美国疾病控制与预防中心报告的辅助生殖技术活产率可能误导公众
研究比较2014年美国疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)排除胚胎或卵母细胞冻存的活产率计算法与纳入所有周期的活产率计算法,发现27家冻存周期占比超过40%的诊所采用CDC法时活产率高于其他94%的诊所(33.1%对31.1%),而纳入冻存周期重算后活产率低于其他诊所(15.5%对26.6%),两种方法的活产率差异随冻存周期比例增加可达4.5倍,可能误导公众。
要点
- 2014年CDC报告将184,527个自体辅助生殖技术周期中的35,406个(19.2%)涉及胚胎或卵母细胞冻存的周期排除在活产率计算之外。
- 27家(458家中的6%)诊所报告超过40%的自体周期涉及冻存,这些诊所合计完成全美12%的辅助生殖技术周期。
- 按CDC法,这27家诊所活产率为33.1%,高于其他94%诊所的31.1%;纳入冻存周期重算后,活产率为15.5%,低于其他诊所的26.6%。
核心结论
- 按CDC方法计算活产率时,冻存周期比例高的诊所活产率高于其他诊所(33.1%对31.1%),纳入冻存周期重算后则低于其他诊所(15.5%对26.6%),两种方法差异随冻存周期比例增加可达4.5倍,可能误导公众。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究计算2014年所有使用自体卵母细胞患者的总诊所活产率,采用两种方法:纳入所有启动的辅助生殖技术周期,或按CDC做法排除冻存周期。
主要发现
- 2014年CDC报告从活产率计算中排除了184,527个自体辅助生殖技术周期中的35,406个(19.2%),这些周期涉及胚胎或卵母细胞冻存。
- 27家(458家中的6%)诊所报告超过40%的自体周期涉及冻存,这些诊所合计完成全美12%的辅助生殖技术周期。
- 按CDC方法,这27家诊所的活产率为33.1%,高于其他94%诊所的31.1%。
- 纳入冻存周期重算后,这27家诊所的活产率为15.5%,低于其他94%诊所的26.6%。
- 两种方法计算的活产率随各诊所冻存周期比例的增加而日益分歧,差异可达4.5倍。
局限性
- 本分析的主要局限性是CDC报告未区分涉及长期冻存胚胎或卵母细胞以保存生育力的周期与涉及短期胚胎冻存的周期。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The Centre for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) publicly reports assisted reproductive technology live-birth rates (LBR) for each US fertility clinic under legal mandate. The 2014 CDC report excluded 35,406 of 184,527 (19.2%) autologous assisted reproductive technology cycles that involved embryo or oocyte banking from LBR calculations. This study calculated 2014 total clinic LBR for all patients utilizing autologous oocytes two ways: including all initiated assisted reproductive technology cycles or excluding banking cycles, as done by the CDC. The main limitation of this analysis is the CDC report did not differentiate between cycles involving long-term banking of embryos or oocytes for fertility preservation from cycles involving short-term embryo banking. Twenty-seven of 458 (6%) clinics reported over 40% of autologous cycles involved banking, collectively performing 12% of all US assisted reproductive technology cycles. LBR in these outlier clinics calculated by the CDC method, was higher than the other 94% of clinics (33.1% versus 31.1%). However, recalculated LBR including banking cycles in the outlier clinics was lower than the other 94% of clinics (15.5% versus 26.6%). LBR calculated by the two methods increasingly diverged based on proportion of banking cycles performed by each clinic reaching 4.5-fold, thereby, potentially misleading the public.
引用
- Kushnir VA, Choi J, Darmon SK, et al. CDC-reported assisted reproductive technology live-birth rates may mislead the public. Reprod Biomed Online. 2017. PMID: 28578895. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2017.05.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。