重复植入失败处于统计学、临床与过度诊断的十字路口
该文基于数学模型分析重复植入失败(RIF)常用定义(三次完成 IVF 周期后未获临床妊娠)的误诊问题。假设 IVF 成功率恒为 30%、RIF 为二分状态且患病率 10%,三次和六次周期后预期累积妊娠机会分别为 59% 和 79%,RIF 诊断假阳性率分别为 75% 和 51%。提高 IVF 成功率或 RIF 患病率可降低假阳性率但幅度有限。
要点
- 常用 RIF 定义为三次完成 IVF 周期后未获临床妊娠。
- 假设 IVF 成功率 30%、RIF 患病率 10% 时,三次周期后累积妊娠机会 59%,假阳性率 75%。
- 六次周期后累积妊娠机会 79%,假阳性率 51%。
核心结论
- 基于三次失败尝试的常用 RIF 定义在预后良好的标准人群中导致过度诊断,并可能引起过度治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 数学模型研究,基于以下主要假设:IVF 成功率恒定并设为 30%;RIF 被设定为二分状态(是或否),患病率为 10%。
主要发现
- 三次周期后预期累积妊娠机会为 59%,RIF 诊断假阳性率为 75%。
- 六次周期后预期累积妊娠机会为 79%,RIF 诊断假阳性率为 51%。
- 提高 IVF 成功率或 RIF 患病率可降低假阳性诊断率,但幅度有限。
关键数值与推荐
- RIF 最常用定义为三次完成 IVF 周期后未获得临床妊娠。
- 模型假设 IVF 成功率恒定为 30%,RIF 患病率为 10%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The most common definition of repeated implantation failure (RIF) is the failure to obtain a clinical pregnancy after three completed IVF cycles. This definition, however, may lead to misuse of the diagnosis. To disentangle this, we set up a mathematical model based on the following main assumptions: rate of success of IVF constant and set at 30%; and RIF postulated to be a dichotomous condition (yes or no) with a prevalence of 10%. On this basis, the expected cumulative chance of pregnancy after three and six cycles was 59% and 79%, respectively. Consequently, the false-positive rate of a diagnosis of RIF is 75% and 51%, respectively. Increasing the rate of success of IVF or the prevalence of RIF lowers but does not make unremarkable the rate of false-positive diagnoses. Overall, this model shows that the commonly used definition of RIF based on three failed attempts in a standard population with good prognosis leads to over-diagnosis and, potentially, to over-treatments.
引用
- Somigliana E, Vigano P, Busnelli A, et al. Repeated implantation failure at the crossroad between statistics, clinics and over-diagnosis. Reprod Biomed Online. 2017. PMID: 29102484. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2017.09.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。