专业学会推荐意见对女性常规盆腔检查意愿的影响
本研究从2家女性诊所招募452名21-65岁女性进行宫颈癌筛查访谈,其中262人未获学会推荐信息,190人随机阅读美国内科医师学会(ACP)或美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)声明摘要。阅读ACP反对常规盆腔检查声明的女性选择检查的比例为39%(36/93;校正OR 0.12;95%CI 0.06-0.21),低于第一阶段参照的79%(208/262);阅读ACOG声明的比例为82%(80/97;校正OR 1.37;95%CI 0.69-2.70)。94%(179/190)认为检查前应讨论潜在获益与危害。
要点
- 阅读ACP反对常规盆腔检查声明的女性选择检查的比例为39%(36/93;校正OR 0.12;95%CI 0.06-0.21),低于第一阶段参照的79%(208/262)。
- 阅读ACOG推荐常规盆腔检查声明的女性选择检查的比例为82%(80/97;校正OR 1.37;95%CI 0.69-2.70),与参照比例相近。
- 94%(179/190)认为盆腔检查前应讨论潜在获益与危害。
核心结论
- 提供专业学会反对常规盆腔检查的推荐意见可大幅降低女性进行该检查的意愿。
- 需要教育材料以确保女性知情偏好和价值观反映在盆腔检查决策中。
研究设计与样本
- 从2家女性诊所招募452名21-65岁女性参与50分钟面对面访谈,访谈内容涉及宫颈癌筛查并包含两阶段盆腔检查相关研究。
- 第一阶段262名女性未获学会推荐信息即被询问检查意愿。
- 第二阶段190名女性随机阅读ACP或ACOG声明摘要后接受访谈。
主要发现
- 第一阶段79%(208/262)表示若有选择会希望进行常规检查,作为参照。
- 第二阶段ACOG组82%(80/97)有该意愿(校正OR 1.37;95%CI 0.69-2.70),与参照相近。
- ACP组39%(36/93)表示会选择检查(校正OR 0.12;95%CI 0.06-0.21),低于参照。
- 总体94%(179/190)认为检查前应讨论潜在获益与危害。
关键数值与推荐
- 美国内科医师学会(ACP)强烈推荐反对对无症状、非妊娠女性进行盆腔检查,理由为有伤害证据(假阳性检测、不必要手术)且无获益证据。
- 美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)基于专家意见推荐从21岁起对无症状女性进行盆腔检查。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The American College of Physicians strongly recommends against performing pelvic examinations in asymptomatic, nonpregnant women, citing evidence of harm (false-positive testing, unnecessary surgery) and no evidence of benefit. In contrast, the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommends pelvic examinations in asymptomatic women beginning at age 21 years, citing expert opinion. OBJECTIVE: We sought to evaluate if providing women with professional societies' conflicting statements about pelvic examinations (recommendations and rationales) would influence their desire for a routine examination. STUDY DESIGN: We recruited 452 women ages 21-65 years from 2 women's clinics to participate in a 50-minute face-to-face interview about cervical cancer screening that included a 2-phase study related to pelvic examinations. In the first phase, 262 women were asked about their desire for the examination without being provided information about professional societies' recommendations. In the second phase, 190 women were randomized to review summaries of the American College of Physicians or American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists statement followed by an interview. RESULTS: First-phase participants served as the referent: 79% (208/262) indicated they would want a routine examination if given a choice. In the second phase, a similar percentage of women randomized to the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists summary had this desire (82%: 80/97; adjusted odds ratio, 1.37; 95% confidence interval, 0.69-2.70). Women randomized to the American College of Physicians summary, however, were less likely to indicate they would opt for an examination (39%: 36/93; adjusted odds ratio, 0.12; 95% confidence interval, 0.06-0.21). Overall, 94% (179/190) believed the potential benefits and harms should be discussed prior to the examination. CONCLUSION: Providing women with a professional society's recommendation advising against routine pelvic examinations substantially reduced their desire to have one. Educational materials are needed to ensure women's informed preferences and values are reflected in decisions about pelvic examinations.
引用
- Sawaya GF, Smith-McCune KK, Gregorich SE, et al. Effect of professional society recommendations on women's desire for a routine pelvic examination. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28528899. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2017.05.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。