文献速递生殖医学

第三方辅助生殖卵母细胞库的伦理问题:一项系统综述

Ethics of oocyte banking for third-party assisted reproduction: a systematic review.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod Update · 2018-01-01

该研究系统检索了PubMed和Embase,纳入对第三方辅助生殖中卵母细胞捐赠或冻存伦理方面进行有理据描述的英文文献,识别出卵母细胞库建立与维护涉及摄入、储存和分配三个环节的多重伦理问题。多数文献聚焦捐赠卵母细胞的摄入环节,储存与分配环节涉及较少,许多伦理问题尚无共识。

要点

  • 卵母细胞库实践包括捐赠卵母细胞的摄入、储存和分配三个环节,每个环节涉及多重伦理挑战。
  • 摄入环节伦理涉及捐赠者风险、心理社会影响、招募动机与补偿、知情同意,以及子代福利标准、捐赠者选择、匿名与披露。
  • 储存环节伦理涉及质量标准、保密性、所有权与控制、跨国运输;分配环节涉及受者选择、非传统家庭可接受性、稀缺时优先排序、跨境生殖保健、配子匹配与咨询。

核心结论

  • 建立和维护卵母细胞库须考虑多重伦理方面,但许多方面尚无共识采用何种方法。
  • 现有文献主要关注捐赠卵母细胞的摄入伦理,储存和分配方面较少涉及,应承认这一重要文献空白。
  • 研究结果可作为辅助生殖领域临床医生构想卵母细胞库伦理挑战的起点,并可促使政策制定者建立可信且适应性强的治理结构。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,于2016年7月和2017年2月在PubMed和Embase进行系统检索,检索式组合卵母细胞、捐赠或冻存、生殖保健和伦理的同义词。
  • 纳入多种英文文献,要求对第三方辅助生殖中卵母细胞捐赠或冻存的伦理方面或道德考量进行有理据的描述。

主要发现

  • 卵母细胞库实践包括捐赠卵母细胞的摄入、储存和分配三个环节,每个环节涉及多重伦理挑战。
  • 多数文献讨论捐赠卵母细胞摄入相关的伦理方面,兼顾捐赠者和潜在子代的利益。
  • 储存环节伦理包括质量标准、保密性、所有权与控制问题以及捐赠卵母细胞的国际运输。
  • 分配环节伦理包括受者选择、非传统家庭治疗可接受性、稀缺时受者优先排序、跨境生殖保健、受者与捐赠卵母细胞匹配、知情同意和咨询。

关键数值与推荐

  • 与捐赠者相关的伦理方面为捐赠的风险和心理社会影响、捐赠者招募中的动机与补偿以及知情同意的要求。
  • 与潜在子代相关的伦理方面为双重:其一为福利标准和捐赠者选择,其二为匿名与披露。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文指出许多伦理方面尚无共识采用何种方法。
  • 原文指出文献主要集中在捐赠卵母细胞的摄入伦理,储存和分配方面较少涉及,存在重要文献空白。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The demand for donor oocytes has increased dramatically over the years. Today people in need of ART with the use of donor oocytes can appeal to commercial or public donor oocyte banks. The introduction of oocyte banks has shed a new light on the practice of ART using donor oocytes. The establishment and maintenance of oocyte banks should be sensitive to the ethical considerations. However, it is currently unclear which ethical aspects have to be taken into account. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: The aim of this article is to identify the ethical aspects of establishing and maintaining oocyte banks for third-party ART. SEARCH METHODS: A systematic search was performed in July 2016 and February 2017 in both PubMed and Embase using a search string that combined synonyms for oocytes, donation or banking, reproductive care and ethics. We included a wide variety of English-language articles with a reasoned description of ethical aspects or moral considerations on oocyte donation or banking for third-party ART. OUTCOMES: The practice of oocyte banking consists of three components, namely, the intake, storage and distribution of donor oocytes, and each is associated with multiple ethical challenges. The majority of the literature discusses ethical aspects with regard to the intake of donor oocytes, taking into account both the interests of the donor and those of the potential child. Ethical aspects related to the donor are the risks and psychosocial impact of donation, motivations and compensation in donor recruitment, and requirements for informed consent. Ethical aspects related to the potential child are 2-fold: first, the welfare standard and the selection of donors, and second, anonymity and disclosure. Ethical aspects of storing donor oocytes for ART are quality standards, confidentiality, issues of ownership and control, and international transport of donor oocytes. Ethical aspects of the distribution of donor oocytes concern the selection of recipients and the acceptability of treatment of 'non-traditional' families in particular, prioritization of recipients in case of scarcity, cross-border reproductive care, matching of recipients and donor oocytes, informed consent and counselling for recipients. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: Our review demonstrates that multiple ethical aspects have to be taken into account when establishing and maintaining an oocyte bank. Yet, for many of these aspects there is no consensus regarding what approach should be employed. Remarkably, the existing literature focuses mainly on ethical aspects related to the intake of donor oocytes, while aspects related to storage and distribution of donor oocytes are less often addressed. An important gap in the existing literature should therefore be acknowledged. To conclude, our findings can serve as a starting point for clinicians in the field of ART, to conceptualize what challenges arise when establishing and maintaining oocyte banks for third-party ART. The review may also stimulate policy makers to set up a trustworthy and adaptive governance structure for the intake, storage and distribution of donor oocytes.

来源:Hum Reprod Update,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kool EM, Bos AME, van der Graaf R, et al. Ethics of oocyte banking for third-party assisted reproduction: a systematic review. Hum Reprod Update. 2018. PMID: 29762669. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmy016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。