直接腹腔镜穿刺器插入:九例诉讼案件的教训
本文回顾了1990年至2015年加拿大九例与直接穿刺器插入(DTI)相关的诉讼案件,其中肠管损伤七例、大血管损伤两例。血管损伤导致一例永久性脑损伤、一例近乎截肢;肠管损伤均在术后3天内出现腹膜炎表现,但仅两例及时处理,延迟处理者出现回肠造口/结肠造口、多次手术及一例死亡,且所有延迟处理的案件诉讼结果均有利于原告。
要点
- DTI相关大血管损伤可导致永久性脑损伤或近乎截肢,诉讼均有利于原告。
- 肠管损伤均在术后3天内出现腹膜炎表现,但仅两例及时处理。
- 延迟剖腹探查导致回肠造口/结肠造口、多次手术及一例死亡,诉讼均有利于原告。
核心结论
- 使用DTI技术进行腹腔镜初次腹膜通路时,若累及大血管或肠管损伤处理延迟,意外腹腔内损伤可能很严重,导致显著不良临床并发症,并可能引发更高诉讼且诉讼结果更有利于原告。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为病例系列(加拿大工作组分类II-2),纳入1990年至2015年由第一作者(G.A.V.)在加拿大复核的九例诉讼案件医疗与法律记录。
- 样本为九例诉讼案件,其中肠管损伤七例、大血管损伤两例。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄31岁(范围14-65岁),平均体重指数25 kg/m2(范围20-35 kg/m2)。
- 腹腔镜指征包括诊断性4例、腹腔镜辅助阴式子宫切除术3例、盆腔包块1例、腹腔镜胆囊切除术1例。
- DTI使用10-mm穿刺器(5个带护套、1个可重复使用、3个未知)。
- 损伤包括小肠4例、结肠3例、大血管2例;血管损伤导致1例永久性脑损伤、另1例近乎截肢,两例诉讼均有利于原告。
- 所有肠管损伤均在术后3天内出现腹膜炎体征和症状(术后第1天5例、第2天1例、第3天1例),但仅2例被处理并补救,临床和医疗法律结果良好。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To report circumstances and clinical and medicolegal outcomes of 9 litigated cases associated with direct trocar insertion (DTI) injuries to the bowel (7 cases) and major vessel (2 cases) during primary laparoscopic access. DESIGN: A case series from 1990 through 2015 (Canadian Task Force Classification II-2). PATIENTS: Nine litigated cases. INTERVENTIONS: A retrospective review of medical and legal records of litigated cases in Canada reviewed by the primary author (G.A.V.). MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The average and range of age and body mass index of the women were 31 years (range, 14-65 years) and 25 kg/m2 (range, 20-35 kg/m2), respectively. Indications for laparoscopy included diagnostic (4), laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy (3), pelvic mass (1), and laparoscopic cholecystectomy (1). DTI was performed with 10-mm trocars (5 shielded, 1 reusable, and 3 unknown). Two complications were experienced by patients of the same male surgeon (cases 2 and 9). Injuries included the small bowel (4 cases), colon (3 cases), and major vessel (2 cases). Vascular injuries resulted in permanent brain damage in 1 and near loss of limb in the other; litigation was favorable to the plaintiff in both cases. All bowel injuries presented with signs and symptoms of peritonitis within 3 postoperative days (PODs) (5 patients on POD 1, 1 patient on POD 2, and 1 patient on POD 3); however, only 2 cases were acted upon and remedied with favorable clinical and medicolegal outcomes. A delayed exploratory laparotomy resulted in significant adverse clinical outcomes (ileostomy/colostomy in 4 patients, multiple surgeries in 7 patients, and 1 death), and in all delayed actions, the medicolegal outcomes were favorable to the plaintiff. CONCLUSION: During laparoscopic primary peritoneal access using the DTI technique, inadvertent intra-abdominal injury may be significant when major vessels are involved and when intervention is delayed in bowel injuries. These result in significant adverse clinical complications and may provoke higher litigation with more favorable outcomes for the plaintiff.
引用
- Vilos GA, Ternamian A, Vilos AG, et al. Direct Laparoscopic Trocar Insertion: Lessons Learned from Nine Litigated Cases. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28576693. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2017.05.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。