ACOG 委员会意见第 731 号摘要:团体产前保健
本意见比较个体产前保健与团体产前保健模式,指出个体产前保健仍是标准实践,团体产前保健在部分实践场景和患者人群中可能有益或更受偏好,证据提示患者产前知识更好、对分娩准备更充分、满意度更高且更常启动母乳喂养,无证据表明团体产前保健造成伤害,两种模式均需进一步研究以显示结局差异并识别最受益人群。
要点
- 个体产前保健仍是标准实践,团体产前保健在部分实践场景和患者人群中可能有益或更受偏好。
- 证据提示团体产前保健患者产前知识更好、对分娩准备更充分、满意度更高且更常启动母乳喂养。
- 无证据表明团体产前保健造成伤害,两种模式均需进一步研究以显示结局差异并识别最受益人群。
核心结论
- 团体产前保健在部分实践场景和患者人群中可能有益或更受偏好,但个体产前保健仍是标准实践。
- 证据提示团体产前保健患者产前知识更好、对分娩准备更充分、对保健满意度更高且更常启动母乳喂养。
- 无证据表明团体产前保健造成伤害,个体与团体保健模式均需进一步研究以显示结局差异并识别最受益人群。
研究设计与样本
- 美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)委员会意见,基于对个体产前保健与团体产前保健模式的比较与证据回顾。
主要发现
- 团体产前保健模式旨在改善患者教育并提供社会支持机会,同时保留个体产前保健的风险筛查和身体评估。
- 将需求相似的患者集中进行保健会面可增加教育部分的时间、提高效率并减少重复。
- 证据提示团体产前保健患者产前知识更好、对分娩准备更充分、对保健满意度更高且更常启动母乳喂养。
- 无证据表明团体产前保健造成伤害。
关键数值与推荐
- 个体产前保健仍是标准实践;团体产前保健在部分实践场景和患者人群中可能有益或更受偏好。
- 团体产前保健模式应保留个体产前保健的风险筛查和身体评估。
- 个体与团体保健模式均需进一步研究,以显示结局差异并识别最受益于特定保健模式的人群。
临床怎么用
- 个体产前保健仍是标准实践;团体产前保健在部分实践场景和患者人群中可能有益或更受偏好。
- 团体产前保健模式设计上应保留个体产前保健的风险筛查和身体评估,并增加教育与社会支持机会。
- 原文未据此给出进一步推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出个体与团体保健模式均需进一步研究,以显示结局差异并识别最受益于特定保健模式的人群。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Individual prenatal care is intended to prevent poor perinatal outcomes and provide education to women throughout pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpartum period through a series of one-on-one encounters between a woman and her obstetrician or other obstetric care provider. Concerns regarding increasing health care costs, health care provider availability, dissatisfaction with wait times, and the minimal opportunity for education and support associated with the individual care model have given rise to interest in alternative models of prenatal care. One alternative model, group prenatal care, may be beneficial or preferred for some practice settings and patient populations, although individual prenatal care remains standard practice. Group prenatal care models are designed to improve patient education and include opportunities for social support while maintaining the risk screening and physical assessment of individual prenatal care. Bringing patients with similar needs together for health care encounters increases the time available for the educational component of the encounter, improves efficiency, and reduces repetition. Evidence suggests patients have better prenatal knowledge, feel more ready for labor and delivery, are more satisfied with care in prenatal care groups, and initiate breastfeeding more often. There is no evidence that suggests that group prenatal care causes harm. Individual and group care models warrant additional study with a goal of demonstrating differences in outcomes and identifying populations that benefit most from specific care models.
引用
- ACOG Committee Opinion No. 731 Summary: Group Prenatal Care. Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 29470340. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000002526
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。