement (CSI) of endometrial cancer and to compare the two methods regarding inter-rater reliability and diagnostic accuracy. METHODS: Fifteen ultrasound experts assessed off-line de-identified 3D-VCI volumes and 2D-TVU video clips from 58 patients with biopsy-confirmed endometrial cancer regarding the presence of deep (≥50%) MI and CSI. Video clips and 3D volumes were assessed independently. Interrater reliability was measured using kappa statistics. Histological diagnosis after hysterectomy served as gold standard. Accuracy measurements were correlated to rater experience using Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (ρ). RESULTS: Agreement between 2D-TVU and 3D-VCI for diagnosing MI was median 76% (range 64-93%) and for CSI median 88% (range 79-97%). Interrater reliability was better for 2D-TVU than for 3D-VCI (Fleiss' kappa 0.41 vs. 0.31 for MI and 0.55 vs. 0.45 for CSI). Median accuracy for diagnosing deep MI was 76% (range 59-84%) with 2D-TVU and 69% (range 52-83%) for 3D-VCI; the corresponding figures for CSI were 88% (range 81-93%) and 86% (range 72-95%). Accuracy was significantly correlated to how many cases the raters assessed annually. CONCLUSIONS: Off-line assessment of MI and CSI in women with endometrial cancer using 3D-VCI has lower interrater reliability and lower accuracy than 2D-TVU video clip assessment. Since accuracy was correlated to the number of cases assessed annually it is advised to centralize these examinations to high-volume centres.
引用
- Green RW, Valentin L, Alcazar JL, et al. Endometrial cancer off-line staging using two-dimensional transvaginal ultrasound and three-dimensional volume contrast imaging: Intermethod agreement, interrater reliability and diagnostic accuracy. Gynecol Oncol. 2018. PMID: 30029961. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2018.06.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。