便携式口袋阴道镜与标准临床阴道镜使用醋酸和卢戈氏碘作为对比介质的效果相当:秘鲁的一项研究
在秘鲁利马的一家三级医疗中心,对200例细胞学异常和/或HPV阳性的女性,使用标准阴道镜和口袋阴道镜以醋酸和卢戈氏碘为对比剂采集宫颈图像。129例质量合格图像由四名医生判读,两种阴道镜判读一致率83.1%;与病理相比,口袋阴道镜敏感度71.2%、特异度57.5%,标准阴道镜敏感度79.8%、特异度56.6%。加用卢戈氏碘较仅用醋酸可使所有病理类别的一致率提高至多8.9%,敏感度和特异度分别提高超过6.0%和9.0%。
要点
- 两种阴道镜医生判读一致率为83.1%。
- 与病理相比,口袋阴道镜敏感度71.2%、特异度57.5%,标准阴道镜敏感度79.8%、特异度56.6%。
- 加用卢戈氏碘较仅用醋酸使一致率提高至多8.9%,敏感度和特异度分别提高超过6.0%和9.0%。
核心结论
- 在秘鲁使用醋酸和卢戈氏碘进行阴道镜检查时,口袋阴道镜识别癌前病变和癌性病变的性能与标准阴道镜相似。
研究设计与样本
- 在秘鲁利马la Liga Contra el Cáncer采集宫颈图像的研究,纳入200例细胞学异常和/或HPV阳性的秘鲁女性。
- 使用标准阴道镜和口袋阴道镜以醋酸和卢戈氏碘为对比剂采集图像,并按标准诊疗程序活检。
- 质量审核后,129例女性的图像被发送给四名医生,由其对每张图像提供诊断。
主要发现
- 两种阴道镜图像判读一致率为83.1%。
- 与病理相比,口袋阴道镜敏感度71.2%、特异度57.5%,标准阴道镜敏感度79.8%、特异度56.6%。
- 与既往仅使用醋酸的研究相比,加用卢戈氏碘作为第二对比剂使所有病理类别的一致率提高至多8.9%,使医生判读与病理相比的敏感度和特异度分别提高超过6.0%和9.0%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to develop a tele-colposcopy platform for primary-care clinics to improve screening sensitivity and access. Specifically, we developed a low-cost, portable Pocket colposcope and evaluated its performance in a tertiary healthcare centre in Peru. DESIGN AND SETTING: Images of the cervix were captured with a standard-of-care and Pocket colposcope at la Liga Contra el Cáncer in Lima, Peru. POPULATION: Two hundred Peruvian women with abnormal cytology and/or human papillomavirus positivity were enrolled. METHODS: Images were collected using acetic acid and Lugol's iodine as contrast agents. Biopsies were taken as per standard-of-care procedures. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: After passing quality review, images from 129 women were sent to four physicians who provided a diagnosis for each image. RESULTS: Physician interpretation of images from the two colposcopes agreed 83.1% of the time. The average sensitivity and specificity of physician interpretation compared with pathology was similar for the Pocket (sensitivity = 71.2%, specificity = 57.5%) and standard-of-care (sensitivity = 79.8%, specificity = 56.6%) colposcopes. When compared with a previous study where only acetic acid was applied to the cervix, results indicated that adding Lugol's iodine as a secondary contrast agent improved the percent agreement between colposcopes for all pathological categories by up to 8.9% and the sensitivity and specificity of physician interpretation compared with pathology by over 6.0 and 9.0%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The Pocket colposcope performance was similar to that of a standard-of-care colposcope when used to identify precancerous and cancerous lesions using acetic acid and Lugol's iodine during colposcopy examinations in Peru. TWEETABLE ABSTRACT: The Pocket colposcope performance was similar to that of a standard-of-care colposcope when identifying cervical lesions.
引用
- Mueller JL, Lam CT, Dahl D, et al. Portable Pocket colposcopy performs comparably to standard-of-care clinical colposcopy using acetic acid and Lugol's iodine as contrast mediators: an investigational study in Peru. BJOG. 2018. PMID: 29893472. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.15326
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。