延时成像算法与第5天胚胎形态学选择用于移植:一项临床前验证研究
本研究在私立体外受精中心的前瞻性研究中,分析100个周期中428枚在EmbryoScope中培养的胚胎,评估已发表的延时成像算法之间以及算法与胚胎学家在选择最佳第5天移植胚胎时的一致性。七种算法中仅一对显示极好一致性(κ=0.867),多数算法与胚胎学家选择及实验室实际移植胚胎的一致性为差至中等(κ=0.315-0.802)。作者提出对测试算法在不同临床环境中适用性的担忧,强调临床使用前需进行适当的外部验证。
要点
- 七种已发表延时成像算法间一致性多数较差,仅一对极好(κ=0.867)。
- 算法与多数胚胎学家选择及实际移植胚胎的一致性为差至中等(κ=0.315-0.802)。
- 作者强调临床使用前需进行适当的外部验证。
核心结论
- 研究结果对测试的延时成像算法在不同临床环境中的适用性提出担忧,强调临床使用前需进行适当的外部验证。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,在私立体外受精中心进行,分析100个周期中428枚在EmbryoScope中培养的胚胎。
- 无干预措施。
主要发现
- 七种已发表算法分析的18对可能配对中,仅一对显示极好一致性(κ=0.867),一对显示好一致性(κ=0.725),四对显示中等一致性(κ=0.226-0.334),其余12对显示差一致性(κ=0.008-0.149)。
- 在最佳情况下,多数算法与多数(>5)胚胎学家选择为「最佳」的胚胎以及移植日实验室实际选择的胚胎之间的一致性为差至中等(κ=0.337-0.722;κ=0.315-0.802)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the agreement between published time-lapse algorithms in selecting the best day-5 embryo for transfer, as well as the agreement between these algorithms and embryologists. DESIGN: Prospective study. SETTING: Private in vitro fertilization center. PATIENT(S): Four hundred and twenty-eight embryos from 100 cycles cultured in the EmbryoScope. INTERVENTION(S): None. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Interalgorithm agreement as assessed by the Fleiss kappa coefficient. RESULT(S): Of seven published algorithms analyzed in this study, only one of the 18 possible pairs showed very good agreement (κ = 0.867); one pair showed good agreement (κ = 0.725), four pairs showed fair agreement (κ = 0.226-0.334), and the remaining 12 pairs showed poor agreement (κ = 0.008-0.149). Even in the best-case scenario, the majority of algorithms showed poor to moderate kappa scores (κ = 0.337-0.722) for the assessment of agreement between the embryo(s) selected as "best" by the algorithms and the embryo that was chosen by the majority (>5) of embryologists, as well as with the embryo that was actually selected in the laboratory on the day of transfer (κ = 0.315-0.802). CONCLUSION(S): The results of this study raise concerns as to whether the tested algorithms are applicable in different clinical settings, emphasizing the need for proper external validation before clinical use.
引用
- Storr A, Venetis C, Cooke S, et al. Time-lapse algorithms and morphological selection of day-5 embryos for transfer: a preclinical validation study. Fertil Steril. 2018. PMID: 29331237. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2017.10.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。