文献速递产科

疾病严重程度对华盛顿州剖宫产率的影响

Effect of severity of illness on cesarean delivery rates in Washington State.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2017-06-27

这项横断面分析纳入华盛顿州2010至2014财年287,031例分娩的医院汇总数据,用All Patient Refined Diagnosis Related Groups分类系统计算入院疾病严重度评分。医院入院疾病严重度评分与初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率在所有财年相关(R² 0.38-0.58,P<.001),约50%的医院间剖宫产率变异与入院疾病严重度相关。

要点

  • 医院入院疾病严重度评分与初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率在所有财年相关(R² 0.38-0.58,P<.001)。
  • 随入院疾病严重度升高,初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率也升高,且该模式在各财年持续存在。
  • 约50%的医院间初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率变异似乎与入院疾病严重度相关。

核心结论

  • 入院疾病严重度评分与华盛顿州各医院初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率强相关,约50%的医院间变异似乎与入院疾病严重度相关。
  • 尽管全州剖宫产率下降,该关系随时间持续存在,提示患者疾病严重度可能继续导致医院间剖宫产率变异。
  • 作者认为确定最佳剖宫产率时应考虑患者疾病严重度,高疾病严重度医院因承担区域需求而可能有高剖宫产率,以任意基准要求这些中心可能危及支持区域安全网机构所需的资金。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面分析,分析华盛顿州所有非军队医院(每年≥100例分娩)在2010至2014联邦财年的医院层面汇总数据,共287,031例分娩。
  • 数据来自Washington State Comprehensive Hospital Abstract Reporting System,包含来自医院计费系统的住院人口学、诊断、操作和出院信息。
  • 使用All Patient Refined Diagnosis Related Groups分类系统将年龄、入院诊断和操作代码转换为患者层面入院疾病严重度评分,并计算无剖宫产史的足月单胎头位人群每个财年的医院层面平均入院疾病严重度评分。
  • 使用线性回归评估医院入院疾病严重度与初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率之间的关联,计算Pearson相关系数,并比较每个财年的回归线斜率和95%置信区间。

主要发现

  • 医院在分娩量、护理级别和华盛顿州内地理位置方面多样。
  • 医院汇总入院疾病严重度评分在所有财年与初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率相关(R² 0.38-0.58,P<.001)。
  • 在研究期间的每一年,随着入院疾病严重度升高,初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率也升高。
  • 回归线斜率在研究期间下降,提示全州初次足月单胎头位剖宫产率下降发生在疾病严重度整个范围内。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为确定最佳剖宫产率时应考虑患者疾病严重度。
  • 作者认为高疾病严重度医院因承担区域需求而可能有高剖宫产率,以任意基准要求这些中心可能危及支持区域安全网机构所需的资金。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Hospitals and providers are increasingly held accountable for their cesarean delivery rates. In the perinatal quality improvement arena, there is vigorous debate about whether all hospitals can be held to the same benchmark for an acceptable cesarean rate regardless of patient acuity. However, the causes of variation in hospital cesarean delivery rates are not well understood. OBJECTIVE: We sought to evaluate the association and temporal trends between severity of illness at admission and the primary term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rate among hospitals in Washington State. We hypothesized that hospitals with higher patient acuity would have higher cesarean delivery rates and that this pattern would persist over time. STUDY DESIGN: In this cross-sectional analysis, we analyzed aggregate hospital-level data for all nonmilitary hospitals in Washington State with ≥100 deliveries/y during federal fiscal years 2010 through 2014 (287,031 deliveries). Data were obtained from the Washington State Comprehensive Hospital Abstract Reporting System, which includes inpatient demographic, diagnosis, procedure, and discharge information derived from hospital billing systems. Age, admission diagnoses and procedure codes were converted to patient-level admission severity-of-illness scores using the All Patient Refined Diagnosis Related Groups classification system. This system is widely used throughout the United States to adjust hospital data for severity of illness. Mean admission hospital-level severity-of-illness scores were calculated for each fiscal year among the term singleton vertex population with no history of cesarean delivery. We used linear regression to evaluate the association between hospital admission severity of illness and the primary term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rate, calculated Pearson correlation coefficients, and compared regression line slopes and 95% confidence intervals for each fiscal year. RESULTS: Hospitals were diverse with respect to delivery volume, level of care, and geographic location within Washington. Hospital aggregate admission severity-of-illness score correlated with primary term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rate in all fiscal years (R2 0.38-0.58, P < .001). For every year in the study interval, as admission severity of illness increased so did the primary term singleton vertex cesarean rate. The slope of the regression line decreased during the study interval, suggesting that statewide decrease in primary term singleton vertex cesarean rate occurred across the range of severity of illness. CONCLUSION: Admission severity-of-illness score is strongly associated with the primary term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rate among hospitals in Washington State. Approximately 50% of variation in hospital primary term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rates appeared to be related to admission severity of illness. This relationship persisted over time despite a statewide decrease in cesarean delivery, suggesting that patient acuity will likely continue to contribute to hospital variation in cesarean delivery rates despite perinatal quality improvement efforts. The major implication of this study is that patient acuity should be considered when determining optimal cesarean delivery rates. High-acuity hospitals are likely to have high cesarean rates because they provide a specific role in serving regional needs. To hold these centers to an arbitrary benchmark may jeopardize the funding necessary to support regional safety net institutions.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hitti J, Walker S, Benedetti TJ, et al. Effect of severity of illness on cesarean delivery rates in Washington State. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28666693. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2017.06.020

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。