盆腔器官脱垂手术中保留子宫与子宫切除术的比较:系统综述、荟萃分析与临床实践指南
本系统综述检索MEDLINE、Cochrane和clinicaltrials.gov(截至2017年1月),纳入94项合格研究,其中53项比较保留子宫与子宫切除术的脱垂手术。总体证据质量中等,保留子宫的脱垂手术在手术时间、出血量和网片暴露风险方面优于类似路径联合子宫切除术,短期脱垂结局无显著差异。作者建议可为希望保留子宫的合适女性提供该选择。
要点
- 与子宫切除加网片骶骨固定术相比,骶骨子宫固定术可减少网片暴露、手术时间、出血量和手术费用,脱垂复发无差异。
- 与阴道子宫切除加子宫骶骨悬吊术相比,腹腔镜骶骨子宫固定术改善C点和阴道长度、估计出血量、术后疼痛和功能及住院时间。
- 经阴道网片子宫固定术较联合子宫切除术减少网片暴露、因网片暴露的再手术、术后出血和估计出血量,并改善后盆腔器官脱垂量化测量。
核心结论
- 保留子宫的脱垂手术与类似手术路径联合子宫切除术相比,改善手术时间、出血量和网片暴露风险,且不显著改变短期脱垂结局。
- 作者认为,可为希望保留子宫的合适女性在顶端脱垂修复中提供保留子宫作为选项。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索MEDLINE、Cochrane和clinicaltrials.gov数据库自建库至2017年1月。
- 纳入比较保留子宫的脱垂手术与涉及子宫切除术的脱垂手术的随机和非随机研究。
- 筛选4467篇摘要,确定94项合格研究,其中53项比较保留子宫与子宫切除术。
- 若3项或以上研究比较相同手术并报告相同结局,则进行荟萃分析。
- 总体证据质量中等。
主要发现
- 与子宫切除加网片骶骨固定术相比,保留子宫的骶骨子宫固定术减少网片暴露、手术时间、出血量和手术费用,脱垂复发无差异。
- 与阴道子宫切除加子宫骶骨悬吊术相比,腹腔镜骶骨子宫固定术改善盆腔器官脱垂量化检查的C点和阴道长度、估计出血量、术后疼痛和功能及住院时间,但开腹骶骨子宫固定术加重烦人的泌尿症状、手术时间和生活质量。
- 经阴道网片子宫固定术(对比联合子宫切除术)减少网片暴露、因网片暴露的再手术、术后出血和估计出血量,并改善后盆腔器官脱垂量化测量。
- 经阴道子宫骶骨或骶棘韧带子宫固定术或Manchester手术与阴道子宫切除加自体组织悬吊术相比,均显示改善手术时间和估计出血量,且保留子宫未加重脱垂结局。
- 显著缺乏术后超过3年的脱垂结局、保留子宫在 obliterative 手术中的作用以及保留子宫后子宫病理的长期风险数据。
关键数值与推荐
- 与子宫切除加网片骶骨固定术相比,骶骨子宫固定术减少网片暴露、手术时间、出血量和手术费用,脱垂复发无差异。
- 与阴道子宫切除加子宫骶骨悬吊术相比,腹腔镜骶骨子宫固定术改善C点和阴道长度、估计出血量、术后疼痛和功能及住院时间;开腹骶骨子宫固定术加重烦人的泌尿症状、手术时间和生活质量。
- 经阴道网片子宫固定术较联合子宫切除术减少网片暴露、因网片暴露的再手术、术后出血和估计出血量,并改善后盆腔器官脱垂量化测量。
- 经阴道子宫骶骨或骶棘韧带子宫固定术或Manchester手术与阴道子宫切除加自体组织悬吊术相比,均改善手术时间和估计出血量,且未加重脱垂结局。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,可为希望保留子宫的合适女性在顶端脱垂修复中提供保留子宫作为选项。
局限性
- 显著缺乏术后超过3年的脱垂结局数据。
- 显著缺乏保留子宫在 obliterative 手术中作用的数据。
- 显著缺乏保留子宫后子宫病理的长期风险数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We aimed to systematically review the literature on apical pelvic organ prolapse surgery with uterine preservation compared with prolapse surgeries including hysterectomy and provide evidence-based guidelines. DATA SOURCES: The sources for our data were MEDLINE, Cochrane, and clinicaltrials.gov databases from inception to January 2017. STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: We accepted randomized and nonrandomized studies of uterine-preserving prolapse surgeries compared with those involving hysterectomy. STUDY APPRAISAL AND SYNTHESIS METHODS: Studies were extracted for participant information, intervention, comparator, efficacy outcomes, and adverse events, and they were individually and collectively assessed for methodological quality. If 3 or more studies compared the same surgeries and reported the same outcome, a meta-analysis was performed. RESULTS: We screened 4467 abstracts and identified 94 eligible studies, 53 comparing uterine preservation to hysterectomy in prolapse surgery. Evidence was of moderate quality overall. Compared with hysterectomy plus mesh sacrocolpopexy, uterine preservation with sacrohysteropexy reduces mesh exposure, operative time, blood loss, and surgical cost without differences in prolapse recurrence. Compared with vaginal hysterectomy with uterosacral suspension, uterine preservation in the form of laparoscopic sacrohysteropexy improves the C point and vaginal length on the pelvic organ prolapse quantification exam, estimated blood loss, postoperative pain and functioning, and hospital stay, but open abdominal sacrohysteropexy worsens bothersome urinary symptoms, operative time, and quality of life. Transvaginal mesh hysteropexy (vs with hysterectomy) decreases mesh exposure, reoperation for mesh exposure, postoperative bleeding, and estimated blood loss and improves posterior pelvic organ prolapse quantification measurement. Transvaginal uterosacral or sacrospinous hysteropexy or the Manchester procedure compared with vaginal hysterectomy with native tissue suspension both showed improved operative time and estimated blood loss and no worsening of prolapse outcomes with uterine preservation. However, there is a significant lack of data on prolapse outcomes >3 years after surgery, the role of uterine preservation in obliterative procedures, and longer-term risk of uterine pathology after uterine preservation. CONCLUSION: Uterine-preserving prolapse surgeries improve operating time, blood loss, and risk of mesh exposure compared with similar surgical routes with concomitant hysterectomy and do not significantly change short-term prolapse outcomes. Surgeons may offer uterine preservation as an option to appropriate women who desire this choice during apical prolapse repair.
引用
- Meriwether KV, Antosh DD, Olivera CK, et al. Uterine preservation vs hysterectomy in pelvic organ prolapse surgery: a systematic review with meta-analysis and clinical practice guidelines. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 29353031. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2018.01.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。