非裔美国女性定制胎儿生长标准:PRB/NICHD 底特律研究
该回顾性队列纳入底特律大都会区4183名孕妇(4001名非裔美国人和182名白人),纵向构建了校正母亲身高、体重、产次及胎儿性别的非裔美国人定制胎儿生长标准,并与GROW、NICHD非裔美国标准及WHO标准比较小于胎龄儿(SGA)和大于胎龄儿(LGA)的筛查阳性率。新标准筛查出更多SGA胎儿,尤其早产儿,但LGA数量与现有标准大致相同。
要点
- 非裔美国人定制PRB/NICHD标准校正母亲身高、体重、产次及胎儿性别,不假设协变量效应成比例或各百分位相等。
- SGA筛查阳性率:NICHD非裔美国标准7.2%、GROW标准12.3%、WHO按胎儿性别定制标准13%、PRB/NICHD定制标准14.4%。
- LGA筛查阳性率:GROW标准8.7%、PRB/NICHD定制标准9.2%、WHO按胎儿性别定制标准10.8%、NICHD非裔美国标准12.3%。
核心结论
- 研究构建了基于非裔美国人群胎儿数据的PRB/NICHD定制胎儿生长标准,未假设协变量效应成比例及各体重百分位效应相等,并提供易用的百分位计算器。
- 该标准较现有标准筛查出更多有SGA风险的胎儿,尤其在早产儿中,但LGA数量与现有标准大致相同。
- 四种生长标准比较显示,决定标准间一致性的最重要因素是是否校正相同的已知影响胎儿生长的因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入底特律大都会区4183名孕妇(4001名非裔美国人和182名白人),于孕14-40周接受超声检查,每例妊娠超声次数中位数5次(四分位距3-7次),且有相关协变量数据。
- 采用纵向分位数回归构建非裔美国女性估测胎儿体重(EFW)百分位模型,校正母亲身高、体重、产次及胎儿性别,并排除对胎儿体重有显著影响的病理因素。
- 将PRB/NICHD生长标准与GROW标准、NICHD非裔美国标准及WHO标准比较,基于每例妊娠最后一次超声检查筛查SGA(<第10百分位)或LGA(>第90百分位)。
主要发现
- 40周平均出生体重:白种人母亲新生儿较非裔美国人母亲新生儿高133 g;男性新生儿较女性新生儿高150 g;母亲体重、身高和产次对出生体重有正向影响。
- 纵向EFW分析显示:所有体重百分位中男性胎儿较女性胎儿约高2%;母亲身高每增加10 cm,第95百分位体重增加2%,且对较大胎儿影响更大;母亲体重和产次对EFW有正向影响,随孕周增加而增大,且在不同体重百分位间存在差异。
- SGA筛查阳性率:NICHD非裔美国标准7.2%,GROW标准12.3%,WHO按胎儿性别定制标准13%,PRB/NICHD定制标准14.4%;所有标准中早产儿SGA筛查阳性率至少为足月儿的2倍。
- LGA筛查阳性率:GROW标准8.7%,PRB/NICHD定制标准9.2%,WHO按胎儿性别定制标准10.8%,NICHD非裔美国标准12.3%。
- 标准间总体一致性最高为GROW与PRB/NICHD定制标准(Cohen's interrater agreement,kappa=0.85)。
关键数值与推荐
- SGA定义为估测胎儿体重<第10百分位,LGA定义为>第90百分位,基于每例妊娠最后一次超声检查。
- SGA筛查阳性率:NICHD非裔美国标准7.2%,GROW标准12.3%,WHO按胎儿性别定制标准13%,PRB/NICHD定制标准14.4%。
- LGA筛查阳性率:GROW标准8.7%,PRB/NICHD定制标准9.2%,WHO按胎儿性别定制标准10.8%,NICHD非裔美国标准12.3%。
- GROW与PRB/NICHD定制标准间Cohen's kappa=0.85。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The assessment of fetal growth disorders requires a standard. Current nomograms for the assessment of fetal growth in African American women have been derived either from neonatal (rather than fetal) biometry data or have not been customized for maternal ethnicity, weight, height, and parity and fetal sex. OBJECTIVE: We sought to (1) develop a new customized fetal growth standard for African American mothers; and (2) compare such a standard to 3 existing standards for the classification of fetuses as small (SGA) or large (LGA) for gestational age. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective cohort study included 4183 women (4001 African American and 182 Caucasian) from the Detroit metropolitan area who underwent ultrasound examinations between 14-40 weeks of gestation (the median number of scans per pregnancy was 5, interquartile range 3-7) and for whom relevant covariate data were available. Longitudinal quantile regression was used to build models defining the "normal" estimated fetal weight (EFW) centiles for gestational age in African American women, adjusted for maternal height, weight, and parity and fetal sex, and excluding pathologic factors with a significant effect on fetal weight. The resulting Perinatology Research Branch/Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (hereinafter, PRB/NICHD) growth standard was compared to 3 other existing standards--the customized gestation-related optimal weight (GROW) standard; the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (hereinafter, NICHD) African American standard; and the multinational World Health Organization (WHO) standard--utilized to screen fetuses for SGA (<10th centile) or LGA (>90th centile) based on the last available ultrasound examination for each pregnancy. RESULTS: First, the mean birthweight at 40 weeks was 133 g higher for neonates born to Caucasian than to African American mothers and 150 g higher for male than female neonates; maternal weight, height, and parity had a positive effect on birthweight. Second, analysis of longitudinal EFW revealed the following features of fetal growth: (1) all weight centiles were about 2% higher for male than for female fetuses; (2) maternal height had a positive effect on EFW, with larger fetuses being affected more (2% increase in the 95th centile of weight for each 10-cm increase in height); and (3) maternal weight and parity had a positive effect on EFW that increased with gestation and varied among the weight centiles. Third, the screen-positive rate for SGA was 7.2% for the NICHD African American standard, 12.3% for the GROW standard, 13% for the WHO standard customized by fetal sex, and 14.4% for the PRB/NICHD customized standard. For all standards, the screen-positive rate for SGA was at least 2-fold higher among fetuses delivered preterm than at term. Fourth, the screen-positive rate for LGA was 8.7% for the GROW standard, 9.2% for the PRB/NICHD customized standard, 10.8% for the WHO standard customized by fetal sex, and 12.3% for the NICHD African American standard. Finally, the highest overall agreement among standards was between the GROW and PRB/NICHD customized standards (Cohen's interrater agreement, kappa = 0.85). CONCLUSION: We developed a novel customized PRB/NICHD fetal growth standard from fetal data in an African American population without assuming proportionality of the effects of covariates, and without assuming that these effects are equal on all centiles of weight; we also provide an easy-to-use centile calculator. This standard classified more fetuses as being at risk for SGA compared to existing standards, especially among fetuses delivered preterm, but classified about the same number of LGA. The comparison among the 4 growth standards also revealed that the most important factor determining agreement among standards is whether they account for the same factors known to affect fetal growth.
引用
- Tarca AL, Romero R, Gudicha DW, et al. A new customized fetal growth standard for African American women: the PRB/NICHD Detroit study. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 29422207. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2017.12.229
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。