剖宫产术中输卵管切除术与输卵管结扎术的比较:一项随机对照试验
在单家学术机构开展的随机对照非劣效性试验中,计划剖宫产并要求绝育的44名女性随机接受输卵管切除术或标准输卵管结扎术;输卵管切除术的手术时间不劣于标准输卵管结扎术(平均差0.5分钟,单侧95%CI上限1.8分钟),完成率高(95%),未见并发症增加。
要点
- 输卵管切除术的手术时间不劣于标准输卵管结扎术,平均差0.5分钟(单侧95%CI上限1.8分钟)。
- 输卵管切除术完成率为95%,1例因粘连未能完成。
- 两组再手术或再入院率无差异。
核心结论
- 剖宫产术中输卵管切除术的手术时间不长于标准输卵管结扎术,平均差30秒。
- 输卵管切除术完成率高(95%),未见并发症明显增加。
研究设计与样本
- 在单家学术机构开展的随机对照非劣效性试验。
- 计划剖宫产并希望绝育的女性随机分配至输卵管切除术或标准输卵管结扎术。
- 主要结局为绝育手术时长,非劣效性界值设为5分钟。
- 以单侧独立样本t检验,α=0.05、把握度90%,每组需18名女性完成干预。
主要发现
- 共44名女性入组,19名成功接受输卵管切除术,18名接受标准输卵管结扎术。
- 输卵管切除术组20例中1例因粘连未能完成手术。
- 两组基线人口学特征相当。
- 输卵管切除术组平均绝育手术时间为5.6分钟,标准输卵管结扎组为6.1分钟,平均差0.5分钟(P<.05,单侧95%CI上限1.8分钟)。
- 剖宫产联合输卵管切除术与联合标准输卵管结扎术相比,中位总手术时间(60 vs 68分钟,P=.34)和估计失血量(600 vs 700 mL,P=.09)均无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效性界值设为5分钟。
- 输卵管切除术组平均绝育手术时间5.6分钟 vs 标准输卵管结扎组6.1分钟,平均差0.5分钟(单侧95%CI上限1.8分钟),达到非劣效。
- 中位总手术时间:输卵管切除术组60分钟 vs 标准输卵管结扎组68分钟(P=.34)。
- 估计失血量:输卵管切除术组600 mL vs 标准输卵管结扎组700 mL(P=.09)。
- 输卵管切除术完成率95%(20例中19例完成)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To estimate whether performance of salpingectomy compared with standard tubal ligation for sterilization at the time of cesarean delivery increases operating time or complication rates. METHODS: A randomized controlled noninferiority trial was performed at a single academic institution. Women undergoing planned cesarean delivery who desired sterilization were randomized to salpingectomy or standard tubal ligation. The primary outcome was length of time of the sterilization procedure, with the noninferiority margin set at 5 minutes. With a one-sided independent sample t test, to achieve a power of 90% with an α of 0.05, 18 women needed to complete each intervention. RESULTS: Forty-four women were enrolled, with 19 successfully undergoing salpingectomy and 18 undergoing standard tubal ligation. Salpingectomy could not be completed in 1 of 20 patients (as a result of adhesions). Baseline demographics were equivalent between groups. Salpingectomy procedure time was noninferior to standard tubal ligation, with a mean difference of 0.5 minutes, with a mean sterilization procedure time of 5.6 minutes in the salpingectomy group and 6.1 minutes in the standard tubal ligation group (P <.05, one-sided 95% CI upper bound 1.8 minutes). There was no difference between cesarean delivery with salpingectomy compared with cesarean delivery with standard tubal ligation in median total operating time (60 vs 68 minutes, P=.34) or estimated blood loss (600 vs 700 mL, P=.09). No patients in either group required reoperation or readmission. CONCLUSION: Salpingectomy procedure time was not longer than standard tubal ligation during cesarean delivery, with a mean difference of 30 seconds. There was a high completion rate for salpingectomy (95%) and no apparent increase in complications. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinicaltrials.gov, NCT03028623.
引用
- Garcia C, Moskowitz OM, Chisholm CA, et al. Salpingectomy Compared With Tubal Ligation at Cesarean Delivery: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 29889755. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000002674
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。