产科服务提供者对分娩方式的偏好及对无医学指征剖宫产的态度:一项横断面研究
该横断面研究在阿根廷两所公立和两所私立医院调查产科服务提供者对低风险女性分娩方式的偏好及对无医学指征剖宫产的态度。168名提供者参与(覆盖率89.8%),93.2%偏好阴道分娩,但66.7%愿意应要求行剖宫产,仅30.4%愿为自己或伴侣选择无医学指征剖宫产。私立机构提供者(OR 4.70,95%CI 1.19-18.62)和妇产科医生(OR 4.37,95%CI 1.58-12.09)更愿意应要求行剖宫产。
要点
- 93.2%的提供者偏好为无医学指征患者选择阴道分娩。
- 66.7%愿意应产妇要求行剖宫产,但仅30.4%愿为自己或伴侣选择无医学指征剖宫产。
- 私立机构提供者(OR 4.70)和妇产科医生(OR 4.37)更愿意应要求行剖宫产。
核心结论
- 尽管无医学指征剖宫产存在伦理争议,但观察到支持水平很高,尤其是私立机构提供者和妇产科医生,这与阿根廷高剖宫产率一致。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,在阿根廷两所公立和两所私立医院进行,纳入提供产前保健和/或分娩服务的妇产科医生和助产士。
- 年分娩量至少1000例的医院中提供者完成自填匿名调查,共168名提供者参与,覆盖率89.8%。
主要发现
- 93.2%的提供者偏好为无剖宫产医学指征的患者选择阴道分娩。
- 74.4%的提供者支持无剖宫产医学指征时患者选择分娩方式的权利,66.7%愿意应产妇要求行剖宫产。
- 仅30.4%的提供者会考虑为自己或个人伴侣的分娩选择无医学指征剖宫产。
- 多因素调整分析中,私立机构提供者较公立/两者兼有机构提供者或助产士更愿意应要求行剖宫产(OR 4.70,95%CI 1.19-18.62)。
- 妇产科医生较助产士更愿意应要求行剖宫产(OR 4.37,95%CI 1.58-12.09)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe obstetrical providers' delivery preferences and attitudes towards caesarean section without medical indication, including on maternal request, and to examine the association between provider characteristics and preferences/attitudes. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: Two public and two private hospitals in Argentina. POPULATION: Obstetrician-gynaecologists and midwives who provide prenatal care and/or labour/delivery services. METHODS: Providers in hospitals with at least 1000 births per year completed a self-administered, anonymous survey. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Provider delivery preference for low-risk women, perception of women's preferred delivery method, support for a woman's right to choose her delivery method and willingness to perform caesarean section on maternal request. RESULTS: 168 providers participated (89.8% coverage rate). Providers (93.2%) preferred a vaginal delivery for their patients in the absence of a medical indication for caesarean section. Whereas 74.4% of providers supported their patient's right to choose a delivery method in the absence of a medical indication for caesarean section and 66.7% would perform a caesarean section upon maternal request, only 30.4% would consider a non-medically indicated caesarean section for their own personal delivery or that of their partner. In multivariate adjusted analysis, providers in the private sector [odds ratio (OR) 4.70, 95% CI 1.19-18.62] and obstetrician-gynaecologists (OR 4.37, 95% CI 1.58-12.09) were more willing than either providers working in the public/both settings or midwives to perform a caesarean section on maternal request. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the ethical debate surrounding non-medically indicated caesarean sections, we observe very high levels of support, especially by providers in the private sector and obstetrician-gynaecologists, as aligned with the high caesarean section rates in Argentina. TWEETABLE ABSTRACT: Non-medically indicated c-section? 74% of sampled Argentine OB providers support women's right to choose.
引用
- Rivo JC, Amyx M, Pingray V, et al. Obstetrical providers' preferred mode of delivery and attitude towards non-medically indicated caesarean sections: a cross-sectional study. BJOG. 2018. PMID: 29325216. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.15122
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。