接受性腺毒性治疗的年轻女性生育力保存临床实践指南:方法学质量与内容的概述及批判性评价
该研究通过广泛文献检索并咨询国际专家,纳入30部关于成年女性生育力保存的国际临床实践指南,使用AGREE II工具由专家组评价其方法学质量,并提取6部「严谨性」领域得分≥60%的指南的内容。结果显示这6部指南讨论的生育力保存相关主题数为4至12个,各指南提供推荐的数量及获得≥5条推荐的主题数(0至4个)差异较大。结论认为现有指南在质量和内容上仍有改进空间,可用于制定质量指标以监测当前生育力保存护理质量或评估未来改进措施。
要点
- 共纳入30部国际生育力保存临床实践指南,其中仅6部在AGREE II「严谨性」领域得分≥60%。
- 6部高质量指南讨论的生育力保存相关主题数为4至12个,获≥5条推荐的主题数为0至4个。
- 指南整体质量和内容仍有改进空间,可用于制定质量指标监测生育力保存护理质量。
核心结论
- 关于生育力保存护理的临床实践指南已存在,但在质量和内容上仍有改进空间。
- 尽管指南为日常实践而写,也可用于制定质量指标以监测当前生育力保存护理质量或评估未来改进措施。
研究设计与样本
- 通过广泛文献检索并咨询(国际)国家关键专家,识别国际上可获得的关于成年女性生育力保存护理的临床实践指南。
- 由(国际)国家专家组使用AGREE II工具评价指南方法学质量,并提取AGREE II「严谨性」领域得分≥60%的最佳指南的内容,按主题分类。
- 共检索到1808篇文献,最终纳入30部临床实践指南。
主要发现
- 纳入的30部指南中,有6部在AGREE II「严谨性」领域得分≥60%。
- 这6部指南讨论的生育力保存相关主题数为4至12个。
- 各指南针对这些主题提供的推荐数量存在差异,获得≥5条推荐的主题数在各指南间为0至4个。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南方法学质量采用AGREE II工具评价,以「严谨性」领域得分≥60%作为筛选最佳指南的阈值。
- 6部最佳指南讨论的生育力保存相关主题数为4至12个,各指南获≥5条推荐的主题数为0至4个。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the methodological quality and content of internationally available clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) on fertility preservation (FP) care in adult women? DESIGN: Internationally available CPGs on FP care in adult women were identified after conducting an extensive literature search and consulting (inter)national key experts. The methodological quality of the CPGs was appraised by an (inter)national panel of experts using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II instrument. The content of the best CPGs, scoring ≥60% for the domain 'Rigour of development' of the AGREE II instrument, was extracted and categorized according to their topic. RESULTS: Thirty of the 1808 documents found were included. After consulting (inter)national key experts, 30 CPGs were included, six of which scored ≥60% for their 'Rigour of development'. The number of FP-related topics discussed by these six CPGs ranged from 4 to 12. The number of recommendations provided by the CPGs on these topics varied. The number of topics to which ≥5 recommendations were dedicated ranged from 0 to 4 between CPGs. CONCLUSION: CPGs on the subject of FP care are available, but there is room for improvement in quality and content. Although written for use in daily practice, the CPGs can also be used to develop quality indicators to monitor the quality of current FP care or to evaluate future improvement initiatives.
引用
- Baysal Ö, Hamilton JAM, Hamilton CJCM, et al. Clinical practice guidelines for fertility preservation in young women undergoing gonadotoxic treatment: an overview and critical appraisal of methodological quality and content. Reprod Biomed Online. 2018. PMID: 29709394. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2018.03.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。